Stacked Intelligent Metasurface Assisted Multiuser Communications: From a Rate Fairness Perspective

Junjie Fang, Chao Zhang, Jiancheng An, Hongwen Yu, Qingqing Wu, Mérouane Debbah, Chau Yuen

TL;DR

This paper explores the potential of Stacked Intelligent Metasurfaces (SIM)—a multi-layered evolution of reconfigurable surfaces—to tackle the "rate fairness" problem in 6G multiuser networks. By developing specialized algorithms to maximize the minimum user rate and the geometric mean of rates, the authors show that SIM can achieve near-perfect fairness and match the performance of traditional digital beamforming while consuming significantly less power.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the push toward 6G, researchers are looking for ways to support massive data rates without the massive power bills associated with traditional "Massive MIMO" (which requires expensive radio frequency chains for every antenna).

While single-layer Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) have been proposed as a low-cost alternative, they often lack the "degrees of freedom" needed to precisely control complex wave propagation. Furthermore, most existing research focuses on maximizing the Sum-Rate (SR)—the total speed of the whole system. The problem? SR optimization often ignores users with poor signals (like those at the edge of a cell), leading to a "rich get richer" scenario where some users get zero service.

The authors address this by investigating SIM-assisted multiuser communications from a fairness perspective, ensuring that every user in a network receives a reliable and equitable data rate.

Methods

The authors model a system where a Base Station (BS) is integrated with a SIM consisting of $L$ layers of programmable meta-atoms. Unlike a single-layer surface, the SIM performs "holographic precoding" in the electromagnetic wave domain as the signal passes through its layers.

To solve the resulting complex optimization problems, they propose two distinct algorithmic frameworks:

  1. For Max-Min Rate (MR): To ensure absolute fairness (where the goal is to boost the slowest user), they use a Consensus ADMM (Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers) approach. This breaks a massive, "non-convex" problem into smaller, parallelizable sub-problems that have simple, closed-form solutions.
  2. For Geometric Mean of Rates (GMR): To strike a balance between total system speed and individual fairness, they employ an Alternating Optimization (AO) algorithm. This method linearizes the objective function to decouple the variables, making it computationally efficient.

Datasets

As is standard for theoretical communications research, the paper relies on sophisticated numerical simulations rather than static datasets.

  • Channel Modeling: They use the Rayleigh-Sommerfeld diffraction theory to model how waves propagate between the layers of the SIM.
  • Environment: A 3D simulation environment at 28 GHz (Ka-band) with users randomly distributed within a 50m radius cluster.
  • Benchmarks: The proposed SIM algorithms are compared against existing single-layer RHS models, MSINR (Maximum Signal-to-Interference-plus-Noise Ratio) methods, and traditional multi-antenna digital beamforming.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Lens" Effect: Think of a SIM as a custom-designed, programmable lens for radio waves. By stacking layers, you gain much finer control over the wavefront, allowing the system to "steer" nulls toward interference and peaks toward users more effectively than a single-layer surface.
  • Fairness vs. Throughput: The paper highlights a crucial trade-off. MR maximization is the "great equalizer," resulting in almost zero variance between user speeds. SR maximization is the "speed king" but leaves some users behind. GMR maximization emerges as the "Goldilocks" solution—providing a Pareto-optimal balance.
  • Diminishing Returns of Layers: The simulation shows that the jump from 1 layer to 2 layers provides a massive performance boost. However, as you add more layers (moving toward 8), the marginal gains decrease, suggesting that a 3-to-4 layer SIM might be the "sweet spot" for practical deployment.

Key Results

  • Near-Perfect Fairness: Under the MR optimization, the standard deviation of user rates was effectively zero, proving the algorithm's ability to enforce strict fairness.
  • Outperforming the State-of-the-Art: The proposed algorithms outperformed existing SIM-related works (like those based on MSINR) in both minimum rate and total sum-rate.
  • SIM vs. Digital Beamforming: A SIM with 6 layers (100 atoms per layer) achieved the same performance as a 16-antenna digital beamforming system. Crucially, the SIM setup consumed only 20.1W, compared to the 26.1W required by the digital system—a significant energy saving for 6G infrastructure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • CSI Requirements: The study assumes "perfect instantaneous Channel State Information (CSI)." In the real world, estimating the channel through multiple layers of a metasurface is notoriously difficult and remains a significant hurdle.
  • Hardware Constraints: The model assumes meta-atoms can shift phase perfectly. Real-world hardware has "quantized" phase shifts (e.g., only 2 or 4 possible states) and inherent phase noise, which could degrade performance.
  • User Mobility: The current work looks at a snapshot of stationary users. Future research needs to address how these multi-layer "lenses" can adapt in real-time to users moving at high speeds.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stacked intelligent metasurface (SIM) extends the concept of single-layer reconfigurable holographic surfaces (RHS) by incorporating a multi-layered structure, thereby providing enhanced control over electromagnetic wave propagation and improved signal processing capabilities. This study investigates the potential of SIM in enhancing the rate fairness in multiuser downlink systems by addressing two key optimization problems: maximizing the minimum rate (MR) and maximizing the geometric mean of rates (GMR). The former strives to enhance the minimum user rate, thereby ensuring fairness among users, while the latter relaxes fairness requirements to strike a better trade-off between user fairness and system sum-rate (SR). For the MR maximization, we adopt a consensus alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM)-based approach, which decomposes the approximated problem into sub-problems with closed-form solutions. For GMR maximization, we develop an alternating optimization (AO)-based algorithm that also yields closed-form solutions and can be seamlessly adapted for SR maximization. Numerical results validate the effectiveness and convergence of the proposed algorithms. Comparative evaluations show that MR maximization ensures near-perfect fairness, while GMR maximization balances fairness and system SR. Furthermore, the two proposed algorithms respectively outperform existing related works in terms of MR and SR performance. Lastly, SIM with lower power consumption achieves performance comparable to that of multi-antenna digital beamforming.
BibTeX
@article{fang2025stacked,
  author = {Junjie Fang and Chao Zhang and Jiancheng An and Hongwen Yu and Qingqing Wu and Mérouane Debbah and Chau Yuen},
  title = {{Stacked Intelligent Metasurface Assisted Multiuser Communications: From a Rate Fairness Perspective}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2025.3636089},
}

Loading related content...

Figure