Stability and convergence of a conservative finite difference scheme for the modified Hunter–Saxton equation

Shun Sato

Introduction

The modified Hunter–Saxton (mHS) equation serves as a critical mathematical model for describing the propagation of short capillary-gravity waves. Unlike standard evolutionary partial differential equations (PDEs) where the rate of change is explicitly defined (e.g., $u_t = f(u)$), the mHS equation is characterized by a mixed derivative term ($u_{tx}$). This structural complexity renders the equation "implicit," making numerical approximations significantly more challenging to solve and analyze.

While recent mathematical progress has established the local well-posedness of the mHS equation, the behavior of its solutions remains volatile. Specifically, solutions are known to undergo "blow-up," where derivatives become infinite in finite time even while the wave height remains bounded. Prior to this work, a rigorous proof of convergence for any numerical scheme applied to the mHS equation was absent from the literature. This paper addresses this gap by developing a conservative finite difference scheme and providing the first formal proof of its stability and convergence.

Methodology

Conservative Finite Difference Scheme

The author constructs a numerical framework designed to be "conservative," meaning the algorithm is engineered to preserve the physical invariants of the continuous system—such as energy and mass—at the discrete level. This preservation is not merely for physical accuracy but serves as a mathematical foundation for ensuring numerical stability.

Key components of the methodology include:

  • Discrete Operators: The scheme utilizes forward, backward, and central difference operators to approximate spatial derivatives on a periodic grid.
  • Moore-Penrose Inverses: To resolve the difficulties posed by the mixed derivative $u_{tx}$, the author employs the Moore-Penrose generalized inverse of the spatial difference operators. This transformation allows the implicit PDE to be reformulated into a system that can be solved iteratively.
  • Invariant Preservation: The scheme is specifically designed to maintain two discrete invariants, $\mathcal{F}_d$ and $\mathcal{H}_d$. These invariants provide the necessary bounds to prevent the numerical solution from growing uncontrollably.
  • Fixed-Point Iteration: Given the nonlinear nature of the resulting discrete equations, a contraction mapping approach is implemented to guarantee the existence and uniqueness of a numerical solution at each temporal step.

Theoretical Analysis

Stability and Convergence

The primary contribution of this research is the rigorous proof of the scheme's convergence. The author demonstrates that the global error of the scheme is $O(\Delta x^2 + \Delta t^2)$, indicating second-order accuracy in both space and time. This implies that reducing the grid spacing and time step by half results in a fourfold reduction in error.

Furthermore, the scheme is proven to be stable in the $L^\infty$ (uniform) norm. The proof reveals that the preservation of nonlinear invariants is the essential mechanism that stabilizes the computation. Stability is maintained provided the time step is appropriately scaled relative to the grid size, specifically $\Delta t = O(\Delta x)$.

Numerical Experiments

To validate the theoretical findings, the method was tested using synthetic initial conditions: $$u_0(x) = a \sin(2\pi x) - (\pi a)^2$$

By varying the parameter $a$, the author evaluated two distinct physical regimes:

  1. Smooth Propagation ($a = 1/100$): The experiments confirmed the predicted second-order convergence rate for smooth solutions.
  2. Blow-up Scenarios ($a = 1/10$): The scheme successfully captured the development of sharp fronts. A notable observation from the numerical data is a hierarchy in wave breaking: the second derivative ($u_{xx}$) blows up significantly earlier (at $T \approx 2.4$) than the first derivative ($u_x$), suggesting the wave sharpens into a cusp before total breakdown.

Conclusion and Future Work

This paper establishes a rigorous numerical framework for the modified Hunter–Saxton equation, proving that conservative schemes can reliably solve equations with mixed derivatives. However, certain limitations remain. The convergence proof assumes a high degree of smoothness in the exact solution ($C^7$ class), which is violated as the system approaches a blow-up point.

Future research may focus on providing a formal theoretical justification for the observed multi-stage blow-up behavior. Additionally, the author suggests that the use of Moore-Penrose inverses and invariant-preserving operators could be extended to other complex PDEs, such as the short pulse equation or the Ostrovsky equation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The modified Hunter--Saxton equation models the propagation of short capillary-gravity waves. As it involves a mixed derivative, its initial value problem on the periodic domain is much more complicated than the standard evolutionary equations. Although its local well-posedness has recently been proved, the behavior of its solution is yet to be investigated. In this paper, to develop a reliable numerical method for this problem, we derive a conservative finite difference scheme. Then, we rigorously prove not only its stability in the sense of the uniform norm but also its uniform convergence to sufficiently smooth exact solutions. Discrete conservation laws are used to overcome the difficulty due to the mixed derivative.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sato2018stability,
  author = {Shun Sato},
  title = {{Stability and convergence of a conservative finite difference scheme for the modified Hunter–Saxton equation}},
  booktitle = {BIT},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1007/s10543-018-0726-9},
}

Loading related content...

Figure