Sporadic and Exceptional

Yang‐Hui He, John McKay

Abstract We study the web of correspondences linking the exceptional Lie algebras $E_{8,7,6}$ and the sporadic simple groups Monster, Baby and the largest Fischer group. This is done via the investigation of classical enumerative problems on del Pezzo surfaces in relation to the cusps of certain subgroups of $PSL(2,R)$ for the relevant McKay-Thompson series in Generalized Moonshine. We also study Conway's sporadic group, as well as its association with the Horrocks-Mumford bundle.

Introduction

In the landscape of modern mathematics, a profound distinction exists between "regular" structures—those belonging to infinite families—and "exceptional" ones, which exist as unique, isolated anomalies. Among the most celebrated of these are the Exceptional Lie Algebras ($E_6, E_7, E_8$) and the 26 Sporadic Simple Groups, the largest of which is the Monster group ($\mathbb{M}$).

While the "Monstrous Moonshine" phenomenon established a deep link between the Monster group and modular functions (specifically the $j$-invariant), the fundamental reason for these connections remains one of the great mysteries of the field. This research seeks to expand the Moonshine bridge by integrating a third pillar: Classical Enumerative Geometry. We aim to demonstrate that the Monster, Baby Monster, and Fischer groups are not merely isolated algebraic objects but are intricately woven into the geometry of del Pezzo surfaces and the properties of modular curves.

The Web of Correspondences

The core of this work is the identification of a "web of correspondences" that links these disparate fields. This mapping suggests a unified structure underlying group theory, representation theory, and algebraic geometry, as illustrated in the following diagram:

A diagram illustrating the web of correspondences between exceptional Lie algebras, sporadic groups, and enumerative geometry.

Specifically, we strengthen a specific hierarchy of mappings:

  • $E_8 \leftrightarrow$ Monster ($\mathbb{M}$)
  • $E_7 \leftrightarrow$ Baby Monster ($\mathbb{B}$)
  • $E_6 \leftrightarrow$ Fischer Group ($Fi'_{24}$)

Methodology and Datasets

To explore these connections, we employ a comparative numerological approach using established mathematical classifications and computational tools:

  • The ATLAS of Finite Groups: Used as the definitive catalog for sporadic group properties and conjugacy classes.
  • Norton’s Database of Replicable Functions: A list of 616 candidate functions for Moonshine-type correspondences.
  • Computational Group Theory: We utilized GAP (Groups, Algorithms, and Programming) and MAGMA to navigate the massive character tables and centralizers of the sporadic groups.

We analyze the $q$-expansion coefficients of McKay-Thompson series associated with the 194 conjugacy classes of the Monster. A key metric in our analysis is the "cusp number"—the number of orbits of rational boundary points (cusps) under the action of modular subgroups. These algebraic results are then mapped onto 19th-century enumerative problems, such as counting bitangents on quartic curves and tritangents on sextic curves.

Key Findings and Numerical Coincidences

Our investigation revealed several striking numerical identities that suggest a deep, yet-to-be-explained unity between these fields:

  1. Monster Group Sums: The sum of cusp numbers across the 172 rational conjugacy classes of the Monster is exactly 360. This matches three times the 120 tritangent planes of Bring’s curve. Furthermore, the sum of their squares is 1024 ($2^{10}$).
  2. Baby Monster and $E_7$: For the group $2.\mathbb{B}$, the sum of cusp numbers over distinct McKay-Thompson series is 448 ($2^3 \times 56$). Notably, 56 is the dimension of the fundamental representation of $E_7$.
  3. Ogg's List and Genus Zero: For the 15 congruence groups defining the primes dividing the Monster's order (Ogg's list), the sum of their cusp numbers is 56, again matching the fundamental representation of $E_7$.
  4. The Horrocks-Mumford Connection: We established that the symmetry group of the Horrocks-Mumford bundle ($G_{HM}$), a unique rank-2 vector bundle on $\mathbb{P}^4$, is the centralizer for exactly one conjugacy class (5C) of exactly one sporadic group: Conway’s $Co_1$.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While these results are currently phenomenological and "numerologically intriguing," they point toward a fundamental mystery in the fabric of mathematics. The authors are transparent about the fact that these correspondences are currently fundamentally mysterious.

Future research will focus on moving beyond numerical coincidences to find a unified theory—perhaps through vertex operator algebras or physical string theory models—that explains why these disparate structures are so deeply intertwined. Additionally, we aim to extend the cusp-sum analysis to the remaining 23 sporadic groups and investigate if similar patterns exist for modular groups with genus greater than zero.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the web of correspondences linking the exceptional Lie algebras $E_{8,7,6}$ and the sporadic simple groups Monster, Baby and the largest Fischer group. This is done via the investigation of classical enumerative problems on del Pezzo surfaces in relation to the cusps of certain subgroups of $PSL(2,R)$ for the relevant McKay-Thompson series in Generalized Moonshine. We also study Conway's sporadic group, as well as its association with the Horrocks-Mumford bundle.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2024sporadic,
  author = {Yang‐Hui He and John McKay},
  title = {{Sporadic and Exceptional}},
  booktitle = {inSTEMM},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.56725/instemm.v1is1.8},
}

Loading related content...

Figure