Spontaneous modulations of high frequency cortical activity

Hiroya Ono, Masaki Sonoda, Brian H. Silverstein, Kaori Sonoda, Takafumi Kubota, Aimée F. Luat, Robert Rothermel, Sandeep Sood, Eishi Asano

TL;DR

This study presents the first whole-brain, high-resolution (5ms temporal resolution) dynamic atlas of neural activity during spontaneous eye movements (saccades). They found that specific patterns of high-gamma brain activity preceding and following saccades can predict saccade direction and duration, and remarkably, can accurately localize the primary visual cortex, offering a potential new tool for epilepsy surgery planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the brain's activity during natural behaviors like eye movements is crucial for both basic neuroscience and clinical applications. Saccadic eye movements, which happen constantly, are accompanied by a phenomenon called "saccadic suppression," where our visual perception is temporarily reduced to prevent us from seeing a blur. While previous studies have hinted at the neural underpinnings of this, they often lacked the spatial and temporal resolution to map these dynamics across the entire brain. Furthermore, in epilepsy surgery, precisely identifying critical brain areas like the visual cortex is paramount. High-frequency oscillations (HFOs) in the brain are of interest as potential biomarkers, but distinguishing physiological HFOs from pathological ones (like those associated with seizures) can be challenging. This paper aims to bridge these gaps by creating a detailed map of brain activity during spontaneous saccades and exploring its potential for clinical localization.

Methods

The researchers utilized intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG) data from 30 patients undergoing epilepsy surgery. This allowed for high-density, high-temporal resolution recordings directly from the brain surface. They developed a "four-dimensional (4D) functional atlas" that maps high-gamma activity (a measure of neural firing) across the entire brain over time, synchronized with eye movements recorded via electrooculography (EOG).

Key techniques include:

  • Time-frequency analysis: To examine how high-gamma activity changes over time around saccade events.
  • Mixed-effects modeling: To statistically analyze the relationships between various factors (e.g., saccade direction, proximity to brain regions) and high-gamma activity.
  • Machine learning (bagged-tree-ensemble model): To build a predictive model for localizing the primary visual cortex based on saccade-related high-gamma patterns.

Datasets

The study used iEEG and EOG data from 30 patients with drug-resistant focal epilepsy. This dataset, collected during routine presurgical evaluation, provided a unique opportunity to study spontaneous brain activity during naturalistic eye movements. The primary visual cortex localization was validated against electrical stimulation mapping (ESM), a gold-standard clinical technique.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Saccades are not just motor commands; they are accompanied by complex, widespread brain dynamics: The study reveals that even spontaneous, "task-free" eye movements trigger significant, coordinated changes in high-gamma activity across multiple brain regions, not just those directly involved in motor control.
  • High-gamma activity is a predictive signal: The patterns of high-gamma suppression and augmentation before and after saccades are not random; they can predict the direction and duration of the upcoming eye movement. This suggests a sophisticated predictive mechanism within the brain.
  • Physiological brain activity can be used for clinical localization: The most striking finding is that these spontaneous saccade-related high-gamma modulations can accurately identify the primary visual cortex. This opens up possibilities for non-invasive or less invasive localization techniques, especially for patients who cannot cooperate with traditional methods like ESM.

Key Results

  • A whole-brain dynamic atlas with 5ms temporal resolution was created, showing transient high-gamma suppression in the striatal region before saccade onset, followed by augmentation in posterior brain regions.
  • More intense striatal high-gamma suppression predicted saccades directed to the ipsilateral side and longer saccade durations.
  • A bagged-tree-ensemble model achieved 95% accuracy in localizing the primary visual cortex using saccade-related high-gamma modulations.
  • Each 1% increase in absolute saccade-related high-gamma modulation increased the odds of a site being classified as the primary visual cortex by 1.43.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of eye-tracking: The study acknowledges that not having precise eye-tracking means the exact visual scene or object fixated at saccade offset is unknown, which could influence visual processing.
  • Uncontrolled room light: The intensity of room light was not strictly controlled, which could also have subtle effects on visual processing.
  • Developmental effects: The study did not include patients younger than five years old, so developmental changes in peri-saccadic high-gamma modulations remain to be explored.

Future work could involve incorporating eye-tracking, controlling environmental factors, and investigating younger populations. The authors also suggest that continuous iEEG monitoring during deep brain stimulation therapy could offer unique opportunities to study thalamic modulations related to saccades. The developed bagged-tree-ensemble model is made available for external validation and use in other patient cohorts.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Objective We clarified the clinical and mechanistic significance of physiological modulations of high-frequency broadband cortical activity associated with spontaneous saccadic eye movements during a resting state. Methods We studied 30 patients who underwent epilepsy surgery following extraoperative electrocorticography and electrooculography recordings. We determined whether high-gamma activity at 70-110 Hz preceding saccade onset would predict upcoming ocular behaviors. We assessed how accurately the model incorporating saccade-related high-gamma modulations would localize the primary visual cortex defined by electrical stimulation. Results The whole-brain level dynamic atlas demonstrated transient high-gamma suppression in the striatal region before saccade onset and high-gamma augmentation subsequently involving the widespread posterior brain regions. More intense striatal high-gamma suppression predicted the upcoming saccade directed to the ipsilateral side and lasting longer in duration. The bagged-tree-ensemble model demonstrated that intense saccade-related high-gamma modulations localized the visual cortex with an accuracy of 95%. Conclusions We successfully animated the neural dynamics supporting saccadic suppression, a principal mechanism minimizing the perception of blurred vision during rapid eye movements. The primary visual cortex per se may prepare actively in advance for massive image motion expected during upcoming prolonged saccades. Significance Measuring saccade-related electrocorticographic signals may help localize the visual cortex and avoid misperceiving physiological high-frequency activity as epileptogenic. Highlights - The whole-brain level dynamic atlas animated spontaneous high gamma modulations associated with saccadic eye movements. - Preceding high gamma activity in the striatal cortex predicted the direction and duration of the upcoming saccades. - Saccade-related high-gamma modulations localized the stimulation-defined visual cortex with an accuracy of 95%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ono2021spontaneous,
  author = {Hiroya Ono and Masaki Sonoda and Brian H. Silverstein and Kaori Sonoda and Takafumi Kubota and Aimée F. Luat and Robert Rothermel and Sandeep Sood and Eishi Asano},
  title = {{Spontaneous modulations of high frequency cortical activity}},
  booktitle = {Clinical},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.clinph.2021.06.020},
}
Figure