Spheroidal ambisonics: Spatial audio in spheroidal bases

Shoken Kaneko, Ramani DuraiswamiJASA 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "spheroidal ambisonics," a novel spatial audio framework that extends traditional ambisonics by using spheroidal wave functions instead of spherical harmonics. This allows for more flexible microphone array designs and potentially creates non-spherical "sweet spots" for audio reconstruction, offering a new dimension for immersive audio experiences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional ambisonics, a popular method for capturing and reproducing spatial sound fields, relies on a spherical harmonics representation. While effective, this inherently ties the system to spherical microphone arrays and results in a spherical "sweet spot" for accurate audio rendering. This limits flexibility in designing microphone arrays and the potential for creating non-uniform listening zones. The authors address this by proposing a generalization of ambisonics to spheroidal coordinates, enabling the use of spheroidal microphone arrays and the creation of more adaptable spatial audio representations.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of "spheroidal ambisonics," which leverages spheroidal wave functions to represent sound fields. The paper focuses on the prolate spheroidal coordinate system and derives the necessary mathematical framework for encoding spatial audio using prolate spheroidal microphone arrays. A key contribution is the derivation of an analytical transcoding formula that converts spheroidal ambisonic coefficients into their spherical ambisonic counterparts. This ensures compatibility with the existing ecosystem of spherical ambisonics, allowing for the use of established decoding and rendering techniques. The encoding process is described as solving a regularized least squares problem.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments are based on simulated incident plane waves and reconstructed sound fields.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Spheres: The fundamental insight is that spatial audio representation doesn't have to be limited to spherical symmetry. By adopting spheroidal coordinates, we can move towards more flexible and tailored audio capture and rendering.
  • Asymmetric Sweet Spots: A significant finding is that spheroidal ambisonics can create non-spherical "sweet spots" for accurate audio reconstruction. This sweet spot is elongated along the long axis of a prolate spheroidal microphone array, offering potential for applications where a non-uniform listening area is desired (e.g., multi-person home theaters).
  • Analytical Transcoding for Compatibility: The derivation of an analytical formula to convert spheroidal ambisonic coefficients to spherical ones is crucial. This bridges the gap between the new framework and existing ambisonic technologies, making the proposed method practical for adoption.
  • Mathematical Elegance: The paper demonstrates that the Helmholtz equation is separable in spheroidal coordinates, providing a solid theoretical foundation for this extension of ambisonics.

Key Results

Numerical experiments involving the encoding and transcoding of plane waves demonstrated the effectiveness of spheroidal ambisonics. The reconstructed sound fields showed a clear asymmetry in the "sweet spot" of accurate reconstruction, being wider along the long axis of the prolate spheroid compared to the spherical ambisonics case. This asymmetry was observed for different incident wave directions. The paper validates the analytical transcoding formula by showing that it allows for accurate reconstruction of the incident field.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that the formulation presented is for prolate spheroidal coordinates, and the case of oblate spheroidal coordinates would require a similar derivation. Future work could explore the optimization of microphone capsule configurations on spheroidal baffles, which is crucial for practical implementations and to avoid spatial aliasing. The authors also suggest that a sound-hard circular disc microphone array, as proposed in other research, can be considered a special case of an oblate spheroidal ambisonic microphone array.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ambisonics is an established framework to capture and reproduce spatial sound fields based on the spherical harmonics representation [Gerzon (1973). J. Audio Eng. Soc. 21(1), 2-10]. A generalization-spheroidal ambisonics-based on spheroidal wave functions is proposed for use with spheroidal microphone arrays. Analytical conversion from spheroidal ambisonics to spherical ambisonics are derived to ensure compatibility with the existing ambisonics ecosystem. Numerical experiments verify spheroidal ambisonics encoding and transcoding for spatial sound field recording. The sound field reconstructed from the transcoded coefficients has a zone of accurate reconstruction which is prolonged towards the long axis of a prolate spheroidal microphone array.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kaneko2021spheroidal,
  author = {Shoken Kaneko and Ramani Duraiswami},
  title = {{Spheroidal ambisonics: Spatial audio in spheroidal bases}},
  booktitle = {JASA},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1121/10.0005942},
}
Figure