Abstract
Graph Signal Filter used as dimensionality reduction in spectral clustering usually requires expensive eigenvalue estimation. We analyze the filter in an optimization setting and propose to use four orthogonalization-free methods by optimizing objective functions as dimensionality reduction in spectral clustering. The proposed methods do not utilize any orthogonalization, which is known as not well scalable in a parallel computing environment. Our methods theoretically construct adequate feature space, which is, at most, a weighted alteration to the eigenspace of a normalized Laplacian matrix. We numerically hypothesize that the proposed methods are equivalent in clustering quality to the ideal Graph Signal Filter, which exploits the exact eigenvalue needed without expensive eigenvalue estimation. Numerical results show that the proposed methods outperform Power Iteration-based methods and Graph Signal Filter in clustering quality and computation cost. Unlike Power Iteration-based methods and Graph Signal Filter which require random signal input, our methods are able to utilize available initialization in the streaming graph scenarios. Additionally, numerical results show that our methods outperform ARPACK and are faster than LOBPCG in the streaming graph scenarios. We also present numerical results showing the scalability of our methods in multithreading and multiprocessing implementations to facilitate parallel spectral clustering.
Introduction
Spectral clustering is a fundamental technique in machine learning for identifying complex structures within data. It operates by utilizing the spectrum (eigenvectors) of a graph's Laplacian matrix to project high-dimensional data into a lower-dimensional space, facilitating simple clustering algorithms like K-means. However, a significant computational bottleneck exists: standard algorithms necessitate that these eigenvectors be orthonormal. Maintaining this property through orthogonalization (e.g., Gram-Schmidt) introduces a "communication bottleneck" in parallel computing environments, as it requires frequent synchronization across processors. This limitation is particularly acute for large-scale datasets and streaming graphs where edges are added dynamically.
Methodology
To address these scalability issues, we propose four variants of Orthogonalization-Free Methods (OFM) that eliminate the need for explicit orthonormalization:
- OFM-$f_1$ & OFM-$f_2$: These methods optimize two distinct objective functions using gradient descent. The functions are designed such that their local minima naturally correspond to the desired eigenspace, bypassing the need for forced orthogonality.
- TriOFM-$f_1$ & TriOFM-$f_2$: These "triangularized" versions update features recursively (column by column). While originally intended for sparse eigenvectors, they prove highly effective for the dense eigenvectors typical in graph Laplacians.
Theoretical Foundation
We demonstrate that these methods do not necessarily need to find exact eigenvectors. Instead, they identify features that are "isomorphic" to the eigenspace. This ensures that the geometric relationships between data points are preserved, allowing K-means to produce equivalent clustering results. Furthermore, OFM-$f_1$ converges to eigenvectors weighted by the square root of their eigenvalues, which we hypothesize provides superior features for clustering due to their relationship with graph "commute times."
To enhance convergence speed, we employ momentum acceleration and an exact line search strategy for optimal step-size determination in each iteration.
Experimental Results
The proposed methods were evaluated using high-performance computing benchmarks, including synthetic graphs from the IEEE HPEC Graph Challenge (up to 20 million nodes), real-world internet traffic data (MAWI-Graph-1), and Graph500 benchmarks.
Clustering Quality and Efficiency
As shown in Figure 2, the OFM-$f_1$ variants maintain high clustering quality across various graph types. Figure 6 provides a broader comparison, demonstrating that OFM methods outperform Power Iteration (PI) and Graph Signal Filter (GSF) in both clustering quality (ARI/NMI) and computational efficiency.
Scalability and Streaming Performance
Parallel implementations of OFM showed excellent scaling, reaching up to 1,024 cores efficiently on 1M-node graphs. In streaming scenarios, OFMs leverage "warm starts" by using features from previous time steps as initializations. This allows them to converge faster than traditional solvers like ARPACK or LOBPCG while maintaining superior clustering quality.
Conclusion
By reframing dimensionality reduction as an unconstrained optimization problem, the proposed orthogonalization-free methods overcome the primary scalability bottlenecks of traditional spectral clustering. Our results indicate that orthogonality is not a prerequisite for high-quality clustering. Future work will focus on a more rigorous theoretical analysis of the effectiveness of weighted eigenvectors and further exploring the relationship between these features and graph commute times.
Summary updated