Specificity of cortical area and thickness as biomarkers for comorbid internalizing and externalizing mental disorders in pre-adolescence

Nanyu Kuang, Zhaowen Liu, Gechang Yu, Kai Zhang, Xinran Wu, Benjamin Becker, Huaxin Fan, Jiajia Zhao, Jujiao Kang, Guiying Dong, Xing‐Ming Zhao, Jianfeng Feng, Barbara J. Sahakian, Trevor W. Robbins, Günter Schumann, Lena Palaniyappan, Jie ZhangmedRxiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Comorbidity is the rule rather than the exception for childhood and adolescent onset mental disorders, yet the neural mechanisms underlying these overlapping conditions remain poorly understood. This study investigates whether the anatomical changes associated with comorbid internalizing and externalizing disorders represent a simple aggregate of individual disorder effects or a unique neurobiological signature. Analyzing data from 11,878 pre-adolescents (ages 9-10) from the Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study, we found that cortical surface area (SA) reductions follow an additive pattern in comorbid cases. Conversely, cortical thickness (CT) exhibits a non-linear effect: while single-disorder groups show significant thickness increases, the comorbid group appears indistinguishable from healthy controls. These divergent patterns are linked to distinct genetic and cellular pathways—SA to excitatory neurons and CT to immune-related processes—suggesting that comorbidity involves a failure of compensatory biological mechanisms.

Introduction

In pediatric psychiatry, the presence of multiple concurrent disorders—comorbidity—is highly prevalent. A child diagnosed with an internalizing disorder, such as anxiety or depression, frequently exhibits externalizing behaviors, such as ADHD or conduct disorder. Despite this clinical reality, it has been unclear whether the neurobiological "footprint" of comorbidity is merely the sum of its parts or a distinct pathological state. Understanding these anatomical variations is critical for developing better predictive models and targeted interventions.

Methods and Data

This research utilized data from Release 3.0 of the Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study, comprising 11,878 participants aged 9-10. The study employed a multi-level analytical approach:

  • Neuroimaging: MRI scans were used to measure Cortical Surface Area (SA) and Cortical Thickness (CT) across 68 brain regions.
  • Statistical Modeling: Linear Mixed Models (LMM) compared four distinct groups: Pure Internalizing, Pure Externalizing, Comorbid, and Healthy Controls, adjusting for age, sex, and socioeconomic factors.
  • Genetics and Bioinformatics: A Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS) was performed on a subset of 4,716 unrelated European participants to identify genetic variants associated with brain changes.
  • Cell-Type Specificity: Genetic findings were integrated with seven independent single-cell RNA sequencing datasets from human brain tissue to map associations to specific cell types, such as neurons and immune cells.

Key Results

The Divergence of Surface Area and Thickness

The study's most significant finding is the divergent behavior of SA and CT in the context of comorbidity.

  • Surface Area (SA) as an Additive Burden: SA reductions acted as a "burden meter." The comorbid group showed significant reductions in 29 out of 68 brain regions compared to controls. These reductions were more pronounced in the comorbid group than in either single-disorder group, supporting an additive model of neurobiological impact.
  • Cortical Thickness (CT) as a Non-Linear Marker: CT followed a surprising non-linear path. While children with only externalizing disorders showed significant increases in 5 regions and those with only internalizing disorders showed increases in 10 regions, the comorbid group showed zero significant CT changes compared to healthy controls.

Biological and Cellular Underpinnings

The genetic drivers for these two metrics were found to be distinct:

  • SA Changes: Linked to excitatory neurons (specifically C1ql3-expressing neurons) and protein phosphorylation, suggesting a relationship with the brain's structural "hardware."
  • CT Changes: Associated with immune-related processes involving microglia and oligodendrocytes (linked to genes such as TNIP3 and PRDM5). This suggests that thickness variations reflect the brain's "maintenance and defense" environment.

Discussion: The Resilience Hypothesis

The authors propose that the increased cortical thickness observed in single-disorder groups may represent a compensatory or adaptive response—possibly involving neuroinflammation or delayed synaptic pruning. In children with comorbid conditions, this "resilience" mechanism appears to be overwhelmed or absent. Consequently, their CT measurements revert to a "near-normal" state that masks the underlying clinical severity. This suggests that children with the highest clinical risk but the lowest biological resilience develop the comorbid illness pattern.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The emergence of comorbidity across distinct clusters of psychopathology is not a simple additive neurobiological effect. Instead, it involves distinct risk-adaptation processes. While SA is a marker of cumulative vulnerability, CT may reflect the brain's capacity for adaptation.

Limitations of this study include its cross-sectional design, which prevents definitive causal conclusions. Future longitudinal follow-ups within the ABCD cohort will be essential to determine if these morphometric patterns can predict the transition from a single disorder to a comorbid state. Additionally, direct measures of neuroinflammation and myelination are needed to verify the hypothesized roles of microglia and oligodendrocytes in these developmental processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Comorbidity is the rule rather than the exception for childhood and adolescent onset mental disorders, but we cannot predict its occurrence and do not know the neural mechanisms underlying comorbidity. We investigate if the effects of comorbid internalizing and externalizing disorders on anatomical changes represent a simple aggregate of the effects on each disorder, and if comorbidity-related cortical surface changes relate to a distinct genetic underpinning. Methods We studied the cortical surface area (SA) and thickness (CT) of 11,878 preadolescents (9-10 years) from the Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development Study. Linear mixed models were implemented in comparative and association analyses among internalizing (Dysthymia, Major Depressive Disorder, Disruptive Mood Dysregulation Disorder, Agoraphobia, Panic Disorder, Specific Phobia, Separation Anxiety Disorder, Social Anxiety Disorder, Generalized Anxiety Disorder, Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder), externalizing diagnostic groups (Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, Oppositional Defiant Disorder, Conduct disorder) a group with comorbidity of the two and a healthy control group. Genome-wide association analysis and cell type specificity analysis were performed on 4,716 unrelated European participants from this cohort. Results Reduced cortical surface area but increased thickness occurs across patient groups when compared to controls. Children with comorbid internalizing and externalizing disorders had more pronounced areal reduction than those without comorbidity, indicating an additive burden. In contrast, cortical thickness had a non-linear effect with comorbidity: the comorbid group had no significant CT changes, while those patient groups without comorbidity had significant thickness increases. Distinct biological pathways were implicated for regional SA and CT changes. Specifically, CT changes were associated with immune-related processes implicating microglia, while SA-related changes related mainly to excitatory neurons. Conclusions The emergence of comorbidity across distinct clusters of psychopathology is unlikely to be a simple additive neurobiological effect. Distinct risk-adaptation processes, with unique genetic and cell-specific factors may underlie SA and CT changes. Children with highest risk but lowest resilience, both captured in their developmental morphometry, develop a comorbid illness pattern.
BibTeX
@misc{kuang2022specificity,
  author = {Nanyu Kuang and Zhaowen Liu and Gechang Yu and Kai Zhang and Xinran Wu and Benjamin Becker and Huaxin Fan and Jiajia Zhao and Jujiao Kang and Guiying Dong and Xing‐Ming Zhao and Jianfeng Feng and Barbara J. Sahakian and Trevor W. Robbins and Günter Schumann and Lena Palaniyappan and Jie Zhang},
  title = {{Specificity of cortical area and thickness as biomarkers for comorbid internalizing and externalizing mental disorders in pre-adolescence}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.04.24.22273790},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure