Abstract: While speciation in eukaryotes is well-studied, a controversy over the nature of bacterial species due to recombination between distant strains continues. It is generally agreed that bacterial diversity can be classified into genetically and ecologically cohesive units, but what produces such variation is a topic of intensive research. Recombination may maintain coherent species of frequently recombining bacteria, but the emergence of distinct clusters within a recombining species, and the impact of habitat structure in this process are not well described, limiting our understanding of how new species are created. Here we present a model of bacterial evolution in overlapping habitat space. We show three different outcomes are possible for a pair of clusters, depending on the size of their habitat overlap: fast divergence with little interaction between the clusters, slow divergence with frequent recombination between the clusters, and stationary or near stationary population structure, where the clusters remain at an equilibrium distance for an indefinite time. We fit our model to two data sets. In Streptococcus pneumoniae, we find a genomically and ecologically distinct subset, held at a relatively constant genetic distance from the majority of the population through frequent recombination with it, while in Campylobacter jejuni, we find a minority population we predict will continue to diverge at a higher rate. This approach may predict and define speciation trajectories in multiple bacterial species.
Introduction
Speciation in eukaryotes typically involves the cessation of interbreeding followed by genetic drift. In bacteria, however, horizontal gene transfer (recombination) allows for the exchange of genetic material across significant distances, complicating the definition of a species. While bacterial diversity is organized into genetically and ecologically cohesive units, the mechanisms producing this variation remain under investigation. Specifically, it is unclear how distinct clusters emerge within a recombining species and how habitat structure influences this process.
The Overlapping Habitats Model
To address these questions, we developed the Overlapping Habitats Model, a Wright-Fisher forward simulation tracking bacterial evolution. The model posits two populations (A and B) occupying specific habitats (a and b) with a shared region (ab).
Recombination is restricted to individuals within the same habitat, while migration allows strains to move between specific and shared spaces. This setup uses habitat overlap as a controllable barrier to recombination, regulating the "cohesive force" of gene flow against the "diversifying force" of mutation.
Empirical Validation and Results
The model was applied to two genomic datasets: 616 Streptococcus pneumoniae isolates and 235 Campylobacter jejuni isolates. By fitting the model to core gene alignments and recombination rate estimates, we identified distinct speciation trajectories.
Three Evolutionary Trajectories
Our simulations revealed three possible outcomes based on habitat overlap:
- Low Overlap: Leads to rapid, clonal-like divergence.
- Intermediate Overlap: Results in slow divergence where clusters gradually drift apart.
- High Overlap: Produces a stationary equilibrium where clusters maintain a fixed genetic distance indefinitely.
Case Studies: S. pneumoniae and C. jejuni
In S. pneumoniae, the SC12 cluster exhibits approximately 41% habitat overlap with the main population. This high overlap creates a "satellite species" effect: SC12 remains genomically distinct but is held at a stable distance by frequent recombination, preventing full speciation.
Conversely, the divergent C. jejuni lineage shows only 24% overlap. Our model predicts this population will continue to diverge at a higher rate, following a trajectory of slow but continuous separation.
Discussion
A key finding is that speciation is "fragmented." It does not occur across the entire genome simultaneously. Instead, certain genes "escape" the cohesive force of recombination and diverge early, while the rest of the genome remains at equilibrium. This creates a patchy genomic landscape of differentiation.
Furthermore, our results suggest that current literature may underestimate bacterial recombination rates. The model required higher rates than typically reported to match the observed lack of "ecoSNPs" (variants present in all members of one cluster but absent in the other) across most genes.
Conclusion
The Overlapping Habitats Model provides a framework for predicting speciation trajectories in recombining bacteria. While the current model assumes heritable habitat specificity, future iterations could integrate explicit selection for habitat-specific alleles. This approach offers a new lens through which to view the tension between genetic drift and gene flow in the microbial world.
Summary updated