Spatially Selective Artificial-Noise Aided Transmit Optimization for MISO Multi-Eves Secrecy Rate Maximization

Qiang Li, Wing-Kin Ma

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of maximizing secure communication rates in a multi-antenna system where multiple eavesdroppers are present. The authors propose a novel approach that jointly optimizes the transmission of confidential information and artificial noise (AN) to jam eavesdroppers, achieving higher secrecy rates than previous methods, even with imperfect knowledge of eavesdropper channels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In wireless communication, ensuring the confidentiality of transmitted data is crucial. This paper focuses on "physical-layer security," which aims to make it difficult for eavesdroppers to decode information, even if they intercept the signal. A key challenge arises when multiple eavesdroppers are present, each with their own antennas. Traditional methods often struggle to effectively jam all eavesdroppers simultaneously. Furthermore, designing these security measures requires knowledge of the eavesdroppers' communication channels (CSI). However, obtaining perfect CSI is often difficult in practice. This paper addresses the problem of maximizing the achievable secrecy rate in a multi-input single-output (MISO) system with multiple eavesdroppers, considering both perfect and imperfect CSI, and proposing a flexible approach to artificial noise (AN) generation.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in developing an optimization framework for Secrecy Rate Maximization (SRM).

  • Joint Optimization: Unlike prior work that often optimized confidential information and AN separately or assumed a fixed AN pattern, this paper proposes jointly optimizing the covariance matrices of both the confidential information (W) and the artificial noise (Σ). This allows for "spatially selective" AN, which can be tailored to jam eavesdroppers more effectively.
  • SDP-Based Approach: The complex optimization problem is reformulated and solved using a sequence of Semidefinite Programs (SDPs). This is a standard and powerful technique in communication system design for convex optimization problems.
  • Tight Relaxation: For the imperfect CSI case, the authors introduce a "worst-case robust SRM" (WCR-SRM) formulation. To handle the infinite number of inequalities arising from CSI uncertainty, they derive a tight relaxation that can be efficiently solved using SDPs.
  • Outage-Constrained Robust SRM (OCR-SRM): The paper also proposes a safe approximation for an even more challenging scenario where CSI errors are random (Gaussian distributed), using the WCR-SRM solution as a basis.
  • Transmit Beamforming Optimality: A significant theoretical finding is that transmit beamforming (where the confidential information signal is directed towards the legitimate receiver) is an optimal strategy for confidential information transmission in this setting, both for perfect and worst-case robust imperfect CSI.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and simulation-based evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Spatially Selective AN: The ability to design AN with any spatial pattern, rather than just isotropic noise, significantly enhances the system's ability to jam multiple eavesdroppers. This is a key differentiator from many previous works.
  • Joint Optimization is Crucial: Optimizing the confidential information and AN covariances simultaneously leads to better performance than optimizing them independently.
  • Transmit Beamforming is Always Optimal for Confidential Information: Even in the presence of multiple eavesdroppers and AN, directing the confidential signal towards the legitimate receiver is the optimal strategy. This provides a strong theoretical justification for using beamforming in secure communication.
  • SDP as a Universal Tool: The paper demonstrates the power of SDPs in solving complex communication security problems, even under imperfect CSI and with additional constraints.
  • Robustness Matters: For practical systems, dealing with imperfect CSI is essential. The proposed robust formulations provide a way to design secure systems that are resilient to CSI uncertainties.

Key Results

  • Improved Secrecy Rates: Simulation results show that the proposed AN-aided SRM design achieves significantly higher secrecy rates compared to both an optimal no-AN design and a design using isotropic AN, especially when the number of eavesdroppers increases.
  • Performance Gains: For three eavesdroppers, the AN-aided SRM design can achieve a secrecy rate gain of up to 2 bits per channel use over the isotropic AN design and a much more dramatic gain over the no-AN design.
  • Effectiveness of AN: The results highlight that AN is not only beneficial but necessary when the number of eavesdroppers is large, as the no-AN design's performance plateaus.
  • Robustness to CSI Errors: The WCR-SRM design demonstrates resilience to CSI uncertainties, outperforming nonrobust designs under worst-case scenarios.
  • Safe Approximation for Outage: The proposed safe approximation for the OCR-SRM problem provides a practical way to achieve a high probability of secrecy satisfaction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While SDPs are efficient, solving a sequence of them can still be computationally intensive, especially for large systems.
  • Imperfect Bob's Channel: The paper mentions that extending the robust framework to handle imperfect CSI at the legitimate receiver (Bob) is a possible future direction, though it would involve more complex fractional SDPs.
  • AN Nullspace Constraint: The paper notes that while the nullspace AN constraint (where AN does not interfere with the legitimate receiver) is common, their approach does not impose it. They suggest that incorporating it might simplify analysis but found it doesn't simplify optimization and yields similar performance. Future work could explore the relationship between SRM-optimal AN and the nullspace AN condition.
  • Efficient Methods for Quasiconvex Problems: For future work, the authors suggest exploring more efficient methods for handling quasiconvex problems that arise in extensions of this work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Consider an MISO channel overheard by multiple eavesdroppers. Our goal is to design an artificial noise (AN)-aided transmit strategy, such that the achievable secrecy rate is maximized subject to the sum power constraint. AN-aided secure transmission has recently been found to be a promising approach for blocking eavesdropping attempts. In many existing studies, the confidential information transmit covariance and the AN covariance are not simultaneously optimized. In particular, for design convenience, it is common to prefix the AN covariance as a specific kind of spatially isotropic covariance. This paper considers joint optimization of the transmit and AN covariances for secrecy rate maximization (SRM), with a design flexibility that the AN can take any spatial pattern. Hence, the proposed design has potential in jamming the eavesdroppers more effectively, based upon the channel state information (CSI). We derive an optimization approach to the SRM problem through both analysis and convex conic optimization machinery. We show that the SRM problem can be recast as a single-variable optimization problem, and that resultant problem can be efficiently handled by solving a sequence of semidefinite programs. Our framework deals with a general setup of multiple multi-antenna eavesdroppers, and can cater for additional constraints arising from specific application scenarios, such as interference temperature constraints in interference networks. We also generalize the framework to an imperfect CSI case where a worst-case robust SRM formulation is considered. A suboptimal but safe solution to the outage-constrained robust SRM design is also investigated. Simulation results show that the proposed AN-aided SRM design yields significant secrecy rate gains over an optimal no-AN design and the isotropic AN design, especially when there are more eavesdroppers.
BibTeX
@article{li2013spatially,
  author = {Qiang Li and Wing-Kin Ma},
  title = {{Spatially Selective Artificial-Noise Aided Transmit Optimization for MISO Multi-Eves Secrecy Rate Maximization}},
  journal = {IEEE TSP},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1109/tsp.2013.2253771},
}
Figure