Abstract
This paper aims to make a comparison between decode-and-forward (DF) relays and reconfigurable intelligent surfaces (RISs) in the case where only one relay or RIS is selected based on the maximization of the signal-to-noise-ratio (SNR). Our study accounts for the spatial distribution of RISs and relays, which is assumed to follow a Poisson point process (PPP). It considers two different path loss models corresponding to RIS/relays randomly located in the near-field and the far-field of the transmitter. Based on the Gamma distribution moment matching method and tools from stochastic geometry, we derive approximations for the outage probability (OP) as well as the energy efficiency (EE) of the RISs-assisted system in the near-field and the far-field scenarios separately. Under the same conditions as RIS, the expressions for OP and EE of the half-duplex and the full-duplex DF relays-assisted systems are also derived. Simulation results show that RIS is the best choice in the near-field case, regardless of the OP or EE criterion. Compared to half-duplex relays and full-duplex relays, the RIS based system is the most energy-efficient solution to assist communication.
Introduction
As the wireless industry pivots toward 6G, the quest for ubiquitous coverage and ultra-high data rates has sparked a debate: should we rely on traditional active Decode-and-Forward (DF) relays or the emerging Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS)? While relays amplify and re-transmit signals, RISs are passive surfaces that manipulate the electromagnetic environment by reflecting signals with controlled phase shifts.
Most comparative studies focus on fixed, single-node deployments. However, in future "smart cities," these devices will be densely and randomly distributed across urban infrastructure. This paper provides a rigorous mathematical framework to compare these technologies in a spatially random environment, asking which technology truly excels when we select the best available node from a random deployment.
Modeling Spatial Randomness
To ensure a "fair comparison," the authors model the locations of RISs and relays using a Poisson Point Process (PPP). The nodes are distributed within a ring-shaped area centered on the user, as shown in the system model below.
The system employs Selection Combining (SC), where the single best RIS or relay—the one maximizing the received Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR)—is chosen to assist the communication. The analysis distinguishes between near-field and far-field propagation. In the near-field, the model accounts for the varying distances and angles between the transmitter and different elements on a large RIS, a critical detail often overlooked in simpler models. To handle the mathematical complexity of the sum of channel gains, the authors utilize Gamma distribution moment matching and derive closed-form approximations using Meijer’s G-functions.
Key Insights: The RIS Advantage
The study highlights several fundamental differences between the two technologies:
- The "Square Law" Gain: An RIS with $N$ reflecting elements provides a beamforming gain that scales with $N^2$. Although passive, a sufficiently large $N$ can overcome the lack of active amplification, making RIS highly competitive.
- Near-Field Dominance: In near-field scenarios, RIS consistently outperforms both half-duplex and full-duplex relays. It avoids the time-slot loss of half-duplex relays and the complex self-interference cancellation required by full-duplex systems.
- Energy Efficiency (EE): This is the "killer app" for RIS. Because RIS elements are passive, the power consumption is significantly lower than that of active relays. The results indicate that RIS is the most sustainable solution for assisting communication across almost all tested scenarios.
- High SNR Saturation: In high-SNR regimes, the outage probability (OP) does not vanish but hits a "floor." This floor represents the spatial probability that no RIS or relay is located close enough to the user within the random deployment area.
Performance Comparison
The authors validated their analytical approximations using Monte Carlo simulations. Key findings include:
- Far-Field Trade-offs: In the far-field, active relays (e.g., with $N=16$ antennas) can offer a 5–6 dB power advantage over an RIS with the same number of elements. However, increasing the number of RIS elements quickly closes this gap; an RIS with $N=64$ can outperform a relay with $N=8$.
- Deployment Density: Both increasing the deployment density ($\rho$) and the number of elements ($N$) improve performance. However, for RIS, increasing $N$ is a more potent lever due to the $N^2$ gain.
- Reliability: RIS-based systems are shown to be more reliable in the near-field, achieving lower outage probabilities than their relay counterparts.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that while active relays may hold an edge in specific far-field signal strength scenarios, RIS-assisted systems are the superior choice for near-field communications and overall energy efficiency. As deployment density and surface size increase, the passive nature of RIS makes it a more scalable and sustainable component for the 6G ecosystem. Future work will likely address the challenges of imperfect channel state information and multi-user interference in these distributed networks.
Summary updated