Spatial variation in particle number size distributions in a large metropolitan area

J. F. Mejía, Lídia Morawska, Kerrie Mengersen

TL;DR

This study reveals that the spatial distribution of particle number size distributions (NSD) in Brisbane is highly heterogeneous, driven by variations in traffic composition rather than just concentration levels. The findings highlight the importance of considering the shape of the NSD, not just its magnitude, to understand urban air pollution sources and their spatial impact.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the spatial variation of airborne particles is crucial for assessing their impact on public health and the environment. While previous studies have often focused on overall particle concentration differences between locations, this paper addresses a gap in understanding how the underlying geometry or shape of particle number size distributions (NSD) varies across a large metropolitan area. This geometric variation can provide more nuanced insights into the types and proximity of pollution sources. The authors aim to investigate whether NSD is evenly distributed across Brisbane and to characterize these spatial variations.

Methods

The researchers collected particle number size distribution (NSD) data from nine different locations in Brisbane over various periods. They analyzed the data using several statistical methods:

  • Modal Structure Analysis: This involved examining the graphical representation of the NSD to identify peaks (modes) and their locations, which are indicative of different emission sources.
  • Cumulative Distribution and Number Median Diameter (NMD): These parameters were used to quantify the overall particle size distribution and the contribution of different size fractions (e.g., ultrafine particles, nanoparticles).
  • Kolmogorov-Smirnov (K-S) Test: This statistical test was employed to compare the modal distributions obtained from each site, determining if they differed significantly.
  • One-way ANOVA and Post-hoc Tests (LSD, Games-Howell): These were used to compare average NMD values between sites and to identify statistically significant differences.
  • Outlier Analysis: A two-stage graphical and statistical procedure was used to identify and remove extreme values that could skew the results.

The study focused on particle sizes in the range of 15-300 nm, as larger particles were found to contribute minimally to the total particle number.

Datasets

The study utilized NSD data collected at nine distinct monitoring sites across Brisbane. The data was gathered over different campaigns with varying durations, spanning a total period of 11 years. Specific details about each site, including its environmental type, monitoring period, and distance to the Central Business District (CBD), are provided in Table 1. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on existing measurement data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shape Matters More Than Just Concentration: The most significant finding is that the shape of the particle size distribution, not just the total number of particles, varies considerably across urban areas. This suggests that different emission sources and their proximity have a distinct "fingerprint" on the particle size spectrum.
  • Bimodality is Common: Most of the analyzed NSDs exhibited a bimodal structure (two distinct peaks), often with one peak below 30 nm and another around 50-100 nm. This bimodality is characteristic of urban emissions, with the smaller mode often linked to petrol vehicles and the larger mode to diesel exhaust.
  • Diesel Dominance Creates a Unique Signature: A site heavily influenced by diesel trucks (Port of Brisbane) showed a distinct NSD with a shifted NMD and a significantly lower contribution of nanoparticles compared to other sites. This highlights how specific traffic compositions can dramatically alter the particle size profile.
  • Proximity to Roads is Key: Sites located very close to major roads (<5m) showed distributions dominated by smaller particles, suggesting that atmospheric dilution and coagulation processes are influenced by immediate proximity to emission sources.
  • Traffic Composition, Not Just Volume: While weekday and weekend data generally showed no significant differences, the study inferred variations in traffic composition as a key driver of the observed spatial differences in NSD, even when overall traffic volume might not be the primary factor.

Key Results

  • Heterogeneous Spatial Distribution: Statistical analyses (K-S tests) confirmed that the modal structures of NSD differed significantly across the nine sites, indicating a heterogeneous distribution throughout Brisbane.
  • Dominance of Ultrafine Particles (UFPs): UFPs (<100 nm) consistently accounted for 82-90% of the total particle number across most sites. Nanoparticles (<50 nm) contributed 60-70%, except at the diesel-dominated site (BP), where their contribution dropped to 50%.
  • Typical Peaks and NMD: Generally, peak concentrations were observed below 30 nm, and Number Median Diameters (NMD) were below 50 nm. The diesel-dominated site (BP) showed higher NMDs around 50-60 nm.
  • Site Classification: Based on modal structures, sites were broadly classified into three groups: (1) urban sites dominated by petrol traffic, (2) urban sites influenced by road proximity, and (3) an isolated site dominated by diesel traffic.
  • Limited Seasonality/Time Effects: The study found that differences in sampling periods or seasons did not significantly affect the NSD, suggesting that local emission sources, particularly traffic, are the dominant factors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Traffic Data: A significant limitation acknowledged by the authors is the lack of detailed traffic composition data. This prevented a direct assessment of the relative contribution of petrol versus diesel vehicles at each site, hindering a more precise interpretation of the observed NSD variations.
  • Unclear Peak at ANZ: One site (ANZ) showed an unusual peak above 100 nm during a specific episode, the cause of which remained unclear and did not fit typical patterns.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future investigations should incorporate detailed traffic composition data to better link specific vehicle types and emission characteristics to observed NSD patterns. Further research could also explore the influence of other emission sources (e.g., industrial, domestic burning) on spatial NSD variations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Air quality studies have indicated that particle number size distribution (NSD) is unevenly spread in urban air. To date, these studies have focussed on differences in concentration levels between sampling locations rather than differences in the underlying geometries of the distributions. As a result, the existing information on the spatial variation of the NSD in urban areas remains incomplete. To investigate this variation in a large metropolitan area in the southern hemisphere, NSD data collected at nine different locations during different campaigns of varying duration were compared using statistical methods. The spectra were analysed in terms of their modal structures (the graphical representation of the number size distribution function), cumulative distribution and number median diameter (NMD). The study found that with the exception of one site all distributions were bimodal or suggestive of bimodality. In general, peak concentrations were below 30 nm and NMDs below 50 nm, except at a site dominated by diesel trucks, where it shifted to around 50 and 60 nm respectively. Ultrafine particles (UFPs (&lt;100 nm)) contributed to 82–90% of the particle number, nanoparticles (&lt;50 nm) to around 60–70%, except at the diesel traffic site, where their contribution dropped to 50%. Statistical analyses found that the modal structures heterogeneously distributed throughout Brisbane whereas it was not always the case for the NMD. The discussion led to the following site classification: (1) urban sites dominated by petrol traffic, (2) urban sites affected by the proximity to the road and (3) an isolated site dominated by diesel traffic. Comparisons of weekday and weekend data indicated that, the distributions were not statistically different. The only exception occurred at one site, where there is a significant drop in the number of diesel buses on the weekend. The differences in sampling period between sites did not affect the results. The statistics instead suggested variations in traffic composition. However, the relative contribution of petrol vehicle emissions at each site could not be assessed due to the limited traffic information available.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mejia2008spatial,
  author = {J. F. Mejía and Lídia Morawska and Kerrie Mengersen},
  title = {{Spatial variation in particle number size distributions in a large metropolitan area}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-8-1127-2008},
}

Loading related content...

Figure