Spatial profiling of ovarian clear cell carcinoma reveals immune-hot features

Ya-Ting Tai, Wei‐Chou Lin, Duncan Yi-Te Wang, Jieru Ye, Tuan Zea Tan, Lin‐Hung Wei, Ruby Yun‐Ju HuangbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses Digital Spatial Profiling (DSP) to map the spatial distribution of immune cells and tumor cell features within ovarian clear cell carcinoma (OCCC). They discovered distinct "immune-hot" and "immune-cold" tumor cell clusters, revealing that specific immune mimicry patterns in tumor cells and the presence of tumor-infiltrating immune cells (TIIs) are significantly associated with OCCC recurrence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ovarian clear cell carcinoma (OCCC) is a challenging cancer, particularly in Asia, where it has a high incidence and often presents at an early stage but with a tendency for recurrence. While "immune-hot" features have been linked to poorer prognosis, a detailed understanding of the spatial relationships between tumor cells and immune cells, and how this intra-tumoral heterogeneity (ITH) influences recurrence, has been lacking. This paper aims to bridge this gap by spatially profiling OCCC to define specific patterns of ITH associated with immune-hot features and their correlation with clinical outcomes, specifically recurrence.

Methods

The researchers employed Digital Spatial Profiling (DSP) using the nanoString GeoMx system. This technique allows for the simultaneous detection and quantification of multiple protein targets within specific regions of interest (ROIs) on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue sections.

Here's a breakdown of the key steps:

  • Sample Preparation: FFPE tissue sections from 10 early-stage OCCC patients were processed.
  • DSP Assay: An 18-protein panel (Human Protein Core) was used to profile selected ROIs. Visualization markers like pan-cytokeratin (PanCK), CD45, and DNA were used to define Areas of Illumination (AOIs) within these ROIs.
  • Data Analysis:
    • Unsupervised Hierarchical Clustering: Used to group AOIs based on their protein expression profiles, identifying distinct tumor cell clusters.
  • Correlation Analysis: Investigated the association between these identified clusters, the presence of tumor-infiltrating immune cells (TIIs), and morphological patterns with OCCC recurrence.
  • Statistical Tests: Chi-square tests and ANOVA were used to assess the significance of observed associations.

The novelty lies in the application of DSP to OCCC, enabling a high-resolution spatial analysis that goes beyond bulk analysis to understand the intricate interactions within the tumor microenvironment.

Datasets

The study utilized FFPE tumor sections from 10 early-stage ovarian clear cell carcinoma (OCCC) patients. These samples were selected from a larger cohort of 195 Stage I/II OCCC patients reviewed at the National Taiwan University Hospital.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tumor Cells Aren't Uniform: The study revealed that tumor cells within OCCC are not monolithic. They can be categorized into distinct clusters based on their protein expression, suggesting different functional states and interactions with the immune system.
  • Immune Mimicry is Key: The identified "immune-hot" clusters (C1-a, C1-b, C1-c) exhibit "immune mimicry" features. This means tumor cells are adopting characteristics that can confuse or interact with the immune system in specific ways, rather than simply being infiltrated by immune cells.
  • Papillary Morphology Signals Trouble: A papillary tumor morphology was strongly associated with recurrence. This morphological feature, when combined with specific immune mimicry patterns (like C1-c), appears to be a significant indicator of a higher risk of the cancer returning.
  • TIIs are Complex: Tumor-infiltrating immune cells (TIIs) are not uniformly distributed. Their presence and interaction with specific tumor cell clusters (like C1-b and C1-c) are linked to recurrence, suggesting a dynamic interplay rather than a simple presence/absence.
  • Immune Mimicry as a Double-Edged Sword: The findings suggest that different types of immune mimicry can have opposing effects. Some (like "GZMB high") might be associated with better outcomes, while others (like "immune-like" with CTLA4) could promote a less permissive tumor microenvironment and potentially worse prognosis.

Key Results

  • Five Clusters Identified: Unsupervised clustering revealed five distinct PanCK+ (tumor cell) clusters: three "immune-hot" (C1-a: granzyme B high, C1-b: immune signal high, C1-c: immune-like) and two "immune-cold" (C2-a: fibronectin-high, C2-b: signal-cold).
  • Recurrence Association:
    • C1-c and C2-a PanCK+ AOIs were significantly associated with OCCC recurrence.
  • Papillary morphology was observed more frequently in recurrent tumors (54.7%) compared to non-recurrent ones (18.9%).
  • C1-c PanCK segments were exclusively found in ROIs with a papillary pattern.
  • TIIs were more frequent in recurrent tumors (66.7%) than in non-recurrent ones (14.3%).
  • TIIs were found in higher frequencies within C1-b and C1-c PanCK+ AOIs.
  • Immune Cell Characterization:
    • Immune cells around C1-b and C1-c PanCK+ AOIs were identified as TIIs with higher CD68 expression.
  • Immune cells around C1-a, C2-a, and C2-b PanCK+ AOIs were identified as non-TIIs with higher SMA expression.
  • Morphology and Immune Cells:
    • Immune cells within papillary ROIs had higher frequency (73.7%) in recurrent tumors.
  • TIIs showed higher frequency in the papillary pattern (70.0%) and lower frequency in the tubulocystic pattern (5.0%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The study was conducted on only 10 patients. While this is a limitation for generalizability, it's a common starting point for novel spatial profiling studies.
  • Early-Stage Focus: The study focused on early-stage OCCC. Future research could explore whether these findings hold true for advanced-stage disease.
  • Further Mechanistic Studies: While the study identifies associations, further research is needed to elucidate the precise mechanisms by which tumor cell immune mimicry and TIIs contribute to OCCC recurrence.
  • Biomarker Validation: The identified immune-hot features, TIIs, and tumor morphology could serve as potential biomarkers for patient selection for immunotherapy. Validation in larger cohorts is crucial.
  • Interaction Complexity: The authors highlight that the interaction between immune mimicry of tumor cells and TIIs is complex and warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction OCCC has high incidence in Asia with frequent occurrence at early stage but without sufficient data on molecular stratification for high-risk patients. Recently, immune-hot features have been proposed as an indicator for poor prognosis for early-stage OCCC. Specific patterns of intra-tumoral heterogeneity (ITH) associated with immune-hot features need to be defined. Methods Formalin-fixed paraffine embedded (FFPE) tumor sections from 10 early-stage OCCC patients were included. Digital Spatial Profiling (DSP) of 18 protein targets was conducted by using the nanoString GeoMx system to profile selected regions of interest (ROIs) based on the reference H&E staining morphology. Areas of illumination (AOIs) were defined according to ROI segmentation by the fluorescence signals of visualization markers pan-cytokeratin (PanCK), CD45, or DNA. Results Unsupervised hierarchical clustering of 252 AOIs from 229 ROIs showed that PanCK segments expressed different combinations of immune markers suggestive of immune mimicry features. Three immune-hot clusters were identified: granzyme B high (C1-a), immune signal high (C1-b) and immune-like cells (C1-c); two immune-cold clusters were identified: fibronectin-high (C2-a) and signal-cold (C2-b). Immune cells around C1-b and C1-c PanCK+ AOIs were tumor infiltrating immune cells (TIIs) with higher expression of CD68, while those around C1-a, C2-a and C2-b PanCK+ AOIs were non-TIIs with higher expression of SMA. C1-c and C2-a PanCK+ AOIs were associated with OCCC recurrence. TIIs had higher frequencies in C1-b and C1-c PanCK+ AOIs and were associated with OCCC recurrence. Correlating with morphology, tumor samples with recurrence showed higher frequency of papillary pattern. Plus, ROIs with papillary pattern had extremely high frequency of PanCK segments of C1-c feature, higher frequency of TIIs, and macrophage lineage immune mimicry with high intensity of CD68. Conclusions Spatial profiling of early-stage OCCC tumors revealed that immune mimicry of tumor cells, the presence of TIIs, and papillary pattern in morphology were associated with recurrence.
BibTeX
@misc{tai2023spatial,
  author = {Ya-Ting Tai and Wei‐Chou Lin and Duncan Yi-Te Wang and Jieru Ye and Tuan Zea Tan and Lin‐Hung Wei and Ruby Yun‐Ju Huang},
  title = {{Spatial profiling of ovarian clear cell carcinoma reveals immune-hot features}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.07.27.550775},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure