TL;DR
This paper presents the first study of small-scale plasma turbulence parameters in the equatorial electrojet (EEJ) using co-located HF and VHF radar observations. By developing a method to account for turbulence effects, the researchers provide new insights into how these irregularities evolve throughout the day and their relationship with the overall electrojet strength.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The equatorial electrojet (EEJ) is a region of intense electric current in the Earth's ionosphere, located above the magnetic equator. This region is known to be a site of plasma instabilities that generate various types of irregularities, including "type I" and "type II" waves. Understanding the characteristics of these plasma waves and the turbulence they create is crucial for comprehending the dynamics of the EEJ and its impact on radio communications and other space weather phenomena.
Previous studies often faced challenges in accurately measuring electron drift velocities due to the influence of these plasma waves. Specifically, the presence of type I irregularities could contaminate measurements, making it difficult to isolate the true electron drift. Furthermore, the role of small-scale turbulence in modifying the large-scale structure and behavior of the EEJ was not fully understood. This paper aims to address these issues by developing and applying a method to estimate turbulence parameters and corrected electron drift velocities, allowing for a more comprehensive analysis of EEJ dynamics.
Methods
The core of this study lies in a novel method for estimating turbulence parameters and correcting electron drift velocity measurements. This method is based on the non-linear short-scale turbulence theory developed by Ronchi et al. (1990). The key idea is to account for the anomalous diffusion of electrons caused by the electric fields of small-scale waves. This anomalous diffusion is mathematically represented as an "anomalous electron collision frequency" ($\nu_e^*$).
By incorporating this $\nu_e^*$ into the equations for electron drift velocity, the researchers can derive "corrected" drift velocities that are less affected by turbulence. The method involves:
- Matching experimental and theoretical drift velocity profiles: The observed electron drift velocities (from radar) are compared with theoretical models that include the turbulence contribution.
- Estimating turbulence parameters: By equating the observed and theoretical drift velocities and solving a system of equations, parameters like the electron density irregularity strength ($\delta n/n$) and the anomalous electron collision frequency ($\nu_e^*$) are estimated.
- Using co-located HF and VHF radars: The study leverages two different radar frequencies (HF at 18 MHz and VHF at 54.95 MHz) which probe different scale sizes of irregularities (8.3 m for HF and 2.7 m for VHF). This allows for a more robust estimation of turbulence parameters and cross-validation of results.
Datasets
The study utilizes data from co-located HF and VHF coherent backscatter radar systems operating at Trivandrum, India (8.5° N, 77° E). The observations were primarily conducted during daytime on magnetically quiet days. Specific dates for data analysis include:
- 22 December 1993
- 15 June 1995
- 25 October 1995
- 26 October 1995
The data were selected to be relatively free from contamination by type I irregularities, which is a known issue for VHF radar observations, especially during periods of strong EEJ activity.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Turbulence significantly impacts EEJ dynamics: The study demonstrates that small-scale plasma turbulence plays a crucial role in modifying the electron drift velocity and overall structure of the equatorial electrojet.
- A unified approach to turbulence estimation: The developed method, by incorporating anomalous collision frequency, provides a consistent way to estimate turbulence parameters ($\delta n/n$, $\nu_e^*$) and corrected drift velocities across different radar systems and conditions.
- Diurnal evolution of turbulence: The research reveals distinct patterns in the diurnal variation of turbulence parameters. Specifically, $\delta n/n$ tends to be higher during the building-up and decaying phases of the EEJ, while the backscattered power (indicating stronger irregularities at the probed scale sizes) is higher during the strong EEJ phase.
- HF radar's advantage: The HF radar's relative immunity to type I contamination proves valuable for estimating turbulence parameters during periods when VHF radar data might be compromised.
- Agreement with in-situ measurements: The deduced $\delta n/n$ values from radar observations show good agreement with values obtained from previous in-situ rocket measurements, lending strong support to the validity of the radar-based method.
Key Results
- The estimated $\delta n/n$ values from both HF and VHF radars fall within the range of 0-10%, consistent with previous in-situ measurements.
- The corrected electron drift velocity ($V_{ey}$) profiles, after accounting for turbulence, often show lower peak altitudes and larger magnitudes compared to uncorrected profiles.
- A direct relationship between $\delta n/n$ and backscattered power is observed during strong EEJ conditions, with $\delta n/n$ being high and power low during weaker EEJ phases (building up/decaying), and vice-versa during strong EEJ phases. This suggests that during strong EEJ, energy is efficiently transferred to smaller scales.
- The study provides detailed time-series plots of corrected $V_{ey}$, relative power, $\delta n/n$, and $\Delta H$ (a measure of the horizontal component of the Earth's magnetic field), illustrating the diurnal variations and interrelationships of these parameters.
Limitations and Future Work
- Type I contamination: While efforts were made to select data free from type I contamination, some instances were noted, particularly on 21 December 1993 and 15 June 1995, which limited the estimation of turbulence parameters during specific time intervals.
- Scale size limitations: The method is based on turbulence theory for scale sizes less than 100 m, and the radar systems probe specific scale sizes (2.7 m for VHF, 8.3 m for HF). The relationship between these probed scales and the broader turbulence spectrum is an area for further investigation.
- Geophysical conditions: The study primarily focuses on magnetically quiet days. Future work could explore the impact of different geophysical conditions, such as highly disturbed or moderately disturbed times, on plasma turbulence in the EEJ.
- Seasonal variations: The paper suggests that studying seasonal variations in plasma turbulence parameters would be a valuable next step.
- Model improvement: The authors believe that the database generated from such studies can be used to improve existing electrojet models.
Summary updated