Sparsity in Algorithms, Combinatorics and Logic (Dagstuhl Seminar 21391)

Daniel Král', Michal Pilipczuk, Sebastian Siebertz, Blair D. Sullivan

TL;DR

This report summarizes Dagstuhl Seminar 21391, which convened researchers to explore the multifaceted concept of "sparsity" across algorithms, combinatorics, and logic. The seminar aimed to foster interdisciplinary collaboration and advance the understanding of how sparsity can be leveraged for efficient algorithms and theoretical insights, particularly in graph theory and logic.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of formally defining and effectively utilizing "sparsity" in computational structures, especially graphs. While sparsity is intuitively understood as a desirable property for efficient algorithms, its precise definition is elusive and has led to various paradigms (e.g., bounded degree, bounded treewidth). These existing paradigms often face a trade-off: being too restrictive for real-world applications or too general to yield strong algorithmic results. The seminar aimed to bridge this gap by bringing together experts from different fields to explore common ground, develop unified theories, and identify new applications of sparsity.

Methods

This report is not a research paper presenting novel methods but rather a summary of a seminar. The "methods" discussed are the research directions and problems explored by the participants. These include:

  • Model-checking on locally well-behaved structures: Investigating whether fixed-parameter tractability for First-Order (FO) logic model-checking holds for graph classes that are "logically disguised" through FO transductions, building on existing results for classes with bounded treewidth or cliquewidth.
  • Transducing paths from classes of unbounded shrubdepth: Exploring duality theorems for First-Order transductions, specifically the conjecture that classes with unbounded shrubdepth transduce the class of all paths.
  • Treedepth vs. pathwidth: Investigating conjectures relating treedepth and pathwidth, particularly whether graphs with bounded treedepth have bounded pathwidth or contain specific graph structures as minors.
  • Treewidth-twin-width: Studying a new graph parameter, treewidth-twin-width, which combines notions of twin-width and treewidth, and examining its relationship to existing parameters.
  • Integer programs equivalent to ones with bounded primal treedepth: Relating the primal treedepth of integer programming instances to their structural properties, aiming to design algorithms for constructing equivalent instances with small primal treedepth.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The report focuses on theoretical research and discussions rather than empirical evaluations on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interdisciplinary Synergy: The seminar highlighted the significant synergy between graph theory, logic, and algorithm design in understanding sparsity. Concepts like bounded expansion and nowhere denseness serve as crucial bridges between these fields.
  • Formalizing Sparsity: The lack of a single, universally accepted definition of sparsity is a core challenge. The seminar explored various formalizations and their implications for algorithmic tractability and theoretical expressiveness.
  • Sparsity as a Tractability Frontier: Sparsity-based paradigms are identified as key to delimiting the boundary of algorithmic tractability for problems expressible in first-order logic.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: A notable theme was the desire to connect theoretical advancements in sparsity with real-world applications, acknowledging that practical implementations often require careful engineering and problem-specific solutions.
  • New Graph Parameters: The exploration of parameters like twin-width and its variants (treewidth-twin-width) suggests new avenues for characterizing graph structure and complexity.

Key Results

As this is a report on a seminar, it doesn't present single, overarching quantitative results. Instead, it documents the outcomes of discussions and working groups, which often involved progress on specific conjectures or the formulation of new research directions. For example, the report mentions:

  • Progress on proving theorems related to FO model-checking on certain graph classes.
  • Investigations into conjectures about graph minors and their relationship to sparsity parameters.
  • Discussions that led to a better understanding of the interplay between different graph parameters like treedepth, pathwidth, and twin-width.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Definition of Sparsity: The report acknowledges that a unified definition of sparsity remains an open challenge, and different formalizations have their own strengths and weaknesses.
  • Real-World Applications: While the seminar aimed to bridge theory and practice, the report notes that the area of real-life applications of sparsity-based methods is still "fledgling." Further work is needed to translate theoretical insights into practical tools.
  • Open Problems: Many of the working group discussions focused on resolving existing conjectures and identifying new open problems, indicating that this is an active and evolving research area. Future work will likely involve pursuing these open problems, developing more robust theoretical frameworks, and exploring new applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

This report documents the program and the outcomes of Dagstuhl Seminar 21391 "Sparsity in Algorithms, Combinatorics and Logic". The seminar took place in a hybrid format from September 26 - October 1, 2021 and brought together 61 researchers. This report includes a discussion of the motivation of the seminar, presentation of the overall organization, abstracts of talks, and a report from each of the working groups.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kral2021sparsity,
  author = {Daniel Král' and Michal Pilipczuk and Sebastian Siebertz and Blair D. Sullivan},
  title = {{Sparsity in Algorithms, Combinatorics and Logic (Dagstuhl Seminar 21391)}},
  booktitle = {Dagstuhl Reports},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=R3Sffiag93},
}
Figure