Sparse Gaussian processes for solving nonlinear PDEs

Rui Meng, Xianjin Yang

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Sparse Gaussian Process (SGP) method to efficiently solve nonlinear Partial Differential Equations (PDEs). By reformulating the problem in a "condensed" subspace, it significantly reduces computational cost while maintaining accuracy, making it a promising approach for complex PDE problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solving nonlinear Partial Differential Equations (PDEs) is a fundamental challenge in many scientific and engineering fields. Traditional numerical methods like finite difference and finite element methods can struggle with the "curse of dimensions." While Gaussian Processes (GPs) have shown promise for solving PDEs by approximating solutions in a Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Space (RKHS), they suffer from a high computational burden, particularly due to the cubic complexity of matrix inversion. This paper addresses the need for a more efficient GP-based method that can achieve comparable accuracy with reduced computational cost. The core problem is to find a "condensed" subspace within the RKHS that captures sufficient information for accurate PDE approximation without the expense of the full RKHS.

Methods

The authors propose a Sparse Gaussian Process (SGP) method. The key idea is to leverage "inducing points" to define a low-rank kernel, which in turn defines a "condensed" RKHS. This condensed space is a subspace of the original RKHS and is generated by linear operators applied to the kernel. The method reformulates the PDE solution as a minimizer of an optimal recovery problem within this condensed subspace. This approach significantly reduces the size of the matrices that need to be inverted, from the number of samples to the number of inducing points, leading to computational savings. The paper provides a rigorous mathematical framework, including existence proofs and error analysis, for this SGP method.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on numerical experiments using synthetic data generated from known PDE solutions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Condensed" Subspaces for PDEs: The paper introduces the concept of a "condensed" subspace within an RKHS for solving PDEs. This subspace, defined by inducing points and linear operators, is hypothesized to contain the essential information for accurate solutions, thus avoiding the computational cost of the full RKHS.
  • SGP as a Computational Shortcut: By using a low-rank kernel derived from inducing points, the SGP method effectively approximates the full GP kernel. This allows for significant computational speedups, particularly in matrix inversion, which is a bottleneck in standard GP methods.
  • Trade-off Between Accuracy and Efficiency: The numerical results highlight a trade-off between the number of inducing points and accuracy. While too few inducing points can lead to a loss of accuracy, the SGP method demonstrates that a significantly smaller number of inducing points (less than half the total samples) can achieve comparable accuracy to the full GP method.
  • Generalization of GP for PDEs: The proposed SGP framework is presented as an extension of existing GP methods for PDEs, allowing for more general positive semi-definite kernels.

Key Results

  • Computational Speedup: The SGP method significantly reduces computational cost. For instance, in the nonlinear elliptic equation example, using less than half the uniform samples as inducing points achieved comparable accuracy to the GP method using the same number of samples.
  • Comparable Accuracy: The numerical experiments demonstrate that the SGP method achieves accuracy comparable to the standard GP method, even when using a substantially smaller number of inducing points. For example, in Table 1, SGP with M=1200 inducing points achieves similar L∞ errors to GP with N=9600 samples.
  • Effective for Various PDEs: The method was tested on several types of nonlinear PDEs, including a nonlinear elliptic equation, a stationary mean field game system, Burger's equation, and a nonlinear parabolic equation, showing consistent performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hyperparameter Learning: The paper acknowledges that the choice of inducing point locations and kernel hyperparameters significantly impacts accuracy. While they fix inducing point locations in experiments, they suggest future work on hyperparameter learning, potentially guided by the probabilistic interpretation of the SGP method.
  • Optimization of Inducing Points: The current approach often samples inducing points from the data points. The paper suggests that investigating better strategies for selecting inducing point positions could further improve performance.
  • Full Optimization of Parameters: The paper mentions that the objective function in hyperparameter learning can be highly nonlinear and costly to compute, suggesting future work on more efficient optimization strategies for these parameters.
  • Handling Constraints: For some problems, the method relies on techniques for eliminating variables or relaxation to handle constraints, indicating potential areas for further methodological development.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article proposes an efficient numerical method for solving nonlinear partial differential equations (PDEs) based on sparse Gaussian processes (SGPs). Gaussian processes (GPs) have been extensively studied for solving PDEs by formulating the problem of finding a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS) to approximate a PDE solution. The approximated solution lies in the span of base functions generated by evaluating derivatives of different orders of kernels at sample points. However, the RKHS specified by GPs can result in an expensive computational burden due to the cubic computation order of the matrix inverse. Therefore, we conjecture that a solution exists on a ``condensed" subspace that can achieve similar approximation performance, and we propose a SGP-based method to reformulate the optimization problem in the ``condensed" subspace. This significantly reduces the computation burden while retaining desirable accuracy. The paper rigorously formulates this problem and provides error analysis and numerical experiments to demonstrate the effectiveness of this method. The numerical experiments show that the SGP method uses fewer than half the uniform samples as inducing points and achieves comparable accuracy to the GP method using the same number of uniform samples, resulting in a significant reduction in computational cost. Our contributions include formulating the nonlinear PDE problem as an optimization problem on a ``condensed" subspace of RKHS using SGP, as well as providing an existence proof and rigorous error analysis. Furthermore, our method can be viewed as an extension of the GP method to account for general positive semi-definite kernels.
BibTeX
@article{meng2023sparse,
  author = {Rui Meng and Xianjin Yang},
  title = {{Sparse Gaussian processes for solving nonlinear PDEs}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=grTRfxVv7i},
}
Figure