Spacecraft Line-of-Sight Control Using a Single Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro

Hyungjoo Yoon, Panagiotis TsiotrasJournal of Guidance Control and Dynamics 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel control strategy for spacecraft using a single Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro (VSCMG). It demonstrates that while full attitude control is impossible with just one VSCMG due to momentum conservation, it's feasible to control the spacecraft's angular velocity to zero while simultaneously pointing a specific body-fixed axis (like a camera or antenna) towards a desired inertial direction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional spacecraft attitude control typically requires at least three independent control torques to achieve full three-dimensional attitude control. This paper tackles the challenge of underactuation, specifically when a spacecraft has only one control actuator: a single Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro (VSCMG). The core problem is that the conservation of angular momentum inherently limits the achievable final states. While previous work focused on just stabilizing the angular velocity to zero, this paper goes further by aiming to achieve a specific partial attitude control objective – pointing a designated body-axis – alongside angular velocity stabilization, all with a single VSCMG. This is particularly relevant for missions where precise pointing of a sensor or antenna is crucial, but full attitude control is not strictly necessary, or as a way to maintain partial control in the event of actuator failures.

Methods

The authors develop a multi-stage control strategy.

  1. Feasible Orientation Parametrization: They first characterize the set of all possible final spacecraft orientations at rest that are consistent with the conservation of angular momentum. This involves introducing a pair of angles to describe these feasible states.
  2. Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) Control: For initial conditions close to the desired state, an LQR controller is designed based on a linearized model of the system. This controller aims to achieve the partial attitude control objective.
  3. Nonlinear Multistage Control: For larger initial conditions, a more robust nonlinear controller is proposed. This controller operates in three stages:
  4. Stage 1: A nonlinear controller focuses on reducing the spacecraft's angular velocity to near zero.
  5. Stage 2: Once the angular velocity is sufficiently low, the controller switches to stabilize both the angular velocity and the gimbal angle, ensuring the VSCMG's spin axis aligns correctly with the desired final state.
  6. Stage 3: Finally, the LQR controller is used to fine-tune the orientation of the designated body-axis to the target inertial direction, while maintaining zero angular velocity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and simulation using a defined spacecraft model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Partial Control is Achievable: The most significant insight is that even with a single VSCMG, it's possible to achieve a useful form of partial attitude control (line-of-sight pointing) by carefully managing the spacecraft's angular velocity and the VSCMG's spin.
  • Momentum Conservation as a Constraint and Enabler: The paper highlights how angular momentum conservation, while limiting full attitude control, also defines the feasible set of final states, which can be exploited for control design.
  • Multistage Control for Robustness: The proposed three-stage control strategy is crucial for handling a wide range of initial conditions, transitioning from aggressive angular velocity reduction to precise orientation control.
  • VSCMG Versatility: The variable speed capability of the VSCMG is key, allowing for more complex control actions than a conventional reaction wheel or CMG.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully demonstrates, through simulations, that the proposed multistage control strategy can drive the spacecraft's angular velocity to zero and point a specific body-fixed axis (the b₁ axis in their formulation) towards a desired inertial direction.
  • The simulations show convergence of angular velocity, gimbal angle, and the target body-axis to their desired values.
  • The control strategy is shown to be effective for large initial conditions, a significant improvement over purely local linear control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Axisymmetric Assumption: The control design and analysis in the paper make simplifying assumptions, such as the spacecraft being inertially axisymmetric. The authors acknowledge that future work should address the general case of a nonaxisymmetric spacecraft.
  • Zero Initial Angular Momentum: The paper primarily deals with cases where the initial angular momentum is non-zero. Extending the analysis to the zero initial angular momentum case is suggested as future work.
  • Robustness: While the controller is designed for a specific model, robustness to external disturbances and parameter uncertainties is not explicitly addressed and would be a valuable extension.
  • Actuator Limitations: The paper does not consider physical limitations of the VSCMG, such as torque or speed limits.

The authors suggest that future work should also explore the general case of multiple VSCMGs and investigate robustness issues.

Summary updated

Abstract

Complete attitude control of a spacecraft is not possible with only one single-gimbal variable-speed control moment gyro due to the conservation of angular momentum. However, partial attitude control without violating the angular momentum conservation principle is still possible. In this paper feedback controllers using only one single-gimbal variable-speed control moment gyro are presented that drive all three components of the angular velocity of a rigid spacecraft to zero, while at the same time a spacecraft body-axis points along an arbitrary inertial direction. To solve this problem, we first introduce a pair of angles to parametrize all feasible final spacecraft orientations at rest without violating the angular momentum constraint Based on this parametrization, an LQR control law is designed to locally achieve the control objective. Afterwards, a multistage control law is proposed to achieve the same control objective for large initial conditions.
BibTeX
@article{yoon2006spacecraft,
  author = {Hyungjoo Yoon and Panagiotis Tsiotras},
  title = {{Spacecraft Line-of-Sight Control Using a Single Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro}},
  journal = {Journal of Guidance Control and Dynamics},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.2514/1.18777},
}
Figure