Spacecraft Angular Velocity and Line-of-Sight Control Using A Single-Gimbal Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro

Hyungjoo Yoon, Panagiotis TsiotrasAIAA 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel control strategy for spacecraft using a single Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro (VSCMG) to achieve partial attitude control, specifically pointing a body-fixed axis (like a camera or antenna) towards a desired inertial direction, even when complete attitude control is impossible due to momentum conservation. They introduce a multi-stage nonlinear control approach that effectively stabilizes angular velocity and achieves this line-of-sight pointing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional spacecraft attitude control often relies on multiple actuators (like reaction wheels or CMGs) to achieve full 3-axis control. However, there's a growing interest in underactuated systems, where fewer actuators are available, due to potential cost savings, weight reduction, and robustness against actuator failures. A key challenge with a single VSCMG is that it cannot achieve complete attitude control because of the fundamental principle of angular momentum conservation. This means the spacecraft can't arbitrarily reach any final orientation. The paper addresses this by focusing on a specific, achievable partial control objective: stabilizing the spacecraft's angular velocity and precisely pointing a designated body-fixed axis towards a target in space. This is crucial for missions where only a specific sensor or antenna needs to be directed, rather than the entire spacecraft's orientation.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-stage control strategy to tackle the problem.

  • Parametrization of Feasible Orientations: They first characterize all possible "rest" orientations of the spacecraft that are achievable given the VSCMG's limitations and the conservation of angular momentum. This is done by parameterizing these orientations with a pair of angles.
  • Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) Control: For local stabilization around the desired equilibrium, they design an LQR controller. This is a standard optimal control technique that minimizes a quadratic cost function, balancing state errors and control effort.
  • Nonlinear Multi-Stage Control: To achieve control from arbitrary initial conditions (i.e., "in the large"), they develop a three-stage nonlinear control approach:
  • Angular Velocity Stabilization: A nonlinear controller is used to reduce the spacecraft's angular velocity to near zero.
  • Gimbal Angle and Wheel Speed Control: Once the angular velocity is sufficiently low, a second nonlinear controller takes over to drive the gimbal angle and wheel speed towards their desired final values, ensuring momentum conservation is maintained.
  • LQR for Final Stabilization: Finally, the LQR controller from the first stage is used to precisely stabilize the remaining attitude errors (specifically, the line-of-sight pointing) and ensure the spacecraft reaches the desired orientation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and simulation-based validation using a defined spacecraft model and initial conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Partial Control is Achievable: The core insight is that while full attitude control is impossible with a single VSCMG, a specific and useful partial control objective (line-of-sight pointing) is achievable. This opens doors for missions with reduced actuator requirements.
  • Feasible Orientations are Key: Understanding and parameterizing the set of achievable final orientations is crucial for designing effective controllers. The paper shows these are constrained by the initial angular momentum.
  • Multi-Stage Control for Robustness: A staged approach is necessary to handle large initial errors. The transition between stages ensures that the system is always in a state where the subsequent controller can effectively operate, moving from global angular velocity reduction to precise line-of-sight aiming.
  • VSCMG Versatility: The variable speed capability of the VSCMG is leveraged not just for torque generation but also to manage the angular momentum conservation constraint, allowing for controlled transitions between states.

Key Results

The paper presents a control methodology that, through simulations, demonstrates:

  • Successful stabilization of the spacecraft's angular velocity to near zero.
  • Accurate pointing of a body-fixed axis (simulated as the b1-axis) to a desired inertial direction.
  • The multi-stage control strategy effectively manages the transitions between different control objectives, ensuring overall stability and performance.
  • The simulations show that the proposed controller can achieve the desired line-of-sight pointing within a reasonable time frame (around 200 seconds in the example).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Semi-Global Stability: The paper notes that while the controller provides "essentially global stability" or "regional stability," it might exclude a "nowhere dense subset" of initial conditions. This means that in extremely rare cases, the controller might not guarantee convergence.
  • Assumptions for Design: The control design relies on certain simplifying assumptions, such as neglecting the gimbal acceleration term and assuming a constant inertia matrix during controller design. While the simulations use the full nonlinear equations, the controller derivation is simplified.
  • Tuning of Gains: The paper mentions that controller gains and LQR weights are chosen by trial and error for the simulations. Developing more systematic methods for gain selection would be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their work is useful for missions requiring two-axis stabilization or for mitigating actuator failures. Further exploration of these applications and more advanced control techniques could be future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is well known that complete attitude control of a spacecraft is not possible with only one single-gimbal Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro (VSCMG) due to the conservation of the angular momentum. However, partial attitude control without violating the angular momentum conservation principle is still possible. In this paper, feedback controllers that stabilize the angular velocity vector of a rigid spacecraft with additional partial attitude stabilization using a single VSCMG are presented. A pair of angles is chosen to parameterize all feasible final spacecraft orientations at rest. Based on this parametrization, an LQR control law is designed to locally stabilize the spacecraft angular velocity, while also controlling a given spacecraft body-axis in inertial space. A multi-stage control law is also suggested to achieve the same control objective in the large.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yoon2005spacecraft,
  author = {Hyungjoo Yoon and Panagiotis Tsiotras},
  title = {{Spacecraft Angular Velocity and Line-of-Sight Control Using A Single-Gimbal Variable-Speed Control Moment Gyro}},
  booktitle = {AIAA},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.2514/6.2005-6393},
}
Figure