Space Charge Driven Emittance Growth and the Effect of Octupoles in IOTA

David Feigelson, Tanaji Sen, J.-f. Ostiguy, Runze Li

This paper investigates the physics of high-intensity proton beams within the Integrable Optics Test Accelerator (IOTA) at Fermilab. As researchers push for higher beam intensities, "space charge"—the collective electromagnetic repulsion between particles in a bunch—becomes a dominant force that degrades beam quality. The authors explore why beams "blow up" (emittance growth) and whether nonlinear magnets called octupoles can help or hinder this process.

TL;DR

Emittance growth in IOTA’s high-intensity proton beams is primarily driven by initial "RMS mismatch" between the beam and the accelerator lattice, occurring almost instantly after injection. While matching beam optics at high-symmetry locations can eliminate particle loss, it fails to stop emittance growth, and the addition of octupoles significantly restricts the "safe zone" (dynamic aperture) for the beam.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In accelerator physics, emittance is a measure of the "size" and "orderliness" of a particle beam in phase space. For high-intensity proton beams, space charge forces cause the emittance to grow rapidly, leading to beam degradation and particle loss.

The IOTA storage ring is designed to test "integrable optics"—a method of using nonlinear forces (like those from octupoles) to create a spread in particle frequencies (tunes) that protects the beam from resonances. However, these same nonlinearities can shrink the dynamic aperture (the region where particle motion remains stable). The authors aim to distinguish between emittance growth caused by simple geometric mismatching and growth caused by the complex nonlinearities of the octupoles.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Theoretical Modeling: They used a simplified 1D RMS mismatch theory based on Sacharer’s envelope equations. This theory treats the beam as a uniform ellipsoid and calculates how "free energy" from a mismatched beam size is converted into thermal motion (emittance).
  2. Numerical Simulation: They used pyORBIT, a Particle-In-Cell (PIC) code, to perform multi-particle tracking. This allowed them to simulate realistic effects like dispersion, transverse coupling, and various particle distributions (Gaussian vs. "Flat-top").

They specifically compared two matching strategies: matching the beam at the injection point versus matching it at the center of the octupole insertion region where the horizontal and vertical beam functions ($\beta_x, \beta_y$) are equal.

Datasets

As a simulation-heavy physics paper, the "datasets" consist of the nominal design parameters for the IOTA ring:

  • Beam Types: Bunched beams (3D packets) and coasting beams (continuous streams).
  • Intensities: Ranging from "low" ($10^9$ protons) to "full design intensity" ($10^{11}$ protons).
  • Distributions: 6D Gaussian distributions and "Flat-topped" distributions (uniform charge density within a rectangular boundary).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Instant" Blow-up: Most emittance growth happens within the first few tens of turns. This timescale matches the plasma oscillation period of the beam, confirming that the growth is a collective space-charge effect rather than a slow accumulation of resonance errors.
  • Mismatch is King: At high intensities, the specific shape of the beam distribution (Gaussian vs. Flat-top) matters very little. The primary driver of emittance growth is the RMS mismatch—the difference between the beam's initial size and the "ideal" size the accelerator expects.
  • The Octupole Trade-off: Octupoles are intended to stabilize the beam, but they drastically reduce the dynamic aperture to about $3\sigma$ (three times the standard deviation of the beam size). This necessitates "truncating" the beam (scraping off the edges) to prevent immediate, massive particle loss.
  • Dispersion's Hidden Role: The simulations revealed that dispersion (how different energy particles take different paths) increases the horizontal beam size, which actually reduces horizontal space charge forces but increases vertical emittance growth.

Key Results

  • Theory vs. Reality: The simplified 1D mismatch theory accounted for over 50% of the emittance growth observed in complex simulations for bunched beams and was accurate within 2% for coasting beams.
  • Loss Mitigation: By matching the beam at the center of the octupole insert, the researchers reduced particle loss to 0%, a significant improvement over the 0.2% loss seen with standard injection matching.
  • Emittance Growth: Despite zero particle loss, emittance still grew by a factor of 8 to 10 at full intensity, suggesting that RMS matching alone cannot preserve beam brightness.
  • Octupole Impact: At full intensity with octupoles, losses reached 70-80% unless the beam was truncated to $1.5\sigma$. Even with truncation, emittance growth remained severe.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their 1D theory is "crude" because it ignores transverse coupling and dispersion. While it predicts the amount of growth well, it doesn't fully explain why matching reduces loss but fails to curb emittance growth.

Future work will likely focus on:

  • Refining the mismatch theory to include 2D/3D effects.
  • Investigating why emittance growth remains so high even when the beam is "matched."
  • Exploring more sophisticated "slow initialization" techniques to better transition beams into the nonlinear environment of the octupole inserts.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Integrable Optics Test Accelerator (IOTA) at Fermilab is a small machine dedicated to a broad frontier accelerator physics program. An important aspect of this program is to investigate the potential benefits of the resonance free tune spread achievable with integrable optics to store and accelerate high intensity proton beams for which space charge is significant. In this context, a good understanding of proton beam emittance growth and particle loss mechanisms is essential. Assuming nominal design parameters, simulations show that for a bunched beam, the bulk of emittance growth takes place immediately following injection, typically within tens of turns. We attempt to account for this growth using a simplified RMS mismatch theory; some of its limitations and possible improvements are briefly discussed. We then compare theoretical predictions to simulations performed using the PIC code pyORBIT. Further exploring ways to mitigate emittance growth and reduce particle loss, we compare two beam matching strategies: (1) matching at the injection point (2) matching at the center of the nonlinear (octupole) insertion region where $β_x = β_y$. To observe how nonlinearity affects emittance growth and whether it dominates growth due to mismatch, we track two different distributions. Finally, we explore the potential of using octupoles in a quasi-integrable configuration to mitigate growth using a variety of initial distributions both at reduced and full intensities.
BibTeX
@misc{feigelson2021space,
  author = {David Feigelson and Tanaji Sen and J.-F. Ostiguy and Runze Li},
  title = {{Space Charge Driven Emittance Growth and the Effect of Octupoles in IOTA}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.15306},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.15306},
}

Loading related content...

Figure