TL;DR
This paper investigates the drivers behind the recent increase in atmospheric methane concentrations between 2006 and 2008. Using two different atmospheric inversion models and a wetland emission model, the study attributes the majority of the methane increase to tropical natural wetlands, particularly in 2007, with a notable contribution from high-latitude wetlands.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Atmospheric methane (CH4) is a potent greenhouse gas, and after a period of relative stability, its growth rate began to increase around 2007. Understanding the sources and sinks responsible for this resurgence is crucial for climate modeling and mitigation strategies. While natural wetlands are known to be a major source of CH4, and anthropogenic activities also contribute significantly, pinpointing the exact contributions of different sources to the observed increase, especially on a year-to-year basis, has been challenging. This paper aims to disentangle these contributions by attributing the observed changes in atmospheric methane during 2006-2008 to specific regions and emission types.
Methods
The study employs two primary methodologies:
- Atmospheric Inversions (INV1 and INV2): These are "top-down" approaches that use atmospheric CH4 concentration measurements to infer the distribution and magnitude of CH4 sources and sinks. Both models are based on Bayesian formalism and assimilate CH4 observations into atmospheric chemical-transport models. INV1 uses a large-region approach with monthly emissions, while INV2 employs a variational approach with finer spatial resolution and daily data assimilation.
- Process-Based Wetland Emission Model (ORCHIDEE): This is a "bottom-up" model that simulates CH4 emissions from natural wetlands based on physical processes like hydrology, temperature, and soil carbon. It uses satellite-derived data for wetland extent and climate forcing data.
The researchers compare the results from these models to attribute the observed changes in atmospheric methane. They also investigate the role of OH radicals (a key CH4 sink) and explore the impact of different climate forcing datasets on the wetland model.
Datasets
The study utilizes several datasets:
- Atmospheric CH4 Observations: Data from surface measurement stations (NOAA/ESRL, CSIRO, IPSL/LSCE) and flask observations.
- Satellite Data: Used for wetland extent (Prigent et al., 2001, 2007) and for atmospheric CH4 column-averaged mixing ratios (SCIAMACHY on ENVISAT).
- Climate Forcing Data: Including CRUNCEP, NCEP, and ERA40 reanalysis data for precipitation and other meteorological variables.
- Prior Emission Inventories: Used as initial estimates for the inversion models.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Tropical Wetlands Dominate: The study strongly suggests that tropical natural wetlands were the primary driver of the global methane increase in 2007, accounting for a significant portion of the anomaly. This highlights the sensitivity of wetland emissions to tropical climate variations.
- High Latitudes Contribute: Abnormally high wetland emissions from high latitudes also played a significant role in 2007, contributing a substantial fraction to the global anomaly. This indicates that warming at higher latitudes can also influence methane emissions.
- Model Discrepancies for 2008: While there was good agreement for 2007, the wetland emission model (ORCHIDEE) projected a much larger anomaly in 2008 than the inversion models. This suggests that the wetland model might be overly sensitive to precipitation, or that other factors not fully captured by the models are at play.
- OH Radical Role is Minor: Changes in OH radicals, a major sink for methane, were found to be small (<1%) in the inversion models and had a minimal impact on the inferred methane emissions, suggesting that source changes are the dominant factor.
- Transport Matters: The study emphasizes that simply looking at surface data is insufficient; atmospheric transport plays a crucial role in how methane anomalies are observed globally, particularly in differentiating between tropical and high-latitude contributions.
Key Results
- Global Emission Increase: Global methane emissions increased by an average of 19 Tg in 2007 and 13 Tg in 2008 compared to the 1999-2006 baseline.
- 2007 Anomaly Attribution: In 2007, tropical emissions accounted for 60-75% of the global anomaly, with natural wetlands contributing about 66%. High-latitude wetlands contributed 15-30% of the global anomaly.
- 2008 Anomaly: The 2008 anomaly was more uncertain, with a wider range of estimates (6-21 Tg) from the inversions. The wetland model projected a significantly larger positive anomaly for 2008 than the inversions.
- Consistency with Satellite Data: The CH4 column-averaged mixing ratio anomalies derived from satellite observations (SCIAMACHY) were found to be consistent with the inversion model results for South America, supporting the inferred flux changes.
Limitations and Future Work
- 2008 Uncertainty: The paper acknowledges significant uncertainties in the 2008 flux anomaly, suggesting the need for additional constraints on both the inversion models (more assimilated observations) and the wetland model (better quantification of precipitation sensitivity).
- Wetland Model Sensitivity: The discrepancy between the wetland model and inversions for 2008 points to a potential oversensitivity of the ORCHIDEE model to precipitation, and future work should focus on refining this aspect.
- Regional Source Separation: While the study provides global and regional insights, further work is needed to precisely separate emissions from different source types, especially in regions with limited observational data.
- Long-term Trends: The paper notes that while the 2007-2008 period saw a significant anomaly, it's too early to determine if it represents a sustained long-term trend, especially given ongoing global anthropogenic emissions. Future monitoring and analysis are crucial.
Summary updated