Source attribution of cloud condensation nuclei and their impact on stratocumulus clouds and radiation in the south-eastern Atlantic

Haochi Che, Philip Stier, Duncan Watson‐Parris, Hamish Gordon, Lucia Deaconu

TL;DR

This study uses the UKESM1 Earth System Model to pinpoint the sources of cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) in the South-Eastern Atlantic (SEA) and their subsequent impact on stratocumulus clouds and radiation. It reveals that while free troposphere nucleation is the dominant source of CCN in the marine boundary layer, biomass burning (BB) aerosols play a crucial, albeit indirect, role in influencing cloud properties and radiative forcing, particularly during the BB season.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine stratocumulus clouds, particularly those over the South-Eastern Atlantic (SEA), are vital for regulating Earth's climate, acting as a significant "air conditioner." However, the complex interactions between aerosols and these clouds introduce substantial uncertainty into climate projections. A key pathway for this interaction is through aerosols acting as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN), which influence cloud droplet formation, liquid water content, and ultimately, the cloud's radiative effect. While biomass burning (BB) aerosols are known to be prevalent in the SEA region, their precise contribution to CCN formation and their subsequent impact on cloud properties and radiative forcing remain debated. This paper aims to disentangle the contributions of various aerosol sources (emissions and atmospheric processes) to CCN in the SEA and quantify their impact on cloud characteristics and radiative balance.

Methods

The researchers employed the United Kingdom Earth System Model (UKESM1) to simulate aerosol and cloud processes over the SEA region for the years 2016-2017. To attribute the impact of different sources, they ran multiple simulations: a baseline simulation and several sensitivity runs where specific emission sources (anthropogenic, biomass burning, sea salt, DMS, dust) and atmospheric processes (secondary organic aerosol formation, boundary layer nucleation, total aerosol nucleation) were turned off. By comparing the results of these simulations to the baseline, they could isolate the contributions of each source to CCN concentration, cloud droplet number concentration (CDNC), liquid water path (LWP), and radiative forcing. Model evaluation was performed using data from aircraft campaigns (ORACLES, CLARIFY) and in-situ measurements (LASIC).

Datasets

  • UKESM1 Model Simulations: The core of the study relies on simulations from the UKESM1 Earth System Model.
  • CMIP6 Emission Data: Used for anthropogenic emissions for the year 2014.
  • GFAS Version 1 Data: Used for biomass burning emissions, scaled by a factor of 2.
  • ERA-Interim Data: Used for nudging horizontal wind fields.
  • Reynolds Sea Surface Temperature and Sea Ice Data: Used as prescribed boundary conditions.
  • Aircraft Observation Data:
    • NASA ORACLES (Observations of Aerosols above CLouds and their interactionS) (2016-2017)
    • CLARIFY (CLoud-Aerosol-Radiation Interaction and Forcing) (2017)
  • In-situ Observation Data:
    • LASIC (Layered Atlantic Smoke Interactions with Clouds) (2016-2017)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Free Troposphere Nucleation Dominance: Aerosol nucleation in the free and upper troposphere, followed by subsidence, is the primary source of CCN in the SEA marine boundary layer, contributing about 41% annually. This highlights the importance of processes occurring far above the surface.
  • Biomass Burning's Indirect Impact: While anthropogenic emissions are the largest emission source of CCN in the marine boundary layer, BB aerosols have a disproportionately larger impact on cloud properties and radiative forcing, especially during the BB season. This is largely due to their location above the inversion layer, where their radiative effects (short-wave absorption) can significantly influence cloud dynamics.
  • Absorption Matters: The short-wave absorption by BB aerosols plays a critical role. It strengthens the temperature inversion, reduces entrainment of dry air, and consequently increases cloud liquid water path (LWP) and cloud droplet number concentration (CDNC), leading to a significant radiative effect.
  • CCN vs. CDNC/LWP Discrepancies: BB's contribution to CDNC and LWP is greater than its direct contribution to CCN concentration in the marine boundary layer. This underscores that the location and radiative properties of aerosols are as important as their sheer number in influencing clouds.

Key Results

  • Marine Boundary Layer CCN:
    • Free/upper troposphere nucleation: ~41% (annual average)
    • Anthropogenic emissions: ~26% (annual average)
    • Biomass burning (BB) emissions: ~17% (annual average)
  • Cloud Layer CCN:
    • Aerosol nucleation: ~36%
    • BB emissions: ~34%
    • Anthropogenic emissions: ~31%
  • CDNC: Total aerosol nucleation is the dominant source overall. Anthropogenic sources are the largest emission contributors annually, followed closely by BB. During the BB season, BB and nucleation are equally dominant.
  • LWP: BB aerosols contribute significantly to LWP, second only to aerosol nucleation on an annual average. During the BB season, BB's impact on LWP is twice that of total aerosol nucleation.
  • Radiative Forcing: BB aerosols exhibit a positive radiative forcing from aerosol-radiation interactions (RFari) in the cloud box region, but their net effective radiative forcing remains negative due to their cloud effects. Sea salt shows a notable cooling effect.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Biases: The study acknowledges potential model biases, including an underestimation of peak CCN during the BB season, which might be linked to uncertainties in BB emissions and the representation of BC particle coatings. Cloud cover is also noted as potentially biased high in this region.
  • Seasonal Variability: The analysis focuses on averages during the BB season. Future work should investigate the month-to-month variations in aerosol impacts, as burning conditions and marine boundary layer evolution change.
  • Vertical Layering: Further investigation into the specific effects of aerosols at different altitudes (boundary layer, cloud layer, free troposphere) on clouds and radiation is recommended.
  • High-Resolution Data: The LASIC observations offer valuable data for validating model performance at higher resolutions, which can benefit future studies.
  • Long-term Trends: Long-term LASIC observations can also support studies on seasonal variations and long-term trends.

Summary updated

Abstract

The semi-permanent stratocumulus clouds over the south-eastern Atlantic Ocean (SEA) can act as an “air conditioner” to the regional and global climate system. The interaction of aerosols and clouds becomes important in this region and can lead to negative radiative effects, partially offsetting the positive radiative forcing of greenhouse gases. A key pathway by which aerosols affect cloud properties is by acting as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN). In this paper, we use the United Kingdom Earth System Model (UKESM1) to investigate the sources of CCN (from emissions and atmospheric processes) in the SEA as well as the response of the cloud droplet number concentration (CDNC), the cloud liquid water path (LWP), and radiative forcing to these sources during 2016 and 2017. Overall, free and upper troposphere nucleated aerosols are the dominant source of the boundary layer CCN concentration at 0.2 % supersaturation (CCN0.2 %), contributing an annual average of ∼ 41 % as they subside and entrain into the marine boundary layer, which is consistent with observations highlighting the important role of nucleation in the boundary layer CCN concentration. In terms of emission sources, anthropogenic emissions (from energy, industry, agriculture, etc.) contribute the most to the annual average CCN0.2 % in the marine boundary layer (∼ 26 %), followed by biomass burning (BB, ∼ 17 %). In the cloud layer, BB contributes about 34 % of the annual CCN0.2 %, midway between the contributions from aerosol nucleation (36 %) and anthropogenic sources (31 %). The contribution of aerosols from different sources to the CDNC is consistent with their contribution to CCN0.2 % within the marine boundary layer, with free and upper troposphere aerosol nucleation being the most important source of the CDNC overall. In terms of emission sources, anthropogenic sources are also the largest contributors to the annual average CDNC, closely followed by BB. However, during the BB season, BB and free and upper troposphere aerosol nucleation are equally the most important sources of the CDNC. The contribution of BB to the CDNC is more significant than its increase to CCN0.2 %, mainly because BB aerosols are mostly located directly above the inversion layer in the model; thus, they can increase the in-cloud CDNC by enhancing the supersaturation through the dynamical feedback due to short-wave absorption. An aerosol source that shows an increase in the CDNC also shows an increase in the LWP resulting from a reduction in autoconversion. Due to the absorption effect, BB aerosol can enhance existing temperature inversions and reduce the entrainment of sub-saturated air, leading to a further increase in the LWP. As a result, the contribution of BB to the LWP is second only to aerosol nucleation on annual averages. These findings demonstrate that BB is not the dominant source of CCN within the marine boundary layer from an emission source perspective. However, as most BB aerosols are located directly above the inversion layer, their effect on clouds increases due to their absorption effect (about the same as anthropogenic sources for the CDNC and more than anthropogenic sources for the LWP), highlighting the crucial role of their radiative effect on clouds. The results on the radiative effects of aerosols show that BB aerosol exhibits an overall positive RFari (radiative forcing associated with aerosol–radiation interactions), but its net effective radiative forcing remains negative due to its effect on clouds (mainly due to its absorbing effect). By quantifying aerosol and cloud properties affected by different sources, this paper provides a framework for understanding the effects of aerosol sources on marine stratocumulus clouds and radiation in the SEA.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{che2022source,
  author = {Haochi Che and Philip Stier and Duncan Watson‐Parris and Hamish Gordon and Lucia Deaconu},
  title = {{Source attribution of cloud condensation nuclei and their impact on stratocumulus clouds and radiation in the south-eastern Atlantic}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-22-10789-2022},
}
Figure