Abstract
We provide two new proofs of a theorem of Cooper, Long and Reid which asserts that, apart from an explicit finite list of exceptional manifolds, any compact orientable irreducible 3-manifold with non-empty boundary has large fundamental group. The first proof is direct and topological; the second is group-theoretic. These techniques are then applied to prove a string of results about (possibly closed) 3-orbifolds, which culminate in the following theorem. If K is a knot in a compact orientable 3-manifold M, such that the complement of K admits a finite-volume hyperbolic structure, then the orbifold obtained by assigning a singularity of order n along K has large fundamental group, for infinitely many positive integers n. We also obtain information about this set of values of n. When M is the 3-sphere, this has implications for the cyclic branched covers over the knot. In this case, we may also weaken the hypothesis that the complement of K is hyperbolic to the assumption that K is non-trivial.
Introduction
A central theme in 3-manifold topology is the relationship between a manifold's geometry and its fundamental group. A particularly strong property is having a "large" fundamental group: a group is large if it contains a finite-index subgroup that admits a surjective homomorphism onto a non-abelian free group $F_2$. Large groups are significant because they satisfy the Virtually Haken Conjecture and imply the existence of finite covers with arbitrarily large first Betti numbers.
While it was previously established by Cooper, Long, and Reid that most 3-manifolds with boundary have large fundamental groups, the original proof was technically dense. This paper provides two streamlined proofs for this foundational result and extends the methodology to 3-orbifolds—spaces that incorporate singularities, often along knots. This extension allows for new insights into the properties of cyclic branched covers of non-trivial knots.
Methods
Lackenby offers two distinct approaches to proving the "largeness" of these groups, simplifying the path to understanding 3-manifold complexity.
1. Topological Approach
This method utilizes cyclic covers and Poincaré duality. By examining the boundary of the manifold, the author uses a lower bound on the rank of cohomology to identify specific surfaces. A "collapsing map" is then employed to show that the presence of two disjoint, non-separating surfaces in a cover forces the fundamental group to surject onto a free group of rank two.
2. Group-Theoretic Approach
This approach relies on a "largeness criterion" based on the growth rate of the ranks of finite-index subgroups. By focusing on the algebraic properties of the group's subgroup lattice, this method sidesteps much of the traditional 3D topological machinery, providing a more abstract but efficient proof.
To extend these results to orbifolds, the singular locus (the knot where the orbifold is singular) is treated as an internal boundary. As the order of the singularity $n$ increases, the orbifold's algebraic behavior increasingly mimics that of a manifold with a boundary component.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Boundary as a Reservoir: The genus of a manifold's boundary serves as a guaranteed source of topological complexity. In high-degree cyclic covers, this complexity "blooms" into enough independent surfaces to ensure the fundamental group is large.
- Simplification through Abstraction: The paper demonstrates that proving a group is "large" does not always require the explicit construction of incompressible surfaces. Group-theoretic growth criteria can provide a powerful shortcut.
- Orbifolds as "Soft" Boundaries: By assigning a high order of singularity ($n$) to a knot, the resulting orbifold behaves like a manifold with boundary, allowing the porting of results from bounded manifolds to closed orbifolds.
Key Results
- Theorem 2.1: Provides new, simplified proofs that for a compact orientable irreducible 3-manifold $M$ with non-empty boundary, $\pi_1(M)$ is large (excluding simple $I$-bundles).
- Theorem 3.6: Establishes that if a knot $K$ has a hyperbolic complement, the orbifold $O(K, n)$ has a large fundamental group for infinitely many integers $n$.
- Theorem 3.7: For any non-trivial knot $K$ in $S^3$, the $mn$-fold cyclic cover branched over $K$ has a large fundamental group for all sufficiently large $n$ (given $m > 2$).
Limitations and Future Work
A primary limitation is the distinction between "infinitely many $n$" and "all but finitely many $n$." While the property is proven for many values, it is not yet proven for every possible value. A significant unsolved problem remains: is the fundamental group of the orbifold $S^3(K, n)$ large for all but finitely many $n$ for any non-trivial knot? Current methods struggle when $n$ is a small prime, indicating a need for further technical refinement.
Summary updated