Solution Landscapes of the Simplified Ericksen--Leslie Model and its Comparison with the Reduced Landau--de Gennes Model

Yucen Han, Jianyuan Yin, Yucheng Hu, Apala Majumdar, Lei Zhang

Abstract

We investigate the solution landscapes of a simplified Ericksen--Leslie (sEL) vector model for nematic liquid crystals, confined in a two-dimensional square domain with tangent boundary conditions. An efficient numerical algorithm is developed to construct the solution landscapes by utilizing the symmetry properties of the model and the domain. Since the sEL model and the reduced Landau--de Gennes (rLdG) models can be viewed as Ginzburg--Landau functionals, we systematically compute the solution landscapes of the sEL model, for different domain sizes, and compare with the solution landscapes of the corresponding rLdG models. There are many similarities, including the stable diagonal and rotated states, bifurcation behaviors, and sub-solution landscapes with low-index saddle solutions. Significant disparities also exist between the two models. The sEL vector model exhibits the stable solution $C\pm$ with interior defects, high-index "fake defects" solutions, novel tessellating solutions, and certain types of distinctive dynamical pathways. The solution landscape approach provides a comprehensive and efficient way for model comparison and is applicable to a wide range of mathematical models in physics.

Introduction

Nematic Liquid Crystals (NLCs) are fluids characterized by molecules that possess a preferred orientation without long-range positional order. Mathematically, these systems are often described using two primary frameworks: the vector-based Ericksen–Leslie (EL) model and the tensor-based Landau–de Gennes (LdG) model. The EL model represents the director field as a vector $\mathbf{n}$, which is computationally efficient but fails to account for the head-to-tail symmetry ($\mathbf{n} \equiv -\mathbf{n}$) inherent in many NLC molecules. Conversely, the LdG model utilizes a tensor $\mathbf{Q}$ to respect this symmetry and capture phenomena like biaxiality.

This study aims to bridge the gap between these models by mapping their "solution landscapes"—the complete set of critical points, including stable minima and unstable saddle points. By comparing these landscapes, we can identify where the simpler vector model suffices and where the more complex tensor model is necessary to capture essential physics.

Methodology

The researchers employ a Solution Landscape approach to systematically identify all equilibrium states of the energy functionals. This involves identifying not just the global minima, but also the unstable "saddle points" that dictate how a system transitions from one state to another.

Symmetry-Exploiting Algorithm

A key technical contribution is the development of a numerical algorithm that leverages the symmetry groups of both the square domain and the energy functionals. This approach allows for the efficient discovery of new solutions by applying symmetry operations to known ones, significantly reducing the search space in high-dimensional energy surfaces. Saddle Dynamics (SD) are used to move between saddle points of different Morse indices.

Model Matching

To facilitate a direct comparison, the effective domain sizes of the two models—denoted by $\eta$ for the simplified EL (sEL) model and $\alpha$ for the reduced LdG (rLdG) model—must be matched. This ensures that the physical scales of the systems being compared are equivalent.

Table 1: Corresponding values of $\eta$ for sEL and $\alpha$ for rLdG models used for comparison.

Key Results and Discussion

The comparison reveals both striking similarities and fundamental differences between the sEL and rLdG models.

Shared Sub-landscapes

For low-energy configurations, the models exhibit a high degree of correspondence. Both predict stable "Diagonal" (D) and "Rotated" (R) states, as well as similar bifurcation behaviors for low-index saddle solutions. This suggests that for simple geometries and low-energy states, the vector model provides a reliable and computationally cheaper approximation.

Disparities in High-Energy States

Significant differences emerge in more complex configurations:

  • Fake Defects: Due to the lack of head-to-tail symmetry, the sEL model produces "fake defects"—discontinuity lines where the director flips 180 degrees. These are physically indistinguishable in the rLdG tensor framework.
  • Vortex Stability: The sEL model predicts a stable $C\pm$ state (a central vortex). In the rLdG model, this state is an unstable saddle point because the tensor framework allows the $+1$ vortex to split into two $+1/2$ defects, which is energetically more favorable.
  • Tessellating Solutions: The sEL model supports novel "tessellating" solutions (e.g., H, LL, and X± states), which are complex patterns formed by tiling simpler solutions.

Complexity with Domain Size

As the domain size increases (increasing $\eta$ and $\alpha$), the sEL landscape becomes increasingly complex, featuring a higher density of high-index saddle points compared to the rLdG model. Furthermore, the sEL model effectively doubles the number of stable states (e.g., 4 Diagonal states vs. 2 in rLdG) because it treats opposite orientations as distinct.

Conclusion

The solution landscape approach provides a powerful tool for model comparison in soft matter physics. While the sEL model is a useful surrogate for low-energy states, its failure to respect head-to-tail symmetry leads to artifacts like fake defects and over-stabilized vortices in complex configurations. Future work should explore the impact of elastic anisotropy and extend the analysis to 3D domains, where "escape into the third dimension" can fundamentally alter the stability of defect structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the solution landscapes of a simplified Ericksen--Leslie (sEL) vector model for nematic liquid crystals, confined in a two-dimensional square domain with tangent boundary conditions. An efficient numerical algorithm is developed to construct the solution landscapes by utilizing the symmetry properties of the model and the domain. Since the sEL model and the reduced Landau--de Gennes (rLdG) models can be viewed as Ginzburg--Landau functionals, we systematically compute the solution landscapes of the sEL model, for different domain sizes, and compare with the solution landscapes of the corresponding rLdG models. There are many similarities, including the stable diagonal and rotated states, bifurcation behaviors, and sub-solution landscapes with low-index saddle solutions. Significant disparities also exist between the two models. The sEL vector model exhibits the stable solution $C\pm$ with interior defects, high-index "fake defects" solutions, novel tessellating solutions, and certain types of distinctive dynamical pathways. The solution landscape approach provides a comprehensive and efficient way for model comparison and is applicable to a wide range of mathematical models in physics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2021solution,
  author = {Yucen Han and Jianyuan Yin and Yucheng Hu and Apala Majumdar and Lei Zhang},
  title = {{Solution Landscapes of the Simplified Ericksen--Leslie Model and its Comparison with the Reduced Landau--de Gennes Model}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1098/rspa.2021.0458},
}

Loading related content...

Figure