Solution landscape of droplet on rough surfaces: wetting transition and directional transport

Yuze Zhang, Xuelong Gu, Yushun Wang, Xianmin Xu, Lei Zhang

Abstract

Droplets on rough surfaces can exhibit various stationary states that are crucial for designing hydrophobic materials and enabling directional liquid transport. Here we introduce a phase-field saddle dynamics method to construct the solution landscape of wetting transition and directional transport on pillared substrates. By applying this method, we reveal the full range of Cassie-Baxter and Wenzel states, along with the complete wetting transition paths. We further elucidate the mechanisms of directional droplet transport on both hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces, demonstrating how surface design can influence directional movement.

Introduction

The interaction between liquid droplets and textured surfaces is a fundamental phenomenon in nature and engineering, exemplified by the self-cleaning properties of lotus leaves and the water-harvesting capabilities of spider silk. Traditionally, wetting behavior is categorized into two primary states: the Cassie-Baxter (CB) state, where air pockets are trapped beneath the droplet, and the Wenzel (W) state, where the liquid fully penetrates the surface grooves.

While the classic CB and Wenzel equations identify the most stable configurations, they fail to capture the complex reality of "metastable" states—intermediate configurations that trap droplets and dictate their dynamic behavior. Understanding these states and the energy barriers separating them is essential for controlling droplet mobility and transitions. Previous numerical approaches could identify specific transition paths but lacked a comprehensive "bird's-eye view" of the entire energy landscape. This paper addresses this gap by introducing a novel method to map the complete solution landscape of wetting on rough surfaces.

Methodology: Phase-Field Saddle Dynamics

The researchers developed a phase-field saddle dynamics approach to systematically explore the energy landscape of droplets on pillared substrates.

Phase-Field Representation

Instead of tracking a sharp liquid-vapor interface, the model employs a continuous phase-field function ($\phi$). This approach naturally accommodates topological changes, such as the splitting or merging of droplets, which are common during wetting transitions.

Saddle Dynamics and Solution Landscape

The core innovation lies in the use of saddle dynamics to identify index-$k$ saddle points. In an energy landscape, an index-1 saddle point represents a "mountain pass" between two local minima (stable states). Higher-index saddles represent more complex unstable configurations.

By implementing an "upward/downward search" algorithm, the method starts from high-index saddle points and follows energy gradients to uncover all connected lower-index saddles and local minima. This process constructs a "solution landscape"—a hierarchical map of all possible stationary states and the pathways between them.

Numerical Implementation

The phase-field equations were solved using the Finite Element Method (FEM) on idealized 2D pillared substrates. The study systematically varied geometric and chemical parameters, including Young’s angle ($\theta$), pillar height ($h$), gap width ($w$), and pillar tilt angle ($\alpha$), to explore their influence on the wetting landscape.

Mapping the Wetting Transition

The application of saddle dynamics revealed a complex hierarchy of states governing the transition from Cassie-Baxter to Wenzel configurations.

Solution landscape and energy barrier analysis for wetting transitions.

The researchers identified a high-level index-3 saddle point (3S) as the "parent" state for the wetting transition. Perturbing this state leads to a series of intermediate Cassie-Wenzel (CBW) states, where the liquid partially penetrates the grooves. A typical transition path was mapped as: CB3 -> TS1 -> CBW1 -> TS2 -> CBW2 -> TS3 -> W3, where TS denotes transition states (index-1 saddles).

The study quantified how surface properties influence these energy barriers. For instance, increasing the pillar height or the Young’s angle (making the surface more hydrophobic) raises the energy barrier for the wetting transition, while increasing the gap width between pillars lowers it.

Directional Transport and Surface Design

A key application of this framework is understanding directional droplet transport on asymmetric surfaces, such as tilted pillars.

Directional transport mechanisms and phase diagram for hydrophobic surfaces.

On tilted pillars, the energy landscape becomes asymmetric. For hydrophobic surfaces, the energy barriers for moving in different directions are unequal. For a configuration with $\theta=102^\circ$ and a tilt $\alpha=70^\circ$, the barrier to move right ($\Delta f = 2.621 \times 10^{-2}$) was found to be significantly higher than the barrier to move left ($\Delta f = 2.249 \times 10^{-2}$), resulting in a preferred leftward transport.

The researchers demonstrated that the preferred direction of motion can be reversed or tuned to achieve bi-directional mobility by adjusting the Young’s angle. This led to the creation of design phase diagrams (e.g., Figure 5E) that map combinations of tilt angle and surface chemistry to specific transport behaviors.

On hydrophilic surfaces, droplets generally spread in the direction of the tilt. However, the model explains an experimental anomaly: if the surface is highly hydrophilic (Young's angle below $65^\circ$), the transport tendency can shift, potentially moving the droplet opposite to the tilt direction.

Conclusion

This work provides a powerful predictive framework for designing functional surfaces by mapping their full solution landscapes. By identifying the hierarchy of metastable states and quantifying energy barriers, researchers can precisely engineer surfaces for applications ranging from microfluidics to self-cleaning coatings.

Future research will focus on extending this methodology to 3D systems, which, while computationally more demanding, will offer even greater fidelity to real-world surfaces. Additionally, incorporating dynamic effects like fluid inertia and environmental factors like condensation will further refine the model's predictive capabilities for complex, real-world scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Droplets on rough surfaces can exhibit various stationary states that are crucial for designing hydrophobic materials and enabling directional liquid transport. Here we introduce a phase-field saddle dynamics method to construct the solution landscape of wetting transition and directional transport on pillared substrates. By applying this method, we reveal the full range of Cassie-Baxter and Wenzel states, along with the complete wetting transition paths. We further elucidate the mechanisms of directional droplet transport on both hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces, demonstrating how surface design can influence directional movement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025solution,
  author = {Yuze Zhang and Xuelong Gu and Yushun Wang and Xianmin Xu and Lei Zhang},
  title = {{Solution landscape of droplet on rough surfaces: wetting transition and directional transport}},
  booktitle = {Soft},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1039/d4sm01372g},
}
Figure