Abstract
Play-to-earn is one of the prospective categories of decentralized applications. The play-to-earn projects combine blockchain technology with entertaining games and finance, attracting various participants. While huge amounts of capital have been poured into these projects, the new crypto niche is considered controversial, and the traditional gaming industry is hesitant to embrace blockchain technology. In addition, there is little systematic research on these projects. In this paper, we delineate play-to-earn projects in terms of economic & governance models and implementation and analyze how blockchain technology can benefit these projects by providing system robustness, transparency, composability, and decentralized governance. We begin by identifying the participants and characterizing the tokens, which are products of composability. We then summarize the roadmap and governance model to exposit there is a transition from centralized governance to decentralized governance. We also classify the implementation of the play-to-earn projects with different extents of robustness and transparency. Finally, we discuss the security & societal challenges for future research in terms of possible attacks, the economics of tokens, and governance.
Introduction: Defining the "Wild West" of GameFi
The Play-to-Earn (P2E) sector—often called GameFi—exploded into a multi-billion dollar industry almost overnight. Despite this growth, it remains a "Wild West" for researchers and developers. Critics often dismiss projects as "Crypto Ponzi schemes," while proponents see a revolution in digital ownership. This paper addresses the lack of systematic research by defining what makes a P2E project unique compared to traditional gaming, specifically focusing on the tension between high-performance gameplay and decentralized asset ownership.
Taxonomy: Participants and Tokenomics
To understand P2E, the authors develop a rigorous taxonomy. They model the ecosystem through three primary roles: Entrepreneurs (the developers), Investors (who provide capital), and Players (who provide labor and engagement).
Tokenomics is the engine of these projects. The paper categorizes tokens by their functional purpose: funding, incentives, payment, and governance. A key insight is the "Dual-Token" model (e.g., AXS and SLP in Axie Infinity). One token acts as a volatile investment/governance tool, while the other serves as a utility currency designed to keep entry costs stable for new players.
Implementation: The Hybrid Reality
Most "blockchain games" are not fully on-chain. The paper reveals a hybrid reality: while asset ownership (NFTs) is decentralized on a blockchain, the actual game logic and player movements often run on centralized services like AWS to maintain performance. The authors validate this taxonomy against influential projects like Axie Infinity, Decentraland, and The Sandbox, noting that as of late 2022, the sector saw over 900,000 active wallets.
Governance: The Path to Decentralization
A core promise of P2E is decentralized governance. The authors outline a three-phase roadmap that most projects attempt to follow to transition from a founder-led startup to a community-governed DAO.
- Phase 1: Direct interaction between entrepreneurs and investors (the ICO phase).
- Phase 2: The entrepreneur governs the "Universe" while players and investors begin to earn and trade.
- Phase 3: The ideal state where players and investors govern the ecosystem, voting on game updates and reward distributions.
However, the paper notes a "Tragedy of the Commons" in DAOs: "myopic voters" often prioritize short-term financial gains (higher immediate rewards) over long-term game sustainability, potentially destabilizing the project from within.
Security and Economic Sustainability
The paper documents several critical failure modes:
- Security Vulnerabilities: Attack vectors include "Rollback of Randomness" (undoing bad loot box rolls) and "Front-running" in NFT marketplaces. The $625 million Ronin bridge hack serves as a stark reminder of the risks associated with project-specific sidechains.
- Economic Failure: "Irregular Issuance"—where utility tokens are earned too quickly—leads to hyperinflation and the collapse of the player base.
- Sustainability: Most P2E models still rely on a constant influx of new players to pay out existing ones, making long-term economic stability an unsolved problem.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While P2E offers a new paradigm for digital ownership, its future depends on solving technical and economic hurdles. Future research must address anti-cheating in decentralized environments, privacy-preserving governance to prevent bribery, and the security of cross-chain bridges, which remain the single biggest point of failure in the ecosystem.
Summary updated