Software Engineering for Self-Adaptive Systems: A Second Research Roadmap

Rogério de Lemos, Holger Giese, Hausi A. Müller, Mary Shaw, Jesper Andersson, Marin Litoiu, Bradley R. Schmerl, Gabriel Tamura, Norha M. Villegas, Thomas Vogel, Danny Weyns, Luciano Baresi, Basil Becker, Nelly Bencomo, Yuriy Brun, Bojan Cukic, Ronald J. Desmarais, Schahram Dustdar, Gregor Engels, Kurt Geihs, Karl M. Göschka, Alessandra Gorla, Vincenzo Grassi, Paola Inverardi, Gabor Karsai, Jeff Kramer, Antónia Lopes, Jeff Magee, Sam Malek, Serge Mankovski, Raffaela Mirandola, John Mylopoulos, Oscar Nierstrasz, Mauro Pezzè, Christian Prehofer, Wilhelm Schäfer, Richard D. Schlichting, Dennis B. Smith, João Pedro Sousa, Ladan Tahvildari, Kenny Wong, Jochen Wuttke

TL;DR

This paper presents a research roadmap for self-adaptive systems, identifying key challenges in their design, development, and management. It focuses on four critical areas: defining the design space for adaptive solutions, evolving software engineering processes, transitioning from centralized to decentralized control, and ensuring practical run-time verification and validation. This work aims to guide future research towards building more robust and trustworthy self-adaptive software.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern software systems are becoming increasingly complex and are expected to operate in dynamic, unpredictable environments. To meet these demands, systems need to adapt their behavior and structure autonomously in response to changes in their context, requirements, or internal state. This capability, known as self-adaptation, is crucial for systems to remain versatile, resilient, and dependable. However, engineering such systems presents significant challenges. Traditional software engineering practices are often ill-suited for the dynamic and evolving nature of self-adaptive systems. This paper addresses the need for a structured approach to guide research and development in this field, building upon a previous roadmap by identifying new critical areas and challenges.

Methods

This paper is a research roadmap, not an empirical study. Its "method" is to synthesize the state-of-the-art and identify future research directions through a structured discussion of key topics. The authors, drawing from a Dagstuhl Seminar, focus on four essential areas of self-adaptation:

  • Design Space for Adaptive Solutions: This involves defining the set of design decisions developers must make when creating self-adaptive systems, including how to represent the system and its environment, how to observe changes, how to control adaptation, and how to identify possible system states.
  • Processes: This area examines how software engineering processes need to evolve to accommodate the continuous adaptation and evolution of systems at run-time, moving beyond traditional development-time activities.
  • From Centralized to Decentralized Control: This section explores the trade-offs and patterns associated with different control architectures for adaptation, ranging from a single central controller to distributed, peer-to-peer coordination.
  • Practical Run-Time Verification and Validation (V&V): This focuses on the critical need for methods and techniques to ensure the trustworthiness and correctness of self-adaptive systems while they are running, addressing challenges like state explosion and evolving requirements.

For each topic, the paper provides an overview, suggests future research directions, and highlights specific challenges.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Design Space" is Crucial: Understanding and systematically defining the design space for self-adaptive systems is paramount. This involves identifying all relevant design decisions and their interdependencies to guide developers effectively.
  • Processes Must Evolve: Traditional software engineering processes, which largely separate development from operation and maintenance, are insufficient for self-adaptive systems. Processes need to embrace run-time evolution and adaptation, blurring the lines between lifecycle phases.
  • Centralized vs. Decentralized Control: A Spectrum, Not a Dichotomy: While centralized and decentralized control represent two poles, practical systems often lie on a spectrum. The choice depends heavily on domain characteristics (e.g., trust, network reliability) and stakeholder requirements (e.g., optimization, reaction time, scalability).
  • Run-Time V&V is Non-Negotiable: Establishing "certifiable trust" in self-adaptive systems hinges on effective run-time V&V. This requires new approaches that can handle dynamic changes, uncertainty, and resource constraints, moving beyond traditional design-time verification.
  • Control Science is Key: The integration of software engineering principles with control theory is essential for building trustworthy self-adaptive systems, leading to the concept of "control science" for V&V.

Key Results

This paper is a roadmap, so it doesn't present empirical results in the traditional sense. Instead, its "results" are the identification and articulation of key research challenges and directions within the four focus areas. The paper outlines specific challenges within each area, such as:

  • Design Space: Defining the design space, refining its dimensions, identifying dependencies, and mapping it to implementation.
  • Processes: Understanding system nature and lifecycle for process definition, identifying factors affecting process changes, and formalizing processes for reuse and analysis.
  • Control: Identifying patterns for interacting control loops, determining pattern applicability, and developing techniques for guaranteeing system-wide quality in decentralized systems.
  • Run-Time V&V: Tracing evolving requirements, managing the complexity of run-time V&V techniques, and providing dynamic monitoring.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their roadmap is not exhaustive and that several other important topics related to self-adaptive systems were not covered, including:

  • Designing systems to handle change (elasticity, generating alternatives).
  • Reactive vs. proactive adaptation.
  • Managing competition and cooperation among adaptive components.
  • Decision-making criteria for adaptation (balancing QoS, cost, etc.).
  • The role of technologies like model-driven development, aspect-oriented programming, and software product lines.
  • The need for benchmarks and exemplars to drive research.

Future work is implicitly directed towards addressing the identified challenges in each of the four roadmap areas. The paper emphasizes the need for further research into pattern applicability, completeness, and quality of service analysis for decentralized approaches. It also highlights the ongoing need to refine the design space, develop more robust processes, and advance run-time V&V techniques. The overarching goal is to establish a more systematic and disciplined engineering practice for self-adaptive software systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The goal of this roadmap paper is to summarize the state of-the-art and identify research challenges when developing, deploying and managing self-adaptive software systems. Instead of dealing with a wide range of topics associated with the field, we focus on four essential topics of self-adaptation: design space for adaptive solutions, processes, from centralized to decentralized control, and practical run-time verification and validation. For each topic, we present an overview, suggest future directions, and focus on selected challenges. This paper complements and extends a previous roadmap on software engineering for self-adaptive systems published in 2009 covering a different set of topics, and reflecting in part on the previous paper. This roadmap is one of the many results of the Dagstuhl Seminar 10431 on Software Engineering for Self-Adaptive Systems, which took place in October 2010.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lemos2010software,
  author = {Rogério de Lemos and Holger Giese and Hausi A. Müller and Mary Shaw and Jesper Andersson and Marin Litoiu and Bradley R. Schmerl and Gabriel Tamura and Norha M. Villegas and Thomas Vogel and Danny Weyns and Luciano Baresi and Basil Becker and Nelly Bencomo and Yuriy Brun and Bojan Cukic and Ronald J. Desmarais and Schahram Dustdar and Gregor Engels and Kurt Geihs and Karl M. Göschka and Alessandra Gorla and Vincenzo Grassi and Paola Inverardi and Gabor Karsai and Jeff Kramer and Antónia Lopes and Jeff Magee and Sam Malek and Serge Mankovski and Raffaela Mirandola and John Mylopoulos and Oscar Nierstrasz and Mauro Pezzè and Christian Prehofer and Wilhelm Schäfer and Richard D. Schlichting and Dennis B. Smith and João Pedro Sousa and Ladan Tahvildari and Kenny Wong and Jochen Wuttke},
  title = {{Software Engineering for Self-Adaptive Systems: A Second Research Roadmap}},
  booktitle = {Software Engineering for Self-Adaptive Systems},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-642-35813-5\_1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure