Social support, network, and relationships among coaches in different sports: a systematic review

João Gonçalo Ferreira, Filipe Rodrigues, Pedro Sobreiro, Hugo da Silva, Fernando Santos, Gonçalo Carvalho, António Hernández-Mendo, J. A. S. RodriguesFrontiers in Psychology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

This systematic review emphasizes the importance of social support for coaches in both their personal and professional lives, noting its positive effects and the negative consequences of its absence. Given the demanding nature of coaching, improving social support systems can enhance coaches' wellbeing and the success of sports activities.

Introduction

While the psychological needs of athletes are a cornerstone of sports science, the "coach" is often overlooked as a high-stress professional. Sports coaching is characterized by irregular hours, job insecurity tied to performance, and intense emotional investment. This systematic review addresses the lack of a cohesive understanding of how social support functions for coaches, aiming to categorize the types of support received—emotional, informational, tangible, and esteem—and determine how these interactions influence mental health outcomes like self-compassion, stress levels, and career longevity.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a systematic review following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines to ensure a rigorous and transparent selection process.

Key aspects of the methodology included:

  • Search Strategy: A comprehensive search of databases including Web of Science, MEDLINE, and ERIC using Boolean operators to combine terms related to social support, coaching, and sport.
  • Eligibility (PECOS): Studies were filtered to include only those involving coaches in competitive sports environments (excluding school PE) and utilizing empirical research designs.
  • Quality Assessment: The STROBE Statement was used to independently assess the methodological quality of the final studies.
PRISMA flowchart illustrating the study selection process from 231 initial records to 11 final studies.

Synthesis of Findings

The review synthesized findings from 11 peer-reviewed empirical studies published between 2000 and 2023. These studies spanned diverse geographic locations, including Switzerland, Singapore, South Africa, Australia, and the UK.

The Multidimensional Nature of Support

Social support in the coaching context is not a monolith but is categorized into four distinct types:

  1. Emotional: Providing comfort and security, primarily sourced from family.
  2. Informational: Offering advice and professional guidance, primarily sourced from peers and other coaches.
  3. Tangible: Concrete help with tasks, such as assistant coaches managing training sessions or family members handling domestic responsibilities.
  4. Esteem: Reinforcing a coach's competence and value, which is particularly crucial during high-pressure competitive periods.
A diagram showing the categorization of family-based social support into informational, emotional, tangible, and esteem types.

Key Sources: Family, Peers, and Friends

  • The "Friend" Factor: Interestingly, while coaches look to peers for professional advice, they frequently perceive support from friends as the most influential for their overall psychological wellbeing. Friends provide a necessary "escape" from the coaching routine.
  • Family Dynamics: Family remains the primary source of emotional and tangible support, though the review notes that the quality of this support can fluctuate based on the coach's work-life balance.
  • Peer Networks: Fellow coaches and assistants are vital for informational support, helping to navigate the technical and tactical challenges of the profession.

Impact on Wellbeing and Performance

  • The Buffer Effect: Social support acts as a critical "buffer" against the demanding nature of the profession, similar to its role in other high-stress fields like healthcare. High levels of support are significantly associated with increased self-compassion, reduced stress levels, and higher job and life satisfaction.
  • Consequences of Isolation: Conversely, a lack of social support is a direct predictor of burnout symptoms, increased work-family conflict, and a higher intention to quit the profession.
  • Organizational Autonomy: Support from sports organizations is most effective when it provides clear guidelines but allows coaches high levels of autonomy. Environments that lack these directives often lead to poorer psychological outcomes.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge several gaps in the current literature:

  • Sample Size: Only 11 studies met the rigorous inclusion criteria, highlighting a significant gap in sports psychology research regarding coaches.
  • Demographic Bias: There is a notable lack of research specifically targeting female coaches and different age groups, who may experience and utilize social support networks differently.
  • Cultural Context: Most existing studies are from Western or high-income nations; the influence of cultural factors on support networks remains largely unexplored.
  • Methodological Needs: Future research requires more longitudinal studies and a blend of quantitative and qualitative methods (such as sociograms) to build a more robust conceptual framework for coach wellbeing.

Summary updated

Abstract

This systematic review emphasizes the importance of social support for coaches in both their personal and professional lives, noting its positive effects and the negative consequences of its absence. Given the demanding nature of coaching, improving social support systems can enhance coaches' wellbeing and the success of sports activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ferreira2024social,
  author = {João Gonçalo Ferreira and Filipe Rodrigues and Pedro Sobreiro and Hugo da Silva and Fernando Santos and Gonçalo Carvalho and António Hernández-Mendo and J. A. S. Rodrigues},
  title = {{Social support, network, and relationships among coaches in different sports: a systematic review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1301978},
}
Figure