Social isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic in Spain: a population study

Marina Martínez-Garcia, Emilio Sansano‐Sansano, Andrea Castillo-Hornero, Rubén Femenía, Kristof Roomp, Nuria Oliver

This study provides a quantitative look at the "shadow pandemic" of social disconnection. By analyzing over 32,000 survey responses, researchers found that social isolation in Spain reached a staggering 26%, with middle-aged adults—not the elderly—bearing the brunt of the impact. The findings highlight a critical interplay between economic hardship, friend-based support networks, and public health compliance.

TL;DR

This paper quantifies the sociological toll of COVID-19 in Spain, revealing that social isolation spiked to nearly 26% of the population. Surprisingly, middle-aged adults (40–59) faced the highest risk of isolation, driven largely by economic hardship and the erosion of friend-based social networks rather than family ones.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the medical community focused on the biological spread of SARS-CoV-2, the sociological impact of prolonged non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs)—like lockdowns and social distancing—remained under-studied. Social isolation is not just a "feeling"; it is a recognized public health crisis linked to premature mortality, cardiovascular disease, and mental health issues, with an effect size comparable to obesity or smoking.

The authors sought to fill the gap in population-level data, specifically looking at how isolation levels shifted across different demographics in Spain and how economic and psychological factors influenced these levels during the "new normality" phase of 2021.

Methods

The researchers utilized the LSNS-6 (Lubben Social Network Scale), a validated six-item instrument that measures the size and frequency of an individual’s social network, distinguishing between family and friends.

The data was collected via the COVID19ImpactSurvey, an anonymous online survey. To ensure the results were representative of the Spanish population, the team employed a re-weighting methodology. They adjusted the raw data (which often skews toward specific demographics in online formats) to match official 2020 Spanish National Institute of Statistics (INE) data across seven geographical regions, accounting for age and gender. They then used logistic regression and ANOVA to identify independent predictors of isolation.

Datasets

  • Primary Dataset: 32,359 survey responses collected in Spain between June 6 and December 16, 2021.
  • Validation Set: An IPSOS digital panel of 1,000 representative respondents was used to validate the survey methodology.
  • Reference Data: Official 2020 statistics from the Spanish National Institute of Statistics (INE) for demographic re-weighting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "U-Shaped" Isolation Curve: Contrary to the common assumption that the elderly are the most isolated, this study found a "U-shaped" distribution. The youth (18–29) and the elderly (60+) were actually less isolated than the middle-aged (40–59) group.
  • Friends vs. Family: In Spain’s family-centric culture, family support remained relatively resilient. The primary driver of social isolation was the collapse of friend-based networks. For example, the youth relied heavily on friends, while the elderly relied on family; the middle-aged group seemed to lose the "friend" component without a proportional gain in family support.
  • The Economic-Isolation Feedback Loop: There is a massive correlation between financial struggle and social withdrawal. Those reporting "severe" economic impact were twice as likely to be isolated.
  • The Compliance Paradox: Participants who reported not adopting any COVID-19 protection measures had significantly lower isolation scores. This suggests that those following the rules most strictly paid the highest "social price," while those ignoring NPIs maintained their social circles at the cost of higher infection risk.

Key Results

  • Prevalence: The prevalence of social isolation was 25.98%, nearly 14 percentage points higher than pre-pandemic estimates in similar European cohorts (which hovered around 12%).
  • Age Peak: The 50–59 age group was the most vulnerable, with 29.54% reporting social isolation.
  • Economic Impact: Over 40% of participants who suffered severe economic consequences were socially isolated.
  • Gender Nuance: While overall prevalence was similar between genders, women who suffered severe economic hits were significantly more likely to be isolated than men in the same financial position, largely due to a sharper decline in their friend-based support networks.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations inherent in online surveys:

  • Self-Selection Bias: The survey reached people active on social media and those with internet access, potentially missing the most marginalized or "digitally isolated" individuals.
  • Recall Bias: LSNS-6 relies on self-reporting of contacts over the previous week, which can be subjective.
  • Cross-sectional Nature: The study provides a snapshot in time. Future work is needed to determine if these isolation levels are temporary or if the pandemic has caused a permanent shift in the "social fabric" of the population.

The researchers suggest that public health policy must move beyond biological containment and begin deploying social support programs, particularly targeting middle-aged individuals and those in precarious economic situations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since March of 2020, billions of people worldwide have been asked to limit their social contacts in an effort to contain the spread of the SARS-CoV-2 virus. However, little research has been carried out to date on the impact of such social distancing measures on the social isolation levels of the population. In this paper, we study the impact of the pandemic on the social isolation of the Spanish population, by means of 32,359 answers to a citizen survey collected over a period of 7 months. We uncover (1) a significant increase in the prevalence of social isolation in the population, reaching almost 26%; (2) gender and age differences, with the largest prevalence of isolation among middle-aged individuals; (3) a strong relationship between economic impact and social isolation; and (4) differences in social isolation, depending on the number of COVID-19 protection measures and on the perception of coronavirus infection risk by our participants. Our research sheds quantitative light on the sociological impact of the pandemic, and enables us to identify key factors in the interplay between the deployment of non-pharmaceutical interventions to contain the spread of an infectious disease and a population's levels of social isolation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{martinezgarcia2022social,
  author = {Marina Martínez-Garcia and Emilio Sansano‐Sansano and Andrea Castillo-Hornero and Rubén Femenía and Kristof Roomp and Nuria Oliver},
  title = {{Social isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic in Spain: a population study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-16628-y},
}

Loading related content...

Figure