Snowfall induced by corona discharge

Jingjing Ju, Tie-Jun Wang, Ruxin Li, Shengzhe Du, Haiyi Sun, Liu Y, Ye Tian, Yafeng Bai, Yaoxiang Liu, Na Chen, Jingwei Wang, Cheng Wang, Jiansheng Liu, S. L. Chin, Zhizhan XuarXiv 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We demonstrated for the first time the condensation and precipitation (or snowfall) induced by a corona discharge inside a cloud chamber. Ionic wind was found to have played a more significant role than ions as extra Cloud Condensation Nuclei (CCN). 2.25 g of net snow enhancement was measured after applying a 30 kV corona discharge for 25 min. In comparison with another newly emerging femtosecond laser filamentation method, the snow precipitation induced by the corona discharge has about 4 orders of magnitude higher wall-plug efficiency under similar conditions.

Introduction

The pursuit of artificial precipitation—rainmaking and snowmaking—dates back to the late 19th century, with notable early proponents like Nikola Tesla. Despite decades of experimentation with various ionization techniques, the meteorological community has remained largely skeptical. The primary criticism is that while ionization can successfully induce condensation (the formation of tiny droplets), it rarely triggers actual precipitation (the growth of droplets or flakes large enough to fall). Most experiments have resulted in "all cloud and no rain," lacking a robust scientific basis for large-scale application.

This study addresses this gap by providing experimental evidence of significant snowfall induced by a corona discharge. By identifying the physical mechanism of "ionic wind," we demonstrate how high-voltage discharge can move beyond simple condensation to achieve measurable precipitation with unprecedented energy efficiency.

Experimental Methodology

The experiments were conducted within a diffusion cloud chamber measuring 0.5 m x 0.5 m x 0.2 m. To simulate atmospheric conditions, a steep vertical temperature gradient was established: the bottom plate was cooled to -46°C using liquid nitrogen, while the top plate remained at approximately 20°C.

A pointed copper electrode was positioned within the chamber at heights ranging from 2.0 cm to 20.0 cm from the base. This electrode was connected to a high-voltage DC power supply capable of delivering up to 30 kV. To observe the microphysical processes, a 2.0 W green laser (532 nm) illuminated the chamber, allowing for the visualization of Mie scattering from particles. Data collection involved high-resolution DSLR photography to track particle velocity and size, alongside physical measurements of the snow mass collected on the cold plate.

Results and Discussion

The Role of Ionic Wind

The central discovery of this research is that the primary driver of precipitation is not the ions acting as Cloud Condensation Nuclei (CCN), but rather the "ionic wind" they generate. As positive charges accelerate from the electrode toward the grounded base, they collide with neutral air molecules, creating a powerful vortex. This ionic wind, reaching speeds of up to 1.0 m/s at 30 kV, facilitates violent mixing of moist air across the temperature gradient.

This mixing induces a state of high super-saturation, with saturation ratios reaching up to 3.21. In this environment, water vapor is forced to condense and freeze much more rapidly than through static ionization alone. The turbulence created by the ionic wind effectively bridges the gap between microscopic condensation and macroscopic precipitation.

Precipitation Yield and Efficiency

The application of a 30 kV discharge for 25 minutes resulted in a net snow enhancement of 2.25 g. This represents a total snow weight three to four times higher than the background levels observed in the control group (natural snowfall within the chamber without discharge).

When compared to femtosecond laser filamentation—a modern alternative for weather modification—the corona discharge method proved significantly more effective. It produced approximately 170 times more snow for similar power levels. Most notably, when considering "wall-plug efficiency" (the total electrical energy consumed), the corona discharge method is four orders of magnitude (10,000 times) more efficient than laser-based methods.

Snow Characteristics and Chemical Impact

Analysis of the induced snowfall revealed that the flakes were smaller (~0.9 mm) and denser than naturally occurring "background" flakes (~2.3 mm). This suggests that the corona discharge promotes the rapid formation of a high volume of new ice particles rather than merely accelerating the growth of existing ones.

Furthermore, the environmental impact of the high-voltage discharge was assessed. The resulting snow was found to be nearly pH-neutral with very low nitrate concentrations. This indicates that the process does not produce significant quantities of nitric acid ($HNO_3$), alleviating concerns regarding chemical byproducts in the precipitation.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This research provides a scientific foundation for using corona discharge to induce precipitation. While the laboratory results are compelling, scaling this technology to the open atmosphere presents challenges. The height of natural clouds makes the use of ground-based electrodes difficult.

To overcome this, two primary strategies are proposed: the deployment of electrodes on high-altitude mountain peaks where clouds naturally intersect with the terrain, and the use of "laser-guided discharge." The latter involves using thin plasma strings (laser filaments) to act as conductive paths, allowing high-voltage discharges to be triggered deep within distant cloud layers. Future work will focus on outdoor field trials to validate these laboratory findings in real-world meteorological conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We demonstrated for the first time the condensation and precipitation (or snowfall) induced by a corona discharge inside a cloud chamber. Ionic wind was found to have played a more significant role than ions as extra Cloud Condensation Nuclei (CCN). 2.25 g of net snow enhancement was measured after applying a 30 kV corona discharge for 25 min. In comparison with another newly emerging femtosecond laser filamentation method, the snow precipitation induced by the corona discharge has about 4 orders of magnitude higher wall-plug efficiency under similar conditions.
BibTeX
@misc{ju2016snowfall,
  author = {Jingjing Ju and Tie-Jun Wang and Ruxin Li and Shengzhe Du and Haiyi Sun and Liu Y and Ye Tian and Yafeng Bai and Yaoxiang Liu and Na Chen and Jingwei Wang and Cheng Wang and Jiansheng Liu and S. L. Chin and Zhizhan Xu},
  title = {{Snowfall induced by corona discharge}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1607.05125},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.05125},
}
Figure