SN 2016ije: An SN 2002es-like Type Ia Supernova Exploded in a Metal-poor and Low-surface Brightness Galaxy

Zhitong Li, Tianmeng Zhang, Xiaofeng Wang, Jujia Zhang, L. Galbany, A. V. Filippenko, Thomas G. Brink, C. Ashall, WeiKang Zheng, Thomas de Jaeger, Fabio Ragosta, M. Deckers, M. Gromadzki, D. R. Young, Gaobo Xi, Jun-Cheng Chen, Xulin Zhao, Hanna Sai, Shengyu Yan, Danfeng Xiang, Zhihao Chen, Wenxiong Li, Bo Wang, Hu Zou, Jipeng Sui, Jiali Wang, Jun Ma, Jundan Nie, Suijian Xue, Xu Zhou, Zhimin Zhou

Introduction

Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are renowned for their utility as "standard candles" in measuring the expansion of the universe. However, the discovery of peculiar subclasses has challenged the uniformity of these events. One such group is the SN 2002es-like subclass. These supernovae are characterized by being "subluminous" (fainter than normal SNe Ia) while simultaneously exhibiting "broad" light curves that fade more slowly than other faint subclasses, such as the 91bg-like events.

SN 2016ije, discovered through the Tsinghua-NAOC Transient Survey, provides a unique opportunity to study this rare subclass. Its explosion in a metal-poor, low-surface-brightness (LSB) galaxy and its distinct spectroscopic features offer critical clues into the progenitor systems and explosion mechanisms of 02es-like supernovae.

The Host Environment

One of the most striking aspects of SN 2016ije is its host environment. Most 02es-like supernovae are associated with older stellar populations in massive, redder galaxies. In contrast, SN 2016ije exploded in the outskirts of a tiny, metal-poor galaxy with a stellar mass of approximately $2 \times 10^7 M_\odot$—roughly five orders of magnitude smaller than the Milky Way. Analysis using the Keck II telescope revealed the galaxy has a metallicity about half that of the Sun. This discovery suggests that the progenitors of 02es-like events can originate from a wider range of environments than previously thought, including low-mass, metal-poor systems.

Photometric and Bolometric Analysis

Photometric observations conducted across optical ($UBVRI$) and near-infrared ($JHK$) bands using facilities like the 0.8m Tsinghua-NAOC Telescope (TNT) and the 2.4m Lijiang Telescope (LJT) confirmed the peculiar nature of SN 2016ije.

Key photometric results include:

  • Luminosity: The supernova reached a peak absolute magnitude of $M_{B,\text{max}} = -17.65 \pm 0.06$ mag, confirming its subluminous status.
  • Decline Rate: It exhibited a relatively slow decline rate of $\Delta m_{15}(B) = 1.35 \pm 0.14$ mag, a hallmark of the 02es-like subclass.
  • Nickel Production: Analysis of the bolometric light curve indicates that only $0.14 \pm 0.04 M_\odot$ of $^{56}$Ni was synthesized. This is significantly lower than the $\sim 0.6 M_\odot$ typically found in normal SNe Ia, suggesting a less energetic thermonuclear explosion that left substantial unburned material in the ejecta.

Spectroscopic Peculiarities

Spectroscopic data from the New Technology Telescope (NTT) and the Shane reflector revealed two major anomalies in SN 2016ije:

  1. The Carbon Conundrum: The velocity of unburned carbon (C II) was measured at approximately $4500$ km/s, which is significantly lower than the velocity of silicon (Si II) at $\sim 8300$ km/s near maximum light. In standard explosion models, unburned material is typically located in the outer layers and moves faster. This inversion suggests that unburned carbon is present deep within the inner regions of the ejecta.
  2. Line Broadening: The absorption lines in SN 2016ije are broader than those of its 02es-like peers. This indicates a wide line-forming region along the line of sight, suggesting a specific geometric orientation or a more chaotic distribution of ejecta.

Explosion Mechanism: The Violent Merger Model

To explain these observations, the researchers compared SN 2016ije against various synthetic models, including delayed-detonation and double-detonation scenarios. The best fit was found in a violent merger model involving two white dwarfs (masses of $0.9 M_\odot$ and $0.76 M_\odot$).

Specifically, the data aligns with a viewing angle looking into an iron-group-element "cavity" created by the companion star during the merger (often referred to as the "n3" orientation in simulations). This model accounts for the low carbon velocity and the presence of unburned materials in the inner ejecta. The low metallicity of the host galaxy also appears to play a role in the early-time spectral evolution, making the violent merger model a compelling explanation for this specific event.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

SN 2016ije highlights the diversity of Type Ia supernovae and the importance of host galaxy environments in understanding their origins. While the violent merger model provides a strong explanation for the observed peculiarities, the authors note that 3D asymmetries in mergers are difficult to capture fully with current synthetic spectra.

Future studies will benefit from larger samples provided by surveys like the Rubin Observatory’s LSST. Additionally, polarization studies and more refined 3D numerical simulations will be essential to determine if the "merger-plus-orientation" theory can be generalized to the entire SN 2002es-like subclass.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have conducted photometric and spectroscopic observations of the peculiar Type Ia supernova (SN Ia) 2016ije that was discovered through the Tsinghua-NAOC Transient Survey. This peculiar object exploded in the outskirts of a metal-poor, low-surface brightness galaxy (i.e., $M_{g}$ = $-$14.5 mag). Our photometric analysis reveals that SN 2016ije is subluminous ($M_{B,\rm{max}}$ = $-$17.65$\pm$0.06 mag) but exhibits relatively broad light curves ($Δm_{15}(B)$ = 1.35$\pm$0.14 mag), similar to the behavior of SN 2002es. Our analysis of the bolometric light curve indicates that only 0.14$\pm$0.04 $M_{\odot}$ of $^{56}$Ni was synthesized in the explosion of SN 2016ije, which suggests a less energetic thermonuclear explosion when compared to normal SNe Ia, and this left a considerable amount of unburned materials in the ejecta. Spectroscopically, SN 2016ije resembles other SN 2002es-like SNe Ia, except that the ejecta velocity inferred from its carbon absorption line ($\sim$ 4500 km s$^{-1}$) is much lower than that from silicon lines ($\sim$ 8300 km s$^{-1}$) at around the maximum light. Additionally, most of the absorption lines are broader than other 02es-like SNe Ia. These peculiarities suggest the presence of significant unburned carbon in the inner region and a wide line-forming region along the line of sight. These characteristics suggest that SN 2016ije might originate from the violent merger of a white dwarf binary system, when viewed near an orientation along the iron-group-element cavity caused by the companion star.
BibTeX
@article{li2023sn,
  author = {Zhitong Li and Tianmeng Zhang and Xiaofeng Wang and Jujia Zhang and L. Galbany and A. V. Filippenko and Thomas G. Brink and C. Ashall and WeiKang Zheng and Thomas de Jaeger and Fabio Ragosta and M. Deckers and M. Gromadzki and D. R. Young and Gaobo Xi and Jun-Cheng Chen and Xulin Zhao and Hanna Sai and Shengyu Yan and Danfeng Xiang and Zhihao Chen and Wenxiong Li and Bo Wang and Hu Zou and Jipeng Sui and Jiali Wang and Jun Ma and Jundan Nie and Suijian Xue and Xu Zhou and Zhimin Zhou},
  title = {{SN 2016ije: An SN 2002es-like Type Ia Supernova Exploded in a Metal-poor and Low-surface Brightness Galaxy}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/accde3},
}
Figure