Smooth Optimization with Approximate Gradient

Alexandre d'Aspremont

TL;DR

This paper shows that Nesterov's optimal first-order optimization algorithm for smooth convex problems can tolerate small, bounded errors in gradient computations without sacrificing its optimal convergence rate. This allows for significant computational savings, particularly in applications like semidefinite programming where exact gradient computation is expensive.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many optimization problems, especially in areas like machine learning and operations research, involve minimizing a convex function over a compact set. For smooth convex functions with Lipschitz continuous gradients, Nesterov's algorithm achieves an optimal convergence rate of $O(1/\sqrt{\epsilon})$, where $\epsilon$ is the desired precision. However, computing the exact gradient can be computationally prohibitive in certain applications, such as semidefinite programming (SDP). In these cases, the gradient might involve computing matrix exponentials, which is often the bottleneck. The challenge is to determine if using an approximate gradient, which is cheaper to compute, can still achieve the same optimal convergence rate, thereby making these problems more tractable.

Methods

The core of the paper is a theoretical analysis of Nesterov's smooth optimization algorithm when the gradient oracle provides noisy information. The authors extend the convergence analysis of the original algorithm to handle gradients with a bounded error, formally defined by condition (2.3): $|(\nabla f(x) - \nabla \tilde{f}(x), y - z)| \le \delta \|x, y, z \in Q\|$. They prove that under certain conditions on the step size sequence and the quality of the approximate gradient (controlled by $\delta$), the optimal convergence rate of $O(1/\sqrt{\epsilon})$ is preserved.

The paper then applies these theoretical results to semidefinite optimization, specifically to maximum eigenvalue minimization problems. They leverage a smoothing technique to convert non-smooth problems into smooth ones, where the objective function has a Lipschitz continuous gradient. The key insight is that for these smoothed problems, computing the exact gradient involves a matrix exponential, but an approximate gradient can be obtained by computing only a few leading eigenvalues of a related matrix. This significantly reduces the computational cost per iteration.

Datasets

The paper uses randomly generated problem instances and problems generated from biological data sets (colon cancer data set) for numerical experiments. These are not presented as novel benchmark datasets but rather as examples to test the performance of the proposed method.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robustness to Noise: The most significant insight is that Nesterov's optimal algorithm is surprisingly robust to bounded gradient errors. This means that practical implementations, which inherently use approximations, can still achieve theoretical optimality.
  • Approximate Gradients for SDP: The paper demonstrates a practical pathway to significantly speed up semidefinite optimization problems by using approximate gradients derived from partial eigenvalue computations. This is a crucial step towards solving larger and more complex SDPs.
  • Trade-off between Iterations and Cost: While the theoretical convergence rate is preserved, the effective complexity (total computational cost) depends on the number of eigenvalues needed per iteration. This number can vary significantly with problem structure, leading to an open question about predicting this effective complexity.
  • Spectrum Matters: The paper highlights that the spectral properties of the matrices involved in SDPs (e.g., the distribution of eigenvalues) directly influence how many eigenvalues are needed for an accurate gradient approximation, and thus the overall computational cost.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Convergence: The paper proves that Nesterov's algorithm with approximate gradients (satisfying condition 2.3) maintains an optimal convergence rate of $O(1/\sqrt{\epsilon})$.
  • Computational Savings in SDP: For semidefinite optimization problems, using approximate gradients (via partial eigenvalue decomposition) can lead to substantial speedups. Table 4.1 shows that for problems of size $n=500$, the partial method is about ten times faster than using a full matrix exponential.
  • Empirical Performance: Numerical experiments show that the number of eigenvalues required per iteration can be small (e.g., one eigenvalue) for low precision targets, but increases significantly for higher precision. The performance gains are problem-dependent.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Predicting Effective Complexity: A major limitation acknowledged is the difficulty in predicting the effective complexity (total computational cost) based on problem structure. While the spectral properties are shown to be influential, a general rule for predicting the number of eigenvalues needed per iteration remains an open numerical question.
  • Bound on Iterations: The theoretical bound on the number of iterations (e.g., $8Ld(x^*) / (\sigma\epsilon)$) depends on quantities like $L$ (Lipschitz constant) and $d(x^*)$ (distance to optimum), which are often hard to bound a priori in practice.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the link between problem structure and the number of eigenvalues required for gradient approximation. They also note that while coalescence of eigenvalues near the optimum can theoretically increase iteration cost, this phenomenon was not observed in their numerical examples, perhaps due to the precision targets used. Future work could explore this further and investigate the practical implications of eigenvalue coalescence.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that the optimal complexity of Nesterov's smooth first-order optimization algorithm is preserved when the gradient is only computed up to a small, uniformly bounded error. In applications of this method to semidefinite programs, this means in some instances computing only a few leading eigenvalues of the current iterate instead of a full matrix exponential, which significantly reduces the method's computational cost. This also allows sparse problems to be solved efficiently using sparse maximum eigenvalue packages.
BibTeX
@article{daspremont2008smooth,
  author = {Alexandre d'Aspremont},
  title = {{Smooth Optimization with Approximate Gradient}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Optim.},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1137/060676386},
}
Figure