Abstract
Discriminatory caste attitudes currently stigmatize millions of Indians, subjecting individuals to prejudice in all aspects of life. Governmental incentives and societal movements have attempted to counter these attitudes, yet accurate measurements of public opinions on caste are not yet available for understanding whether progress is being made. Here, we introduce a novel approach to measure public attitudes of caste through an indicator variable: openness to intercaste marriage. Using a massive dataset of over 313K profiles from a major Indian matrimonial site, we precisely quantify public attitudes, along with differences between generations and between Indian residents and diaspora. We show that younger generations are more open to intercaste marriage, yet attitudes are based on a complex function of social status beyond their own caste. In examining the desired qualities in a spouse, we find that individuals open to intercaste marriage are more individualistic in the qualities they desire, rather than favoring family-related qualities, which mirrors larger societal trends away from collectivism. Finally, we show that attitudes in diaspora are significantly less open, suggesting a bi-cultural model of integration. Our research provides the first empirical evidence identifying how various intersections of identity shape attitudes toward intercaste marriage in India and among the Indian diaspora in the US.
The Challenge of Measuring Caste Attitudes
Caste-based discrimination remains a pervasive issue in India, influencing employment, social inclusion, and personal relationships. However, quantifying public sentiment on caste is difficult due to social desirability bias—the tendency for survey respondents to provide socially acceptable answers rather than their true beliefs. Furthermore, the mere incidence of intercaste marriage is an incomplete metric, as it does not account for individuals who are open to the idea but fail to find a suitable partner outside their caste. This study addresses these challenges by analyzing matrimonial profiles, where individuals or their families explicitly state their preferences regarding a partner's caste.
Methodology: Matrimonial Profiles as a Proxy
The researchers analyzed 313,308 anonymized profiles from Shaadi.com, one of India's largest matrimonial platforms. They used the "Caste No Bar" field as a primary indicator of openness to intercaste marriage. To distinguish between generational attitudes, the study compared "self-posted" profiles (representing the individual) with "family-posted" profiles (representing parents or relatives).
To ensure rigorous comparison, the team employed "One-to-One Almost Exact Matching," pairing self-posted and family-posted profiles with nearly identical socioeconomic demographics. Logistic regression models were then used to identify predictors of openness, while Natural Language Processing (NLP) was applied to free-text descriptions to extract spouse preferences.
Key Insights: The Complex Interplay of Status and Identity
The analysis revealed several nuanced findings regarding how socioeconomic status interacts with caste attitudes:
- The Education Paradox: For individuals posting for themselves, higher education is a strong predictor of openness. Conversely, when families post for their children, the candidate's education level has no significant impact on the family's openness. This suggests a "moral policing" effect where families maintain traditional boundaries regardless of professional achievement.
- The Brahmin Ceiling: Across all models, Brahmins—the highest tier in the traditional hierarchy—demonstrated the lowest levels of openness to intercaste marriage, even when controlling for other socioeconomic factors.
- The Geography of Bias: Surprisingly, South Indian states showed less openness than North Indian states, potentially due to cultural norms such as cross-cousin marriage.
Quantitative Results and Generational Shifts
The data confirms a significant generational shift toward greater openness. Individuals posting for themselves are more likely to be open to intercaste marriage than families posting on their behalf (23.94% vs. 20.82%).
Furthermore, the study highlighted "Diaspora Essentialism." The Indian diaspora in the U.S. is significantly less open to intercaste marriage (13.7%) than demographically identical individuals in India (22.9%). This supports the theory that minority groups in foreign environments may cling more tightly to traditional cultural markers to preserve their identity. Openness is also positively associated with urban density, suggesting that city living may slowly erode caste barriers. Text analysis further revealed that individuals open to intercaste marriage are significantly more likely to mention "Personality" in their descriptions, whereas those who are not open focus on "Family" and "Caste."
Limitations and Future Directions
The study acknowledges selection bias, as Shaadi.com users are typically more urban and affluent than the general Indian population. Additionally, the focus was primarily on the Hindu context. Future research could expand to other platforms and religions or utilize longitudinal data to track how attitudes evolve over time. Despite these limitations, this work provides the first large-scale empirical evidence of how identity intersections shape modern caste attitudes.
Summary updated