Small-scale convective turbulence constrains microbial patchiness

Alexander Christensen, Matthew D. Piggott, Erik van Sebille, Maarten van Reeuwijk, Samraat PawarResearch 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Microbes play a primary role in aquatic ecosystems and biogeochemical cycles. Patchiness is a critical component of these activities, influencing biological productivity, nutrient cycling and dynamics across trophic levels. Incorporating spatial dynamics into microbial models is a long-standing challenge, particularly where small-scale turbulence is involved. Here, we combine a realistic simulation of turbulence with an individual-based microbial model to test the key hypothesis that the coupling of motility and turbulence drives intense microscale patchiness. We find that such patchiness is depth-structured and requires high motility: Near the fluid surface, strong convective turbulence overpowers motility, homogenising motile and non-motile microbes equally. In deeper, thermocline-like conditions, highly motile microbes are up to 1.6-fold more patch-concentrated than non-motile microbes. Our results demonstrate that the delicate balance of turbulence and motility that triggers micro-scale patchiness is not a ubiquitous consequence of motility, and that the intensity of such patchiness in real-world conditions is modest.

Introduction

In aquatic environments, microbial distributions are rarely uniform. Instead, they often exhibit "patchiness"—spatial heterogeneity that significantly impacts nutrient cycling, predator-prey interactions, and viral transmission. A leading theoretical mechanism for this clumping is gyrotaxis, where bottom-heavy microbes attempt to swim vertically but are rotated by fluid shear. Under specific conditions, this balance between active reorientation and turbulent rotation can lead to "gyrotactic trapping," concentrating microbes into dense micro-scale patches.

However, previous studies often relied on idealized turbulence models. This research investigates whether gyrotactic patchiness persists in a realistic, 3D convective mixed layer where turbulence intensity varies significantly with depth.

Methodology

The study utilized a dual-modeling approach:

  1. Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS): The SPARKLE code simulated a 3D volume (0.6m x 0.6m x 0.3m) of water undergoing convective mixing driven by surface cooling. This resolved fluid motions down to the sub-millimeter Kolmogorov scale.
  2. Individual-Based Model (IBM): 100,000 virtual microbes were tracked using the OceanParcels framework. These agents were modeled as bottom-heavy spheres with varying swimming speeds ($v_{swim}$) and reorientation timescales ($B$).

Patchiness was quantified using 3D Voronoi tessellation to determine local concentrations. The "patch concentration enhancement factor" ($Q$) compared the density of motile microbes to passive control particles.

The Depth-Structured Turbulence Environment

The simulation revealed a distinct vertical structure in turbulence intensity. Near the surface (Shallow region), convective plumes create high turbulent kinetic energy ($k$) and dissipation rates ($\epsilon$). As depth increases toward the "Deep" region (analogous to a thermocline), these values decrease significantly.

Vertical profiles of turbulent kinetic energy (k) and dissipation rate (ε) across shallow, mid, and deep regions.

Results: Constraints on Patchiness

The findings indicate that microbial patchiness is a fragile phenomenon constrained by the local turbulence regime.

The "Blender" Effect vs. The Deep Patch

In the Shallow region, intense turbulence acts as a "blender," homogenizing the population regardless of swimming ability. Here, the patch enhancement factor $Q$ remains near zero. Significant patchiness only emerges in the Deep region, where turbulence is weak enough for microbial motility to compete with fluid shear. In these calmer waters, agile microbes were found to be up to 1.6 times more concentrated in patches than non-motile controls.

Agility and Parameter Sensitivity

Patchiness is highly sensitive to microbial traits. Only "agile" swimmers—those with high swimming speeds and rapid reorientation times—achieved notable clumping.

Patchiness metrics (Ψ and Φ) as a function of microbial swimming parameters and depth.

As shown in the figure above, the stability parameter $\Psi$ and the patchiness metric $\Phi$ vary significantly across depth layers. The "Deep" region consistently supports higher patchiness for a given set of swimming parameters compared to the "Shallow" and "Mid" regions.

Discussion and Limitations

While theoretical models sometimes predict massive increases in local concentration, these realistic simulations suggest a more modest reality. The maximum enhancement of ~1.6x indicates that while patchiness exists, it may not be as extreme in the open ocean as previously thought.

Several limitations remain:

  • Scale: The simulation is lab-scale; larger ocean layers may introduce additional dynamics.
  • Environmental Factors: Wind-driven turbulence and surface waves were not included, which might push patch-forming zones deeper.
  • Biological Complexity: The model lacks biological behaviors like chemotaxis or reproduction, which could further influence spatial distributions.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that small-scale convective turbulence serves as a primary constraint on microbial patchiness. The "tug-of-war" between swimming agility and turbulent intensity ensures that significant clumping is depth-dependent and restricted to specific microbial phenotypes. Understanding these physical limits is crucial for accurately modeling microbial ecology and biogeochemical fluxes in the ocean.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Microbes play a primary role in aquatic ecosystems and biogeochemical cycles. Patchiness is a critical component of these activities, influencing biological productivity, nutrient cycling and dynamics across trophic levels. Incorporating spatial dynamics into microbial models is a long-standing challenge, particularly where small-scale turbulence is involved. Here, we combine a realistic simulation of turbulence with an individual-based microbial model to test the key hypothesis that the coupling of motility and turbulence drives intense microscale patchiness. We find that such patchiness is depth-structured and requires high motility: Near the fluid surface, strong convective turbulence overpowers motility, homogenising motile and non-motile microbes equally. In deeper, thermocline-like conditions, highly motile microbes are up to 1.6-fold more patch-concentrated than non-motile microbes. Our results demonstrate that the delicate balance of turbulence and motility that triggers micro-scale patchiness is not a ubiquitous consequence of motility, and that the intensity of such patchiness in real-world conditions is modest.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{christensen2021small,
  author = {Alexander Christensen and Matthew D. Piggott and Erik van Sebille and Maarten van Reeuwijk and Samraat Pawar},
  title = {{Small-scale convective turbulence constrains microbial patchiness}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-152503/v1},
}
Figure