Small amplitude red giants elucidate the nature of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch as a standard candle

Richard I. Anderson, Nolan W. Koblischke, L. Eyer

TL;DR

Researchers have discovered that virtually all stars at the Tip of the Red Giant Branch (TRGB)—a crucial "standard candle" for measuring cosmic distances—are actually small-amplitude variable stars. By leveraging this variability, the authors show that different stellar populations (young vs. old) shift the TRGB magnitude by up to 0.085 mag, providing a new way to refine the Hubble constant and potentially resolve the "Hubble tension."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cosmology is currently facing a "Hubble tension": measurements of the universe's expansion rate ($H_0$) using the early universe (Cosmic Microwave Background) disagree with measurements from the local universe (the distance ladder). To fix this, we need incredibly precise "standard candles"—objects with a known intrinsic brightness.

The TRGB is one such candle. It marks the moment low-mass stars undergo a "helium flash," creating a sharp edge in a galaxy's luminosity function. However, the TRGB isn't perfectly uniform; its brightness can vary based on the age and chemical makeup (metallicity) of the stellar population. Until now, the low-level variability of these stars was considered "noise" or irrelevant. This paper argues that this variability is actually a "signal" that allows us to distinguish between different stellar populations, leading to much more accurate distance measurements.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-pronged approach to dissect the TRGB:

  1. Edge Detection: They used the standard Sobel filter (a derivative-based operator) on stellar luminosity functions to find the "inflection point" that defines the TRGB magnitude ($m_{TRGB}$).
  2. Variability Analysis: They cross-matched photometric data with catalogs of variable stars to identify Small Amplitude Red Giants (SARGs).
  3. Population Dissection: By plotting these stars on Period-Luminosity (PL) diagrams, they separated them into "Sequence A" (younger, more metal-rich) and "Sequence B" (older, more metal-poor).
  4. Simulations: They ran extensive Monte Carlo simulations to quantify how methodological choices—like how much you "smooth" the data or how you weight the edge detection—can introduce artificial biases in the results.

Datasets

The study relied on three major astronomical pillars:

  • OGLE-III: Provided high-cadence $V$- and $I$-band photometry for stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC).
  • Gaia DR3: Used for high-precision astrometry (to filter out foreground stars) and synthetic photometry ($F814W$ filter) to match Hubble Space Telescope standards.
  • APOGEE (DR17): Provided spectroscopic data to determine the actual ages and metallicities of the stars, confirming the evolutionary differences between the PL sequences.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Tip is Variable: The most striking finding is that nearly 100% of stars at the TRGB are variable. This transforms the TRGB from a static feature into a dynamic one that carries information about stellar evolution.
  • Sequence B is the "Gold Standard": The authors demonstrate that "Sequence B" stars are older (median age ~6.5 Gyr) and correspond most closely to the metal-poor populations typically found in the halos of distant galaxies. Using this specific subset provides a more "standard" candle than using all red giants indiscriminately.
  • Weighting Biases: A common practice in the field is to weight the edge detection response by the signal-to-noise ratio or Poisson statistics. The authors show that this actually introduces a "Tip-Contrast Relation"—a systematic bias that makes the TRGB appear brighter than it actually is (by up to 0.06 mag).
  • Population Diversity Matters: Simply choosing a different subset of stars (e.g., Sequence A vs. Sequence B) changes the measured distance by ~4%. In the quest for 1% precision in $H_0$, this is a massive effect that must be controlled.

Key Results

  • New Calibration: The authors provide a refined absolute magnitude for the TRGB in the $F814W$ filter: $M_{F814W,0} = -4.025 \pm 0.014 (\text{stat}) \pm 0.033 (\text{syst})$ mag.
  • Quantified Systematics: They identified that the SARG and A-sequence samples yield TRGB values that are 0.039 mag and 0.085 mag fainter, respectively, than the B-sequence.
  • Critique of Previous Work: The paper identifies several weaknesses in a recent high-profile LMC-based TRGB calibration (Hoyt 2023), suggesting that an incorrectly low reddening value and specific weighting choices may have biased previous $H_0$ estimates.

Limitations and Future Work

While this study provides a breakthrough in the LMC, the primary limitation is that the low-level variability of SARGs (0.01–0.04 mag) is difficult to detect in distant galaxies. We cannot yet "clean" every galaxy's TRGB by identifying variable stars.

However, the authors are optimistic. They suggest that the insights gained here—specifically regarding how color cuts and weighting schemes affect the measurement—can be applied to improve TRGB measurements made with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). Future work will involve applying these "variability-informed" techniques to the Small Magellanic Cloud and other nearby galaxies to further solidify the TRGB as a cornerstone of the extragalactic distance ladder.

Summary updated

Abstract

The tip of the red giant branch (TRGB) is an important standard candle for determining luminosity distances. Although several $10^5$ small amplitude red giant stars (SARGs) have been discovered, variability was previously considered irrelevant for the TRGB as a standard candle. Here, we show that all stars near the TRGB are SARGs that follow several period-luminosity sequences, of which sequence A is younger than sequence B as predicted by stellar evolution. We measure apparent TRGB magnitudes, m$_{\mathrm{TRGB}}$, in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), using Sobel filters applied to photometry from the Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment and the ESA Gaia mission, and we identify several weaknesses in a recent LMC-based TRGB calibration used to measure the Hubble constant. We consider four samples: all Red Giants (RGs), SARGs, and sequences A & B. The B-sequence is best suited for measuring distances to old RG populations, with M$_{\mathrm{F814W,0}}$ = -4.025 $\pm$ 0.014(stat.) $\pm$ 0.033(syst.) mag assuming the LMC's geometric distance. Control of systematics is demonstrated using detailed simulations. Population diversity affects m$_{\mathrm{TRGB}}$ at a level exceeding the stated precision: the SARG and A-sequence samples yield 0.039 mag and 0.085 mag fainter (at 5σ significance) m$_{\mathrm{TRGB}}$ values, respectively. Ensuring equivalent RG populations is crucial to measuring accurate TRGB distances. Additionally, luminosity function smoothing ($\sim$ 0.02 mag) and edge detection response weighting (as much as -0.06 mag) can further bias TRGB measurements, with the latter introducing a tip-contrast relation. We are optimistic that variable red giants will enable further improvements to the TRGB as a standard candle.
BibTeX
@article{anderson2024small,
  author = {Richard I. Anderson and Nolan W. Koblischke and L. Eyer},
  title = {{Small amplitude red giants elucidate the nature of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch as a standard candle}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ad284d},
}
Figure