Slow conformational exchange and overall rocking motion in ubiquitin protein crystals

Vilius Kurauskas, Sergei A. Izmailov, Olga N. Rogacheva, Audrey Hessel, Isabel Ayala, Joyce Woodhouse, Anastasya Shilova, Yi Xue, Tairan Yuwen, Nicolas Coquelle, Jacques‐Philippe Colletier, Nikolai R. Skrynnikov, Paul Schanda

Abstract

Proteins perform their functions in solution but their structures are most frequently studied inside crystals. Here we probe how the crystal packing alters microsecond dynamics, using solid-state NMR measurements and multi-microsecond MD simulations of different crystal forms of ubiquitin. In particular, near-rotary-resonance relaxation dispersion (NERRD) experiments probe angular backbone motion, while Bloch-McConnell relaxation dispersion data report on fluctuations of the local electronic environment. These experiments and simulations reveal that the packing of the protein can significantly alter the thermodynamics and kinetics of local conformational exchange. Moreover, we report small-amplitude reorientational motion of protein molecules in the crystal lattice with an ~3-5° amplitude on a tens-of-microseconds time scale in one of the crystals, but not in others. An intriguing possibility arises that overall motion is to some extent coupled to local dynamics. Our study highlights the importance of considering the packing when analyzing dynamics of crystalline proteins.

Introduction

X-ray crystallography remains the cornerstone of structural biology, providing high-resolution snapshots of protein architectures. However, these snapshots are often viewed as static representations of molecules that are inherently dynamic in their native solution environments. A critical question persists: to what extent does the rigid, ordered environment of a crystal lattice distort or suppress the natural conformational fluctuations of a protein?

While fast, picosecond-to-nanosecond motions are generally well-preserved in crystals, slower microsecond-to-millisecond dynamics—often the timescales relevant to enzyme catalysis and molecular recognition—are significantly more susceptible to crystal packing effects. This study investigates these effects using ubiquitin as a model system, focusing on a well-characterized loop flip to determine how different crystal environments alter its kinetics and thermodynamics.

Methodology

To capture the complex interplay between protein dynamics and crystal packing, the researchers employed a synergistic approach combining advanced spectroscopy and large-scale simulations:

  • Solid-State NMR (ssNMR) Spectroscopy: Two complementary $R_{1\rho}$ relaxation dispersion techniques were utilized. Bloch–McConnell (BMCRD) experiments were used to detect fluctuations in local electronic environments (chemical shifts), while Near-Rotary-Resonance (NERRD) experiments provided sensitivity to the angular reorientation of backbone H–N bond vectors.
  • Explicit Crystal Molecular Dynamics (MD): Moving beyond single-molecule simulations, the team performed multi-microsecond simulations of entire crystal lattices (containing up to 48 molecules). This approach explicitly accounts for the intermolecular forces and steric constraints imposed by neighboring proteins in the lattice.
  • Comparative Analysis: The study compared two distinct crystal forms of ubiquitin: MPD-ub and cubic-PEG-ub. By analyzing different packing arrangements, the researchers could isolate the specific effects of the lattice environment on protein behavior.

The Impact of Crystal Packing on Protein Dynamics

The study revealed that the crystal environment acts as more than just a passive cage; it actively reshapes the protein's energy landscape.

The "Crystal Slowdown"

A primary finding was a dramatic reduction in the speed of conformational exchange. In solution, the characteristic loop flip in ubiquitin occurs on a timescale of approximately 6 $\mu$s. Within the crystal lattice, this motion is slowed by a factor of roughly 15, with exchange time constants ($\tau_{ex}$) measured at $90 \pm 25$ $\mu$s for MPD-ub and $125 \pm 45$ $\mu$s for cubic-PEG-ub. This slowdown is attributed to the physical constraints and increased effective viscosity within the crowded lattice environment.

Thermodynamic Shifts and Structural Switching

Beyond kinetics, the crystal lattice can alter the thermodynamic preference for specific conformations. In solution, ubiquitin predominantly adopts a "Type-I" $\beta$-turn in the 50s loop region. However, in the MPD-ub crystal form, packing interactions—specifically the obstruction of the E24 side chain—force the protein to favor a "Type-II" conformation. This demonstrates that the crystal environment can effectively act as a conformational switch, stabilizing states that are less populated in solution.

Structural differences and relaxation dispersion data for ubiquitin crystals. (a) Comparison of cubic-PEG-ub and MPD-ub crystal forms showing the Type-I and Type-II β-turn conformations. (b-d) $R_{1\rho}$ relaxation dispersion profiles for residues D58, T55, and I23.

Discovery of Molecular "Rocking"

Perhaps the most intriguing discovery was the observation of collective "rocking" motion in the cubic-PEG-ub crystal. NERRD data and MD simulations confirmed that the entire protein molecule undergoes a small-amplitude tilt (3–5°) on a tens-of-microseconds timescale. Interestingly, this rocking was not observed in the MPD-ub form, suggesting it is a property highly dependent on the specific lattice architecture. The authors propose that this global motion may be coupled to local loop dynamics, potentially mediated by specific intermolecular interactions like the K11-D52 salt bridge.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This research highlights the necessity of considering the crystal environment when interpreting protein dynamics from crystallographic data. The "static" structures deposited in the PDB may represent states influenced by lattice-induced thermodynamic shifts and restricted by a significant kinetic slowdown.

While the study provides a detailed view of ubiquitin, several questions remain. MD force fields, while powerful, still struggle to perfectly replicate experimental exchange rates, often overestimating the speed of transitions. Furthermore, the extent to which these findings generalize to larger, more flexible proteins remains to be explored. Future work will likely focus on refining these computational models and investigating whether the coupling between local and global motions is a widespread phenomenon in protein crystals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Proteins perform their functions in solution but their structures are most frequently studied inside crystals. Here we probe how the crystal packing alters microsecond dynamics, using solid-state NMR measurements and multi-microsecond MD simulations of different crystal forms of ubiquitin. In particular, near-rotary-resonance relaxation dispersion (NERRD) experiments probe angular backbone motion, while Bloch-McConnell relaxation dispersion data report on fluctuations of the local electronic environment. These experiments and simulations reveal that the packing of the protein can significantly alter the thermodynamics and kinetics of local conformational exchange. Moreover, we report small-amplitude reorientational motion of protein molecules in the crystal lattice with an ~3-5° amplitude on a tens-of-microseconds time scale in one of the crystals, but not in others. An intriguing possibility arises that overall motion is to some extent coupled to local dynamics. Our study highlights the importance of considering the packing when analyzing dynamics of crystalline proteins.X-ray crystallography is the main method for protein structure determination. Here the authors combine solid-state NMR measurements and molecular dynamics simulations and show that crystal packing alters the thermodynamics and kinetics of local conformational exchange as well as overall rocking motion of protein molecules in the crystal lattice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kurauskas2017slow,
  author = {Vilius Kurauskas and Sergei A. Izmailov and Olga N. Rogacheva and Audrey Hessel and Isabel Ayala and Joyce Woodhouse and Anastasya Shilova and Yi Xue and Tairan Yuwen and Nicolas Coquelle and Jacques‐Philippe Colletier and Nikolai R. Skrynnikov and Paul Schanda},
  title = {{Slow conformational exchange and overall rocking motion in ubiquitin protein crystals}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-00165-8},
}
Figure