Slow conformational changes in the rigid and highly stable chymotrypsin inhibitor 2

Yulian Gavrilov, Andreas Prestel, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Kaare Teilum

TL;DR

This study investigates slow, millisecond-timescale conformational changes in the highly stable chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2) protein. Using NMR spectroscopy, the researchers found that these subtle structural rearrangements, linked to well-ordered water molecules, are present in both wild-type and mutated CI2, with their population correlating to the overall protein stability. This work sheds light on how protein dynamics, even in seemingly rigid proteins, can be coupled to function and stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteins are not static entities; they exhibit a range of motions from atomic vibrations to large-scale domain movements. While fast dynamics (femtosecond to nanosecond) are often linked to protein function, the role and impact of slower conformational changes (microsecond to millisecond) on protein folding stability are less understood. Specifically, how these slower dynamics might perturb the overall stability of a protein, especially a known stable and rigid one like chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2), remains an open question. CI2 is a well-studied model protein for folding and stability, typically exhibiting a two-state folding mechanism. This paper aims to characterize these slow conformational dynamics in CI2 and explore their relationship with protein stability, particularly in the context of previously identified stabilizing mutations.

Methods

The core technique employed in this study is <sup>15</sup>N CPMG (Car-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill) spin relaxation dispersion. This NMR method is specifically designed to detect and quantify conformational exchange processes occurring on the millisecond timescale. By measuring how the relaxation rate of <sup>15</sup>N-labeled protein nuclei changes with the applied magnetic field (CPMG frequency), researchers can extract key parameters of this exchange:

  • Exchange rate (k<sub>ex</sub>): The speed at which the protein interconverts between its conformational states.
  • Population of the minor state (p<sub>N*</sub>): The relative abundance of the alternative conformation.
  • Chemical shift difference (|Δω|): The difference in NMR chemical shifts between the two states, providing insights into structural changes.

The researchers applied this technique to wild-type CI2 at various temperatures and to three specific mutants (L49I, I57V, and L49I/I57V) at a single temperature. The data was analyzed using a two-state exchange model, fitting the experimental relaxation dispersion profiles to extract these parameters.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental NMR data collected from protein samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CI2 isn't entirely rigid: Despite its reputation as a rigid and stable protein, CI2 exhibits significant slow conformational dynamics on the millisecond timescale. This challenges the notion of absolute rigidity in such proteins.
  • Water molecules are key players: The observed slow conformational changes are strongly associated with residues that interact with well-defined water molecules. This highlights the crucial role of hydration in protein dynamics and stability, even in the folded state.
  • Minor state stability mirrors major state stability: The population of the minor, higher-energy state (p<sub>N*</sub>) is not uniform across all CI2 variants. It is most populated in the most stable variants (like L49I/I57V) and least populated in the least stable ones. This suggests that the factors influencing the stability of the major folded state also influence the stability of this minor conformational state.
  • Mutations have subtle structural effects on the minor state: While the stabilizing mutations (L49I and I57V) influence the stability of the minor state, they have only a minor effect on its structure. This suggests that the mutations primarily alter the energetic landscape rather than the specific structural rearrangements of the excited state.
  • Negative heat capacity (ΔC<sub>p</sub>) of the transition: The transition to the minor state has a negative heat capacity, which is opposite to protein unfolding. This suggests that the minor state might involve a decrease in solvent-accessible surface area, possibly due to better packing or altered water interactions.

Key Results

  • Presence of a minor conformational state: CI2 exists in at least two folded states on the millisecond timescale, with a minor, higher-energy state (N*) populated at 4.3% at 1°C.
  • Temperature dependence: The population of the minor state (p<sub>N*</sub>) decreases with increasing temperature, becoming less than 0.1% at 54°C.
  • Localized dynamics: The most significant chemical shift differences, indicative of structural changes, are clustered around residues in the N-terminal end of the main β-strands and in the inhibitory loop.
  • Variant-specific populations: The population of the minor state (p<sub>N*</sub>) at 5°C varies among the analyzed variants: L49I/I57V (4.8%), L49I (3.6%), WT (4.2%), and I57V (4.0%). This correlates with their known overall folding stabilities.
  • Similar structures of the minor state: The chemical shift differences (|Δω|) for the minor state are largely similar across all four variants, indicating that the mutations do not drastically alter the structure of this excited state.
  • Activation enthalpy: The activation enthalpy for the transition from the minor to the major state is approximately 63 kJ/mol, comparable to that of CI2 folding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Structural determination of the minor state: While the study identifies the regions involved in slow conformational changes, it lacks the resolution to determine the precise 3D structure of the minor state (N*). The authors suggest comparing variations across existing crystal structures of CI2 as a potential avenue for gaining structural hints.
  • Direct measurement of water dynamics: Quantifying the exchange of water molecules directly is experimentally challenging due to the vast excess of bulk water. The authors mention specialized techniques but note their complexity.
  • Unfolding of the minor state: The paper cannot definitively determine if both the major and minor folded states can unfold directly. However, they argue that the low population and fast equilibrium of the minor state make it unlikely to significantly impact conclusions about CI2's two-state folding behavior.

Future work could focus on developing more advanced NMR techniques or complementary biophysical methods to directly visualize the structure of the minor state. Further investigation into the precise role of specific water molecules and their exchange dynamics would also be valuable. The authors also suggest that CI2 could serve as an excellent model for studying the role of long-lived water molecules in protein structures and for benchmarking long millisecond molecular dynamics simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Slow conformational changes are often directly linked to protein function. It is however less clear how such processes may perturb the overall folding stability of a protein. We previously found that the stabilizing double mutant L49I/I57V in the small protein chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 from barley led to distributed increased nanosecond and faster dynamics. Here we asked what effects the L49I and I57V substitutions, either individually or together, have on the slow conformational dynamics of CI2. We used <sup>15</sup> N CPMG spin relaxation dispersion experiments to measure the kinetics, thermodynamics, and structural changes associated with slow conformational change in CI2. These changes result in an excited state that is populated to 4.3% at 1°C. As the temperature is increased the population of the excited state decreases. Structural changes in the excited state are associated with residues that interact with water molecules that have well defined positions and are found at these positions in all crystal structures of CI2. The substitutions in CI2 have only little effect on the structure of the excited state whereas the stability of the excited state to some extent follows the stability of the main state. The minor state is thus most populated for the most stable CI2 variant and least populated for the least stable variant. We hypothesize that the interactions between the substituted residues and the well-ordered water molecules links subtle structural changes around the substituted residues to the region in the protein that experience slow conformational changes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gavrilov2023slow,
  author = {Yulian Gavrilov and Andreas Prestel and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Kaare Teilum},
  title = {{Slow conformational changes in the rigid and highly stable chymotrypsin inhibitor 2}},
  booktitle = {Protein},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1002/pro.4604},
}
Figure