Abstract
Natural killer (NK) cells eliminate infected and tumorigenic cells through delivery of granzymes via perforin pores or by activation of caspases via death receptors. In order to understand how NK cells combine different cell death mechanisms, it is important to quantify target cell responses on a single cell level. However, currently existing reporters do not allow the measurement of several protease activities inside the same cell. Here, we present a strategy for the comparison of two different proteases at a time inside individual target cells upon engagement by NK cells. We developed single-fluorescent protein reporters containing the RIEAD or the VGPD cleavage site for the measurement of granzyme B activity. We show that these two granzyme B reporters can be applied in combination with caspase-8 or caspase-3 reporters. While we did not find that caspase-8 was activated by granzyme B, our method revealed that caspase-3 activity follows granzyme B activity with a delay of about 6 min. Finally, we illustrate the comparison of several different reporters for granzyme A, M, K, and H. The approach presented here is a valuable means for the investigation of the temporal evolution of cell death mediated by cytotoxic lymphocytes.
Introduction
Natural Killer (NK) cells serve as the body’s specialized immune surveillance system, tasked with identifying and eliminating infected or malignant cells. This elimination occurs through two primary pathways: the delivery of cytotoxic granzymes via perforin pores and the activation of internal "suicide" enzymes, known as caspases, through death receptor signaling. While these pathways are well-characterized in isolation, the precise temporal orchestration and relative dominance of these mechanisms within a single target cell have remained elusive.
The primary technical barrier has been the difficulty of "multiplexing" traditional reporters, such as those based on Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET). FRET-based tools often suffer from spectral overlap, making it challenging to monitor more than one protease activity simultaneously without signal interference. This study introduces a novel class of "single-fluorescent protein reporters" designed to overcome this limitation, allowing researchers to track multiple lethal enzymes in real-time at the single-cell level.
Methodology: The Single-FP Reporter System
The researchers developed a modular reporter system consisting of three key components: a localization domain (a Nuclear Export Signal, or NES), a specific cleavage linker, and a single fluorescent protein (e.g., mGFP or mCherry).
As illustrated in the figure above, the intact reporter is actively excluded from the nucleus by the NES. When a specific protease (such as Granzyme B or Caspase-3) enters or is activated within the cell, it cleaves the linker. The liberated fluorescent protein is small enough to diffuse freely into the nucleus. By monitoring the increase in nuclear fluorescence using time-lapse confocal microscopy, the researchers can precisely quantify the timing and magnitude of protease activity. Because each reporter utilizes only a single color, multiple reporters can be combined to monitor several proteases simultaneously.
Key Findings and Insights
The application of these reporters revealed several critical insights into the "molecular choreography" of NK cell-mediated killing:
- The 6-Minute Executioner Delay: By multiplexing Granzyme B and Caspase-3 reporters, the study found that Caspase-3 activation consistently follows Granzyme B entry with a delay of approximately 6 minutes. This provides a precise timeline for the transition from the initiation of the attack to the final execution phase of cell death.
- Resolving the Caspase-8 Pathway: There has been ongoing debate regarding whether Granzyme B directly activates Caspase-8. Using these reporters, the authors demonstrated that Caspase-8 activation during an NK cell attack is primarily driven by the CD95 (Fas) death receptor pathway, rather than direct cleavage by Granzyme B.
- Granzyme Hierarchy: In NK92 cell models, Granzyme B and Granzyme A were identified as the most active cytosolic proteases. In contrast, activity for Granzymes H, K, and M was significantly lower or absent, suggesting a clear hierarchy in the NK cell's arsenal.
- Specificity and Precision: The reporters proved highly specific. For instance, Granzyme B reporter cleavage was significantly inhibited by Serpin B9, a natural Granzyme B inhibitor. Furthermore, the onset of Caspase-3 activity was found to occur roughly 10 minutes before physical signs of cell death, such as cell shrinkage and rounding, became apparent.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This new reporter strategy provides a powerful tool for studying the stochastic nature of immune cell interactions. By measuring multiple events within the same cell, researchers can account for the inherent variability in the timing of NK-target contacts.
While the current method is optimized for adherent cell lines like HeLa and MDA-MB-468, future work may adapt these tools for cells in suspension. Additionally, while these reporters primarily measure cytosolic activity, they offer a foundation for developing organelle-specific sensors. Ultimately, this technology holds potential for clinical applications, such as assessing the killing efficiency of patient-derived NK cells in cancer immunotherapy contexts.
Summary updated