Single-cell dissection of a collective behaviour in honeybees

Ian M. Traniello, Syed Abbas Bukhari, Payam Dibaeinia, Guillermo Serrano, Arián Avalos, Amy Cash-Ahmed, Alison L. Sankey, Mikel Hernáez, Saurabh Sinha, Sihai Dave Zhao, Julian Catchen, Gene E. RobinsonbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how genetic variations influence collective behavior in honeybees by analyzing single-cell brain transcriptomics and gene regulatory networks (GRNs). They found that genetic differences in aggression are reflected in GRN architecture, particularly in foragers, suggesting an evolutionary adaptation in the division of labor for colony defense.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how genetic variation translates into complex collective behaviors is a significant challenge in biology. Honeybees exhibit sophisticated collective defense mechanisms, with different groups of bees playing specialized roles. While previous studies identified genes associated with colony-level aggression, the specific impact of these genetic variations on individual bee brain function and how they shape collective behavior remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by dissecting the genetic underpinnings of aggression at the single-cell level within the honeybee brain.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Single-cell RNA Sequencing (scRNA-Seq): This technique allowed them to profile gene expression in individual brain cells from both aggressive soldier bees and less aggressive forager bees.
  • Gene Regulatory Network (GRN) Analysis: They used computational methods (SimiC and GENIE3) to infer GRNs, which model the complex relationships between transcription factors (TFs) and their target genes (TGs). This allowed them to assess how these networks differ between soldier and forager brains.
  • Expression Quantitative Trait Loci (eQTL) Mapping: This method was used to link genetic variants (SNPs) to gene expression levels, helping to identify genes whose expression is influenced by genetic variations associated with colony aggression.
  • Comparative Analysis: They compared GRN architecture and gene expression patterns between soldiers and foragers, and between bees from high-aggression and low-aggression colonies.

Datasets

The study utilized existing datasets and generated new ones:

  • Previously collected whole-genome data: From Africanized honeybee (AHB) populations in Puerto Rico, used for identifying colony aggression genes.
  • Newly generated scRNA-Seq data: From the brains of soldier and forager bees from both Africanized honeybee (Puerto Rico) and European honeybee (Urbana, Illinois) colonies. This dataset comprises approximately 24,000 cells.
  • Existing insect brain atlases and gene expression data: Used for annotating cell types within the honeybee brain.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GRN architecture, not just gene expression, reflects genetic differences: While direct gene expression differences between soldiers and foragers were not always pronounced, the regulatory relationships within their brains (i.e., GRN architecture) showed significant differences, especially in high-aggression colonies. This suggests that how genes are regulated is more critical than just their overall expression level for understanding behavioral differences.
  • Foragers show more pronounced genetic differences than soldiers: Surprisingly, genetic differences in GRN architecture were more pronounced in forager bees than in soldier bees. This challenges the intuition that the most aggressive individuals would show the most genetic variation related to aggression.
  • Evolutionary adaptation in division of labor: The findings point towards an evolutionary change in the division of labor for colony defense, where genetic factors might be influencing the propensity of foragers to participate in defense, in addition to soldiers' roles.
  • Serotonin metabolism implicated: The study highlights the role of serotonin metabolism, a known regulator of aggression, and its genetic underpinnings in shaping these behavioral differences.
  • Specific brain regions are key: The identified GRN differences were prominent in specific brain cell populations, including Kenyon cells in the mushroom bodies and astrocyte-like glia, which are involved in sensory processing (olfaction and vision) and behavioral plasticity.

Key Results

  • No significant overlap between aggression genes and DEGs: Differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between soldiers and foragers did not significantly overlap with the previously identified "colony aggression genes" or eGenes.
  • Greater GRN dissimilarity in high-aggression colonies: Regulatory dissimilarity between soldiers and foragers was significantly greater in high-aggression colonies compared to low-aggression colonies.
  • eGenes form tightly connected subnetworks: Genes identified through eQTL mapping (eGenes) formed highly interconnected regulatory subnetworks, suggesting a coordinated genetic influence on brain function.
  • Serotonin receptor gene expression correlated with aggression: The expression of serotonin receptor genes (5HT1B and 5HT2a) was correlated with the expression of tryptophan metabolism genes (TrypRS-m), particularly in foragers and in more aggressive colonies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation vs. Causation: While the study identifies strong correlations between genetic variations, GRN architecture, and behavior, establishing direct causal links requires further experimental validation.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on specific honeybee populations. Future work could explore these findings across a wider range of honeybee subspecies and social insect species.
  • Functional Validation: The authors suggest that future research should focus on experimentally validating the identified GRN differences and their functional consequences on behavior. This could involve gene editing or manipulation techniques.
  • Broader implications for collective behavior: The study's approach of integrating population genetics with systems biology through scGRNs offers a powerful framework for understanding the evolution of collective behaviors in other species.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Understanding how genotypic variation results in phenotypic variation, a major challenge in biology, is especially difficult for collective behaviour because collective group phenotypes arise from complex interactions between group members 1 . Honeybees aggressively defend their colony from attacks with highly integrated collective behaviour in which different groups of bees play specific roles, giving rise to distinct colony-level differences in aggression. A previous genome-wide association study of a population of Africanized honeybees ( Apis mellifera scutellata ) from Puerto Rico that recently evolved decreased aggression identified hundreds of genes with single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that associated with colony-level variation in aggression 2 . Many of these SNPs also showed strong signals of selection for decreased aggression 2,3 , but their influence on brain function was unknown. Using brain single-cell (sc) transcriptomics and sc gene regulatory network analysis, we show here that variants of these genes give rise to genetic differences in transcription factor-target gene relationships. These differences involved the activity of several TFs, some that have been previously associated with aggression, like single stranded-binding protein c31A , and some that have been associated with tissue morphogenesis but not behaviour, like apontic . The activity of these and other TFs was located in specific brain cell populations related to olfaction and vision, the two sensory modalities that bees use in colony defence. They also implicate metabolism of serotonin, a neurochemical already known to influence honeybee aggression, but not from a genetic perspective. Surprisingly, genetic differences were more pronounced in the brains of forager bees than in similarly aged but more aggressive soldier bees, pointing to an evolutionary change in division of labour for colony defence. Our results demonstrate how group genetics can shape a collective phenotype by modulating individual brain gene regulatory network architecture.
BibTeX
@misc{traniello2022single,
  author = {Ian M. Traniello and Syed Abbas Bukhari and Payam Dibaeinia and Guillermo Serrano and Arián Avalos and Amy Cash-Ahmed and Alison L. Sankey and Mikel Hernáez and Saurabh Sinha and Sihai Dave Zhao and Julian Catchen and Gene E. Robinson},
  title = {{Single-cell dissection of a collective behaviour in honeybees}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.03.29.486106},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure