Simultaneously Transmitting and Reflecting (STAR)-RISs: Are They Applicable to Dual-Sided Incidence?

Jiaqi Xu, Xidong Mu, Joey Tianyi Zhou, Yuanwei Liu

TL;DR

This paper extends the concept of Simultaneously Transmitting and Reflecting Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (STAR-RISs) to "dual-sided incidence," where signals strike both sides of the surface at once. The authors prove that these surfaces are inherently symmetrical under scalar impedance conditions and demonstrate that pairing STAR-RIS with Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) significantly outperforms traditional orthogonal schemes in uplink scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RISs) have gained massive traction for their ability to "steer" the wireless environment. However, conventional RISs are reflection-only, limiting them to a 180° half-space. The recently proposed STAR-RIS solves this by allowing signals to both permeate (transmit) and bounce off (reflect) the surface, achieving full 360° coverage.

Most existing research assumes a "single-sided" model—typically a downlink scenario where a base station hits one side of the surface. But what happens in the uplink, where users located on both sides of the surface transmit simultaneously? This paper fills that knowledge gap by providing the hardware and signal models necessary to understand how STAR-RIS handles dual-sided signal incidence.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-step analytical approach:

  1. Electromagnetic (EM) Modeling: Using the principles of surface electric and magnetic currents ($J_s$ and $K_s$), the authors model an electrically thin STAR-RIS element. They derive the relationship between incident fields and radiated fields.
  2. Symmetry Proof: A key contribution is the proof that if the surface impedance of an element is characterized by scalars, the transmission and reflection (T&R) coefficients are identical for both sides. This means $T_{A \to B} = T_{B \to A}$ and $R_A = R_B$, simplifying the hardware design and signal processing.
  3. System Simulation: They model a two-user uplink system where one user is on the "reflection side" and the other is on the "transmission side."
  4. Statistical Approximation: To handle the complexity of double-Rician cascaded channels, the authors use the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to approximate the aggregate channel as a normal distribution, allowing for closed-form expressions of outage probabilities in high-SNR regimes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The results are based on theoretical derivations and numerical simulations using standard wireless channel models (Rician fading).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Symmetry Principle: The discovery that STAR-RIS elements are naturally symmetrical under scalar impedance is a major "aha moment." It suggests that hardware doesn't need to be specialized for "front" or "back" incidence, reducing manufacturing complexity.
  • NOMA Synergy: The paper highlights that STAR-RIS and NOMA are a perfect match. Because the surface can adjust the power ratio between transmitted and reflected signals, it provides an additional "knob" to tune the power levels required for successful Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) in NOMA.
  • The High-SNR Error Floor: Unlike traditional systems where increasing power always helps, the authors found that in this dual-sided uplink, the outage probability eventually hits an "error floor." This floor isn't caused by noise, but by the inherent interference between the two users sharing the surface.

Key Results

  • NOMA vs. OMA: Numerical results show that STAR-RIS-aided NOMA consistently achieves lower outage probabilities than Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) for both users.
  • Model Accuracy: The approximation of the cascaded Rician channel as a normal distribution was validated using Kullback–Leibler (KL) divergence. The error becomes negligible once the surface has more than 20 elements ($M \ge 20$).
  • Tunable Performance: The authors demonstrated that the outage probability error floor can be lowered by carefully adjusting the ratio between the amplitudes of transmission and reflection coefficients ($\beta^T$ and $\beta^R$). For instance, decreasing the transmission coefficient can significantly benefit the user on the reflection side without necessarily tanking the other user's performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalar Impedance Assumption: The proof of symmetry relies on scalar surface impedance. Future work could explore tensor-based impedances, which are common in more complex metasurface designs and might break this symmetry.
  • User Scaling: This study focused on a two-user setup. Real-world deployments will involve many more users, requiring more complex interference management and beamforming strategies.
  • Hardware Impairments: The model assumes relatively ideal hardware. Investigating the impact of phase-shift errors or amplitude fluctuations in a dual-sided context would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

A hardware model and a signal model are proposed for dual-sided simultaneously transmitting and reflecting reconfigurable intelligent surfaces (STAR-RISs), where the signal simultaneously incident on both sides of the surface. Based on the proposed hardware model, signal models for dual-sided STAR-RISs are developed. For elements with scalar surface impedance, it is proved that their transmission and reflection coefficients on both sides are identical. Based on the obtained symmetrical dual-sided STAR model, a STAR-RIS-aided two-user uplink communication system is investigated for both non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) and orthogonal multiple access (OMA) schemes. Analytical results for the outage probabilities for users are derived in the high transmit signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) regime. Numerical results demonstrate the performance gain of NOMA over OMA and reveal that the outage probability error floor can be lowered by adjusting the ratio between the amplitudes of transmission and reflection signals.
BibTeX
@article{xu2023simultaneously,
  author = {Jiaqi Xu and Xidong Mu and Joey Tianyi Zhou and Yuanwei Liu},
  title = {{Simultaneously Transmitting and Reflecting (STAR)-RISs: Are They Applicable to Dual-Sided Incidence?}},
  journal = {IEEE Wireless Communications Letters},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/lwc.2022.3219017},
}
Figure