Significantly Super-Chandrasekhar Limiting Mass White Dwarfs and their Consequences

Banibrata Mukhopadhyay, Upasana Das, A. R. Rao, Sathyawageeswar Subramanian, Mukul Bhattacharya, Subroto Mukerjee, Tanayveer Singh Bhatia, Jagannath Sutradhar

TL;DR

This paper challenges the century-old Chandrasekhar limit, proposing that highly magnetized white dwarfs (B-WDs) can reach masses up to $\sim 2.58 M_\odot$—nearly 80% higher than the standard limit. These "super-Chandrasekhar" stars offer a compelling explanation for over-luminous Type Ia supernovae and mysterious high-energy sources like Soft Gamma-ray Repeaters (SGRs) while remaining surprisingly difficult to detect due to their low luminosity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In 1935, Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar established that white dwarfs have a maximum mass of approximately $1.44 M_\odot$. Beyond this, electron degeneracy pressure can no longer withstand gravity, leading to a collapse. However, modern observations have revealed "peculiar" Type Ia supernovae that are far too bright to be explained by a $1.44 M_\odot$ progenitor.

Additionally, high-energy phenomena like Soft Gamma-ray Repeaters (SGRs) and Anomalous X-ray Pulsars (AXPs) are typically attributed to "magnetars" (highly magnetized neutron stars). However, the magnetar model struggles to explain certain observations, such as low ultraviolet luminosities and specific spin periods. The authors seek to provide a unified theoretical framework that accounts for these anomalies using magnetized white dwarfs.

Methods

The researchers employed several computational and theoretical approaches to model these massive white dwarfs:

  • Landau Quantization: They incorporated quantum mechanical effects into the Equation of State (EoS). In the presence of intense magnetic fields, electron energy levels become quantized (Landau levels), which significantly alters the pressure-density relationship.
  • GRMHD Modeling: To move beyond simple spherical models, they used General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations (specifically the publicly available XNS code). This allowed them to model the stars as ellipsoids, accounting for the structural distortions caused by magnetic fields and rotation.
  • Modified Gravity: As an alternative "avenue," they explored Starobinsky-model gravity ($f(R)$ gravity) to see if modifications to Einstein's general relativity could similarly support higher white dwarf masses.
  • Luminosity Calculations: They modeled the star as a degenerate core surrounded by an ideal gas envelope to calculate the temperature profile and photon diffusion, determining how bright these objects would appear to observers.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, it does not use a "training dataset" in the machine learning sense. Instead, it validates its models against:

  • Observational Data of SNeIa: Specifically "over-luminous" events that suggest progenitors in the $2.1–2.8 M_\odot$ range.
  • Specific Astrophysical Sources: Data from SGRs, AXPs, and unique objects like the transient radio source GCRT J1745-3009 and the white dwarf pulsar AR Sco.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A New Mass Limit: By including magnetic field effects, the authors derive a new limiting mass $M_l \approx 2.58 M_\odot$ (for a mean molecular weight per electron $\mu_e = 2$).
  • The "Invisible" Giant: Despite being more massive, B-WDs are predicted to be significantly less luminous than their low-magnetic counterparts (as low as $10^{-13} L_\odot$). This explains why they haven't been widely observed yet—they are essentially "dim" massive stars.
  • Standard Candle Alternative: The existence of these stars suggests a "second standard candle" for cosmology, which could refine our understanding of cosmic expansion.
  • Rotational Power: The paper suggests that the high-energy emissions of SGRs/AXPs can be explained by the rotational energy of a B-WD, which has a larger moment of inertia than a neutron star, removing the need to invoke "extraordinarily strong, yet unobserved" magnetic fields.

Key Results

  • Mass-Radius Scaling: The authors found that for highly magnetized stars, the mass becomes independent of central density at a certain limit, similar to the original Chandrasekhar derivation but at a much higher threshold.
  • Quantitative Example: A modeled B-WD with a central magnetic field of $8.8 \times 10^{15}$ G reached a mass of $2.44 M_\odot$ with a radius of only 650 km.
  • Luminosity Suppression: Table 1 in the paper shows that as the magnetic field increases, the surface temperature ($T_s$) and luminosity ($L$) drop drastically. For example, a star with a $10^{13}$ G central field might have a luminosity $10^8$ times smaller than a non-magnetic white dwarf.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stability Concerns: The authors acknowledge critiques regarding the stability of these stars. Previous models using purely poloidal or purely toroidal magnetic fields are known to be unstable.
  • Mixed Field Configurations: The authors argue that the next step is to model "mixed" field configurations (a combination of poloidal and toroidal) with rotation, which are expected to be more stable and naturally occurring.
  • Systematic Unfolding: Future work aims to explore the actual connection to over-luminous SNeIa more deeply and perform self-consistent stability analyses based on realistic magnetic geometries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since 2012, we have initiated a new idea showing that the mass of highly magnetized or modified Einstein's gravity induced white dwarfs could be significantly super-Chandrasekhar with a different mass-limit. This discovery has several important consequences, including explanation of peculiar, over-luminous type Ia supernovae, soft gamma-ray repeaters and anomalous X-ray pulsars without invoking extraordinarily strong, yet unobserved, magnetic fields. It further argues for a possible second standard candle. Based on simpler calculations, these white dwarfs are also shown to be much less luminous than their standard counter-parts (of low magnetic fields). This discovery altogether initiates a new field of research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mukhopadhyay2017significantly,
  author = {Banibrata Mukhopadhyay and Upasana Das and A. R. Rao and Sathyawageeswar Subramanian and Mukul Bhattacharya and Subroto Mukerjee and Tanayveer Singh Bhatia and Jagannath Sutradhar},
  title = {{Significantly Super-Chandrasekhar Limiting Mass White Dwarfs and their Consequences}},
  booktitle = {ePrints-IISc},
  year = {2017},
}
Figure