Signal Recovery on Graphs: Random versus Experimentally Designed Sampling

Siheng Chen, Rohan Varma, Aarti Singh, Jelena KovacevicarXiv 2015 · OpenReview

Abstract

We study signal recovery on graphs based on two sampling strategies: random sampling and experimentally designed sampling. We propose a new class of smooth graph signals, called approximately bandlimited, which generalizes the bandlimited class and is similar to the globally smooth class. We then propose two recovery strategies based on random sampling and experimentally designed sampling. The proposed recovery strategy based on experimentally designed sampling is similar to the leverage scores used in the matrix approximation. We show that while both strategies are unbiased estimators for the low-frequency components, the convergence rate of experimentally designed sampling is much faster than that of random sampling when a graph is irregular. We validate the proposed recovery strategies on three specific graphs: a ring graph, an Erdős-Rényi graph, and a star graph. The simulation results support the theoretical analysis.

Introduction

In classical signal processing, sampling theorems dictate how to reconstruct continuous signals from discrete measurements. However, modern data often resides on complex networks or graphs, such as sensor networks, social media, or biological systems. Graph Signal Processing (GSP) seeks to extend these classical concepts to irregular domains. This paper addresses two fundamental challenges in GSP: developing a realistic signal model that accounts for high-frequency noise and determining optimal sampling strategies to minimize reconstruction error.

Signal Modeling: Approximately Bandlimited Signals

Most existing GSP theories assume "bandlimited" signals, where energy is strictly confined to low-frequency graph Laplacian eigenvectors. Real-world data is rarely this clean, often containing a "tail" of high-frequency components. To address this, we introduce approximately bandlimited (ABLA) signals. Unlike strictly bandlimited models, ABLA signals allow for energy in high-frequency components, provided that energy decays at a specific rate ($\beta$). This framework provides a more robust and applicable model for real-world graph data.

Sampling and Recovery Strategies

We compare two distinct approaches for selecting a subset of nodes for measurement:

  1. Random Sampling (Algorithm 1): Nodes are selected uniformly at random. This method is computationally inexpensive as it does not require an analysis of the graph's underlying structure.
  2. Experimentally Designed Sampling (Algorithm 2): Nodes are selected based on sampling scores derived from the graph's eigenvectors. This is analogous to "leverage scores" used in matrix approximation, identifying nodes that are most influential or informative regarding the signal's low-frequency structure.

Both strategies are proven to be unbiased estimators for the low-frequency components of the signal, but their performance varies significantly depending on the graph's topology.

Experimental Evaluation

We evaluated the algorithms using three synthetic graph models (10,000 nodes each) representing different structural archetypes: a regular Ring graph, a random Erdős-Rényi graph, and a highly irregular Star graph.

MSE performance across Ring, Erdős-Rényi, and Star graphs.

The results, illustrated above, highlight a critical bias-variance tradeoff. In regular graphs (Type-1), such as the Ring and Erdős-Rényi models, signal energy is spread evenly across nodes. Consequently, random sampling performs nearly as well as the designed strategy. However, in irregular graphs (Type-2) like the Star graph, energy is concentrated in specific nodes (e.g., the central hub). In these cases, the designed sampling strategy significantly outperforms random sampling, reaching the theoretical error floor with far fewer samples.

Conclusion

Our findings demonstrate that while random sampling is sufficient for regular graphs, structure-aware sampling is essential for efficient signal recovery on irregular networks. By using sampling scores to "over-sample" informative nodes and re-weighting their contributions, we can achieve much faster convergence and more stable recovery. Future work will explore the computational challenges of scaling these eigenvector-based methods to massive, billion-node graphs.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study signal recovery on graphs based on two sampling strategies: random sampling and experimentally designed sampling. We propose a new class of smooth graph signals, called approximately bandlimited, which generalizes the bandlimited class and is similar to the globally smooth class. We then propose two recovery strategies based on random sampling and experimentally designed sampling. The proposed recovery strategy based on experimentally designed sampling is similar to the leverage scores used in the matrix approximation. We show that while both strategies are unbiased estimators for the low-frequency components, the convergence rate of experimentally designed sampling is much faster than that of random sampling when a graph is irregular. We validate the proposed recovery strategies on three specific graphs: a ring graph, an Erd\H{o}s-R\'enyi graph, and a star graph. The simulation results support the theoretical analysis.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2015signal,
  author = {Siheng Chen and Rohan Varma and Aarti Singh and Jelena Kovacevic},
  title = {{Signal Recovery on Graphs: Random versus Experimentally Designed Sampling}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1504.05427},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1504.05427},
}
Figure