Sigma term and strangeness content of the nucleon

Stephan Dürr, Gergely Endrődi, Julien Frison, Thomas R. Hemmert, Christian Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, Stefan Krieg, Thorsten Kurth, Laurent Lellouch, Thomas Lippert, Antonin Portelli, Alberto Ramos, Andreas Schäfer, Kálman SzabóProceedings of The XXVIII International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory — PoS(Lattice 2010) 2011 · DOI

Abstract

A status report is given for a joint project of the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal collaboration and the Regensburg group to study the quark mass-dependence of octet baryons in SU(3) Baryon XPT. This formulation is expected to extend to larger masses than Heavy-Baryon XPT. Its applicability is tested with 2+1 flavor data which cover three lattice spacings and pion masses down to about 190 MeV, in large volumes. Also polynomial and rational interpolations in $M_\pi^2$ and $M_K^2$ are used to assess the uncertainty due to the ansatz. Both frameworks are combined to explore the precision to be expected in a controlled determination of the nucleon sigma term and strangeness content.

Introduction

In the Standard Model, the mass of a nucleon is not merely the sum of its constituent quark masses; the majority arises from gluon energy and quark kinetic energy. Two fundamental properties characterizing the scalar interaction of quarks within the nucleon are the pion-nucleon sigma term ($\sigma_{\pi N}$) and the strangeness content ($y_N$). These quantities represent the contribution of light (up/down) and strange quarks, respectively, to the nucleon mass.

Direct experimental measurement of these terms is impossible as quark masses cannot be tuned in a laboratory. Traditionally, physicists have relied on indirect methods like pion-nucleon scattering, which are subject to significant uncertainties. This report details a first-principles calculation using Lattice QCD, leveraging the ability to simulate different quark mass regimes to observe the nucleon's mass response.

Datasets and Simulation Landscape

The study utilizes the "6 stout" (or "6 EXP") dataset from the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) collaboration. The simulations involve $N_f = 2+1$ flavors (two degenerate light quarks and one strange quark) across three lattice spacings ($a \approx 0.065, 0.083,$ and $0.124$ fm) to mitigate discretization errors. Pion masses range from $670$ MeV down to a near-physical $190$ MeV.

Distribution of the 2+1 flavor lattice data points in the quark mass plane, showing the coverage across different pion masses.

Large volumes ($M_\pi L \geq 4$) are maintained to minimize finite-volume effects. The distribution of these data points allows for a robust exploration of the mass-dependence of the baryon octet.

Methodology

The primary strategies for extracting the sigma term and strangeness content include:

  1. Hellmann-Feynman Theorem: The team calculates the derivative of the nucleon mass ($M_N$) with respect to the quark masses ($m_q$). According to the theorem, $\sigma_{\pi N} = m_{ud} \frac{\partial M_N}{\partial m_{ud}}$ and the strangeness content is related to $\frac{\partial M_N}{\partial m_s}$. This approach avoids the noise associated with direct calculation of disconnected quark loops.
  2. Covariant Baryon Chiral Perturbation Theory (CBXPT): To extrapolate lattice data to the physical point, the authors use CBXPT. This covariant approach handles relativistic effects better than the standard Heavy-Baryon (HBXPT) version, allowing for reliable fits even at higher pion masses (up to $\sim 400$ MeV).
  3. Analytic Interpolations: Polynomial and rational functions are used as alternative fitting models to quantify systematic uncertainties stemming from the choice of the chiral ansatz.

Results and Discussion

The analysis highlights that the nucleon mass is significantly more sensitive to light quark masses than to the strange quark mass. This sensitivity is reflected in the slopes of the chiral fits.

CBXPT fits to the octet baryon masses ($M_{N, \Lambda, \Sigma, \Xi}$) as a function of $M_\pi^2$ (top) and the strange quark mass proxy $2M_K^2 - M_\pi^2$ (bottom).

The fits consistently yield a pion-nucleon sigma term in the low fifties: $$\sigma_{\pi N} \simeq 50(10)_{stat}(10)_{sys} \text{ MeV}$$

For the strangeness content, the ratio $y_N$ was determined to be: $$y_N \simeq 0.1(2)_{stat}(1)_{sys}$$ Given that the uncertainties exceed the central value, the result is statistically consistent with zero, indicating a very small contribution from strange quarks to the nucleon mass.

Conclusion

While the pion-nucleon sigma term is determined with reasonable precision, the strangeness content remains elusive. The current dataset's strange quark masses are slightly above the physical value, making the slope determination difficult. Future work will focus on including simulations with smaller strange quark masses to better resolve the curvature of the mass-dependence and performing a comprehensive systematic error analysis using bootstrap methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

A status report is given for a joint project of the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal collaboration and the Regensburg group to study the quark mass-dependence of octet baryons in SU(3) Baryon XPT.This formulation is expected to extend to larger masses than Heavy-Baryon XPT.Its applicability is tested with 2+1 flavor data which cover three lattice spacings and pion masses down to about 190 MeV, in large volumes.Also polynomial and rational interpolations in M 2 π and M 2 K are used to assess the uncertainty due to the ansatz.Both frameworks are combined to explore the precision to be expected in a controlled determination of the nucleon sigma term and strangeness content.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{durr2011sigma,
  author = {Stephan Dürr and Gergely Endrődi and Julien Frison and Thomas R. Hemmert and Christian Hoelbling and S. D. Katz and Stefan Krieg and Thorsten Kurth and Laurent Lellouch and Thomas Lippert and Antonin Portelli and Alberto Ramos and Andreas Schäfer and Kálman Szabó},
  title = {{Sigma term and strangeness content of the nucleon}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of The XXVIII International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory — PoS(Lattice 2010)},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.22323/1.105.0102},
}
Figure