Shorts vs. Regular Videos on YouTube: A Comparative Analysis of User Engagement and Content Creation Trends

Caroline Violot, Tugrulcan Elmas, Igor Bilogrevic, Mathias Humbert

Introduction

Since the meteoric rise of TikTok, the social media landscape has undergone a seismic shift toward vertical, short-form video. In 2021, YouTube responded to this trend by introducing "Shorts." While the presence of these videos is now ubiquitous, their long-term impact on the platform's culture and content distribution remained largely unexamined. This paper, presented at the 2024 ACM Web Science Conference, provides the first large-scale longitudinal analysis of how Shorts have fundamentally altered the YouTube ecosystem. By analyzing millions of videos, researchers explored whether short-form content is cannibalizing traditional long-form videos and how user engagement patterns differ between the two formats.

Methodology: Overcoming Technical Hurdles

A significant challenge in studying YouTube Shorts is that the official YouTube Data API does not explicitly label videos as "Shorts." To address this, the researchers developed a novel URL redirection heuristic. They discovered that requesting a video via the youtube.com/shorts/<videoId> endpoint would either maintain that URL (confirming it as a Short) or redirect to a standard /watch?v= URL (identifying it as a Regular Video, or RV).

Using a "seed-and-grow" approach, the team identified approximately 70,000 channels that had posted at least one Short, starting from a base of 50 popular TikTok-related keywords. They then scraped metadata for every video posted by these channels between January 2021 and December 2022, resulting in a massive dataset of 16.7 million videos (9.9 million Shorts and 6.8 million RVs).

The Thematic Divide: Entertainment vs. Information

The study reveals a clear "thematic divide" in how creators utilize different formats. Shorts have rapidly become the dominant medium for entertainment-focused categories. In the "Comedy" category, for instance, 76.5% of all uploads were Shorts. Conversely, information-dense categories like "News & Politics" and "Education" remain the stronghold of regular videos, where Shorts account for only 14.4% of content.

This suggests that while Shorts are highly effective for "snackable" entertainment, users and creators still rely on long-form video for depth, nuance, and complex information. Furthermore, the data shows a "New Creator Bias": channels established after the launch of Shorts are significantly more likely to focus exclusively on short-form content, viewing YouTube primarily as a short-form platform.

The Engagement Paradox

One of the most striking findings is the disparity in engagement metrics. Shorts appear to be an engine for massive reach; on average, a Short receives 110 times more views than a regular video from the same channel. By the end of 2022, Shorts were generating up to six times more views than RVs across the platform.

However, this reach comes with a trade-off in the quality of engagement:

  • Passive Engagement: Shorts excel at capturing likes and views, driven by the platform's algorithmic scroll.
  • Active Engagement: Regular videos maintain a higher rate of comments per view. This indicates that while Shorts drive "passive" consumption, RVs are more effective at fostering community discussion and deep engagement.

Interestingly, while the mean view count for Shorts is high due to viral outliers, the median number of views for mid-length RVs (10–30 minutes) is actually higher than the median for Shorts. This suggests that while Shorts offer a higher ceiling for virality, well-made traditional videos provide a more reliable "floor" for reaching a guaranteed audience.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The introduction of Shorts has successfully allowed YouTube to compete in the short-form market, but it has also initiated a shift in creator labor. Older channels are progressively reducing their production of regular videos in favor of Shorts to "game" the algorithm for reach.

While this study provides a comprehensive overview of the current shift, the authors note a selection bias toward "trendy" content due to their initial keyword seeding. Future research will likely focus on the quality of discourse within the comments of both formats and the long-term economic impact of different monetization models for Shorts versus traditional videos. For now, YouTube remains a platform in transition, balancing its legacy of deep, long-form content with the high-velocity demands of the short-form era.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{violot2024shorts,
  author = {Caroline Violot and Tugrulcan Elmas and Igor Bilogrevic and Mathias Humbert},
  title = {{Shorts vs. Regular Videos on YouTube: A Comparative Analysis of User Engagement and Content Creation Trends}},
  booktitle = {WebSci},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1145/3614419.3644023},
}
Figure