"Sharing, Not Showing Off": How BeReal Approaches Authentic Self-Presentation on Social Media Through Its Design

Jaewon Kim, Robert Wolfe, Ishita Chordia, Katie Davis, Alexis Hiniker

TL;DR

This paper investigates how BeReal's design features encourage authentic self-presentation among adolescents, finding that its emphasis on spontaneity and limited features successfully nudges users towards more genuine sharing. However, the study also highlights limitations, suggesting a need for platforms that support a broader range of authentic self-expression beyond just unfiltered photos.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the growing challenge of fostering authentic self-presentation and genuine relationship-building on social media, particularly for adolescents. Existing platforms often encourage curated, performative self-presentation, leading to heightened self-consciousness, social comparison, and anxiety. This can hinder the development of meaningful connections, which are crucial for adolescent well-being. The authors explore BeReal as a case study, a platform designed to counter these pressures by promoting spontaneous and unfiltered sharing.

Methods

The researchers conducted a qualitative study using semi-structured interviews with 29 BeReal users aged 13-18. They employed a reflexive thematic analysis to understand participants' general experiences, motivations, and perceptions of BeReal's features and their impact on self-presentation and authenticity. The analysis involved multiple coding phases and affinity diagramming to identify overarching themes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BeReal's design actively discourages staged posts: Features like random daily notifications, a strict two-minute posting window, and a visible retake counter all push users towards spontaneous, uncurated content.
  • Reduced pressure to perform: The ephemeral nature of posts and the absence of "likes" or follower counts alleviate the pressure to present a perfect, idealized self, making sharing feel more low-stakes.
  • Audience curation is key: BeReal encourages users to connect with "real friends," fostering a sense of a smaller, more intimate online space that feels more "friendly," "cozy," and "communal."
  • Simplicity drives authenticity: The minimalist design and single purpose of BeReal (authentic photo sharing) make its mission clear and differentiate it from more feature-rich platforms like Instagram.
  • Authenticity can be a double-edged sword: While BeReal promotes genuine sharing, it can also lead to pressure to be "real" even when uncomfortable, and can foster new forms of judgment and toxicity around who is "truly" authentic.
  • Limitations in depth of expression: Participants expressed a desire to share more than just unfiltered photos, indicating that BeReal's focus on a single facet of self-disclosure might be limiting for deeper relationship building.

Key Results

  • Participants reported that BeReal's features effectively encouraged them to share frequently and "authentically" (i.e., post unfiltered, unstaged photos).
  • The platform was perceived as a "judgment-free" and "safe, close space" by many users due to its curated audience and lack of performance metrics.
  • BeReal was seen as a positive departure from other social media platforms, reducing toxicity and social comparison for many.
  • However, some participants felt pressured to post even when they didn't want to, and some experienced new forms of toxicity related to judging others' authenticity or content as "boring."
  • A significant finding was the desire for platforms that allow for more nuanced self-disclosure beyond just photos, suggesting a need for richer forms of authentic expression.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations: the participant sample was predominantly female, and BeReal has introduced new features since data collection (e.g., Spotify integration, bonus BeReals, branded accounts, groups) that may have altered user perceptions. Future work should explore these new features and their impact on authentic self-presentation and privacy. The authors also suggest future research should explore novel designs that cultivate different modes of sharing beyond single-form photo sharing, supporting more comprehensive authentic sharing integral to adolescent relationship-building. They propose design recommendations for platforms to support "accurate" self-presentation, provide "air cover" for audience management, scaffold reciprocal sharing, and prevent "weaponized authenticity."

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kim2024sharing,
  author = {Jaewon Kim and Robert Wolfe and Ishita Chordia and Katie Davis and Alexis Hiniker},
  title = {{"Sharing, Not Showing Off": How BeReal Approaches Authentic Self-Presentation on Social Media Through Its Design}},
  journal = {Proc. ACM Hum. Comput. Interact.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1145/3686909},
}

Loading related content...

Figure