Shared Information for a Markov Chain on a Tree

Sagnik Bhattacharya, Prakash Narayan

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new, simpler proof for characterizing "shared information," a measure of mutual dependence among multiple random variables, specifically for Markov chains on trees. They also develop an efficient algorithm for estimating this shared information when the underlying probability distribution is unknown, which is crucial for applications like distributed data analysis and secure communication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Shared information (SI) is a powerful tool for quantifying how much multiple random variables "know" about each other. It has operational meanings in areas like secret key generation and distributed data analysis. However, calculating SI, especially for complex dependencies, is challenging. While SI for a simple Markov chain (a line of variables) is well-understood, extending this to more general tree-like structures (Markov chains on trees, or MCTs) has been an active research area. Existing characterizations of SI for MCTs often rely on complex proofs or specific interpretations (like secret key capacity). Furthermore, in many real-world scenarios, the exact probability distribution governing these variables is unknown, necessitating robust estimation methods. This paper aims to provide a more accessible characterization of SI for MCTs and develop a practical algorithm for its estimation.

Methods

The authors present a novel proof for the explicit characterization of shared information for Markov chains on trees. Their approach leverages the global Markov property of trees, which relates to how information is separated by graph cuts, and a concept called agglomeration, where connected subsets of nodes in the tree are treated as single units. This allows them to simplify the problem by reducing it to simpler cases.

For the estimation part, they frame the problem as a correlated bandits problem. This is a scenario where an agent (the algorithm) needs to identify the "best" option (the edge with minimal mutual information) by repeatedly "pulling arms" (sampling pairs of connected random variables). They propose a uniform sampling strategy and analyze its performance, focusing on bounding the probability of error in identifying the correct edge. Their analysis accounts for estimator bias, a refinement over simpler bandit algorithms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical characterizations and algorithmic development rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Global Markov Property is Key: The paper demonstrates that the global Markov property of trees is fundamental to simplifying the characterization of shared information. This property, based on graph separation, provides a powerful structural insight.
  • Agglomeration Simplifies Complexity: The concept of "agglomerating" connected nodes in the tree into single units proves instrumental in reducing the complexity of the problem, allowing for inductive proofs and simpler characterizations.
  • Bandits for Information Estimation: Framing the estimation of minimal mutual information (which equals SI for MCTs) as a correlated bandits problem offers a practical algorithmic approach for scenarios where the underlying distribution is unknown.
  • Bias Matters in Estimation: The authors highlight the importance of accounting for estimator bias in their bandit algorithm analysis, leading to more accurate bounds on error probability.
  • Tree Structure Enables Simpler SI: The inherent structure of a Markov chain on a tree allows for a significantly simpler characterization of shared information compared to more general graphical models.

Key Results

  • New Proof for SI Characterization: The paper provides a new, direct proof for the explicit characterization of shared information for Markov chains on trees, SI(X<sub>M</sub>) = min<sub>(i,j)∈E</sub> I(X<sub>i</sub> ∧ X<sub>j</sub>), where the minimum is taken over all edges in the tree. This means SI is simply the minimum mutual information between adjacent variables in the tree.
  • Equivalence of Markov Properties: They prove that for MCTs, the global Markov property is equivalent to the local Markov property, even when the joint probability distribution is not strictly positive.
  • Bandit Algorithm for Estimation: A uniform sampling bandit algorithm is proposed to estimate SI. The analysis provides bounds on the probability of misidentifying the edge with the minimal mutual information.
  • Sample Complexity Bounds: The paper derives bounds on the sample complexity required for the estimation algorithm to achieve a desired level of accuracy with high probability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uniform Sampling: The proposed bandit algorithm uses uniform sampling for simplicity. The authors suggest that more refined bandit algorithms could potentially improve sample complexity.
  • Bias-Correction Tradeoffs: While bias-corrected estimators for mutual information exist, their impact on the bounded differences inequality and overall sample complexity needs further investigation.
  • General Graphical Models: The current work is specific to trees. Extending the characterization and estimation techniques to more general graphical models remains an open challenge.
  • Optimality of Decay Rate: The paper poses the question of whether the derived exponential decay rate in the probability of error is optimal, which requires further theoretical analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Shared information is a measure of mutual dependence among multiple jointly distributed random variables with finite alphabets. For a Markov chain on a tree with a given joint distribution, we give a new proof of an explicit characterization of shared information. The Markov chain on a tree is shown to possess a global Markov property based on graph separation; this property plays a key role in our proofs. When the underlying joint distribution is not known, we exploit the special form of this characterization to provide a multiarmed bandit algorithm for estimating shared information, and analyze its error performance.
BibTeX
@article{bhattacharya2024shared,
  author = {Sagnik Bhattacharya and Prakash Narayan},
  title = {{Shared Information for a Markov Chain on a Tree}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Information Theory},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tit.2024.3353769},
}

Loading related content...

Figure