Shape and connectivity of groups and clusters: Impact of dynamical state and accretion history

Euclid Collaboration, Tony Bonnaire, N. AghanimarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Matter distribution around clusters is highly anisotropic from their being the nodes of the cosmic web. Clusters' shape and the number of filaments they are connected to, i.e., their connectivity, should reflect their level of anisotropic matter distribution and must be, in principle, related to their physical properties. We investigate the influence of the dynamical state and the formation history on both the morphology and local connectivity of about 2400 groups and clusters of galaxies from the large hydrodynamical simulation IllustrisTNG at z=0. We find that the mass of groups and clusters mainly influences the geometry of the matter distribution: massive halos are significantly more elliptical, and more connected to the cosmic web than low-mass ones. Beyond the mass-driven effect, ellipticity and connectivity are correlated and are imprints of the growth rate of groups and clusters. Both anisotropy measures appear to trace different dynamical states, such that unrelaxed groups and clusters are more elliptical and more connected than relaxed ones. This relation between matter anisotropies and dynamical state is the sign of different accretion histories. Relaxed groups and clusters are mostly formed long time ago, and slowly accreting matter at the present time. They are rather spherical and weakly connected to their environment, mostly because they had enough time to relax and, hence, lost the connection with their preferential directions of accretion and merging. In contrast, late-formed unrelaxed objects are highly anisotropic with large connectivities and ellipticities. These groups and clusters are in formation phase and must be strongly affected by the infalling of materials from filaments.

Introduction

In the standard cosmological model, galaxy clusters are the "hubs" of the cosmic web—massive nodes where vast filaments of dark matter and gas intersect. While these structures are often simplified as spherical blobs for mass estimations, they are inherently anisotropic. This study explores the drivers behind cluster morphology, specifically investigating whether a cluster's shape and its connectivity to the cosmic web are merely functions of its mass or if they provide a deeper signature of its dynamical state and accretion history.

Understanding these relationships is critical for precision cosmology. Departures from sphericity can introduce significant biases in cluster mass measurements, which are essential for constraining fundamental parameters of the universe. By linking a cluster's geometry to its life story, researchers can better interpret observational data from upcoming large-scale surveys.

Methodology

The research utilizes a multi-pronged analysis of the IllustrisTNG (TNG300-1) hydrodynamical simulation at redshift $z=0$. The sample consists of 2,419 galaxy groups and clusters with masses $M_{200} \ge 10^{13} M_\odot/h$.

To quantify the anisotropy and state of these clusters, the team employed several key metrics:

  • Ellipticity ($\epsilon$): Derived from the diagonalization of the mass tensor of all particles within the cluster, measuring the deviation from a perfect sphere.
  • Connectivity ($\kappa$): Calculated using the T-ReX algorithm to identify the skeleton of the cosmic web. It represents the number of filaments branching out from a cluster node.
  • Dynamical State ($\chi_{DS}$): A composite metric accounting for the center-of-mass offset, the fraction of mass in sub-structures, and the virial ratio (kinetic vs. potential energy balance).
  • Accretion History: Reconstructed via merger trees to determine formation redshifts and current growth rates.

Key Results and Discussion

The Role of Mass

Mass is identified as the primary driver of cluster geometry. As shown in Figure 1, there is a clear shift toward higher ellipticity as cluster mass increases. Massive halos are not only more elongated but also more strongly connected to the cosmic web, typically residing at more complex intersections of the cosmic skeleton.

The cumulative distribution function (CDF) of ellipticity ($\epsilon$) for different mass bins, showing that more massive clusters tend to be more elliptical.

Dynamical State and Accretion History

Beyond mass, the dynamical state of a cluster significantly influences its shape. The study finds a strong correlation between ellipticity and the relaxedness parameter ($\chi_{DS}$). Unrelaxed clusters—those currently undergoing mergers or rapid growth—are consistently more elliptical and better connected than their relaxed counterparts.

This phenomenon is described as the "memory loss" of relaxed clusters. As a cluster ages and its accretion rate slows, it gradually relaxes into a more spherical configuration. In doing so, it loses the structural memory of the specific filaments from which it originally gathered its mass. Conversely, late-formed, unrelaxed objects remain highly anisotropic, reflecting the ongoing infalling of material from multiple directions.

Visual examples of four clusters from the simulation, illustrating the diversity in connectivity ($\kappa$), ellipticity ($\epsilon$), and relaxedness across different mass scales.

Connectivity as a Growth Proxy

The number of connected filaments ($\kappa$) serves as a proxy for the current accretion rate. A higher connectivity indicates more "highways" for matter to enter the cluster, maintaining it in a disturbed, unrelaxed state. The authors identified three distinct evolutionary populations: old and relaxed (spherical, low connectivity), early-formed but unrelaxed (undergoing late mergers), and late-formed unrelaxed (highly elliptical, high connectivity, fast growth).

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that the shape and connectivity of galaxy clusters are direct imprints of their formation history. While mass sets the baseline, the current dynamical state and accretion rate determine the degree of anisotropy. Future missions like Euclid and the Dark Energy Survey will be vital for validating these simulation-based findings with large-scale observational samples, helping to refine our understanding of the cosmic web's most massive nodes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Matter distribution around clusters is highly anisotropic from their being the nodes of the cosmic web. Clusters' shape and the number of filaments they are connected to, i.e., their connectivity, should reflect their level of anisotropic matter distribution and must be, in principle, related to their physical properties. We investigate the influence of the dynamical state and the formation history on both the morphology and local connectivity of about 2400 groups and clusters of galaxies from the large hydrodynamical simulation IllustrisTNG at z=0. We find that the mass of groups and clusters mainly influences the geometry of the matter distribution: massive halos are significantly more elliptical, and more connected to the cosmic web than low-mass ones. Beyond the mass-driven effect, ellipticity and connectivity are correlated and are imprints of the growth rate of groups and clusters. Both anisotropy measures appear to trace different dynamical states, such that unrelaxed groups and clusters are more elliptical and more connected than relaxed ones. This relation between matter anisotropies and dynamical state is the sign of different accretion histories. Relaxed groups and clusters are mostly formed long time ago, and slowly accreting matter at the present time. They are rather spherical and weakly connected to their environment, mostly because they had enough time to relax and, hence, lost the connection with their preferential directions of accretion and merging. In contrast, late-formed unrelaxed objects are highly anisotropic with large connectivities and ellipticities. These groups and clusters are in formation phase and must be strongly affected by the infalling of materials from filaments.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2021shape,
  author = {Euclid Collaboration and Tony Bonnaire and N. Aghanim},
  title = {{Shape and connectivity of groups and clusters: Impact of dynamical state and accretion history}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2101.04686},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2101.04686},
}

Loading related content...

Figure