Sex differences in viral entry protein expression and host transcript responses to SARS-CoV-2

Mengying Sun, Rama Shankar, Meehyun Ko, Christopher Daniel Chang, Shan‐Ju Yeh, Shilong Li, Ke Liu, Guoli Zhou, Jing Xing, Austin VanVelsen, Tyler VanVelsen, Shreya Paithankar, Benjamin Y. Feng, Krista Young, Michael Strug, Lauren Turco, Zichen Wang, Eric E. Schadt, Rong Chen, Xiaohong Li, Tomiko Oskotsky, Marina Sirota, Benjamin S. Glicksberg, Girish N. Nadkarni, Adam J. Moeser, Seungtaek Kim, Jiayu Zhou, Bin ChenResearch 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the biological underpinnings of higher COVID-19 mortality in men by analyzing large-scale gene expression data and clinical records. It reveals that men generally exhibit higher expression of viral entry proteins ACE2 and TMPRSS2, particularly in the kidney and in older individuals, and that male COVID-19 patients show signs of impaired kidney function, suggesting the kidney may play a significant role in sex-based COVID-19 disparities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite consistent epidemiological observations of higher COVID-19 mortality rates in men compared to women, the underlying biological mechanisms remain largely unknown. This gap in understanding hinders the development of targeted interventions and a comprehensive understanding of disease pathogenesis. The authors aim to bridge this gap by exploring sex differences in the expression of key viral entry proteins (ACE2 and TMPRSS2) and the host's transcriptional responses to SARS-CoV-2 infection.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Large-scale Gene Expression Analysis: They compiled and analyzed a massive dataset of 220,835 human gene expression profiles from three public databases (Treehouse, ARCHS4, and GEO). To handle missing metadata (sex, age, tissue), they utilized machine learning models (deep multi-task neural networks and XGBoost) for imputation, achieving high prediction accuracy.
  • Clinical Data Analysis: They analyzed electronic medical records of 6,031 COVID-19 patients from Mount Sinai Health System, focusing on serum creatinine levels as an indicator of kidney function.
  • Host Transcriptional Response Analysis: They analyzed RNA-Seq data from 782 COVID-19 patients across different sample types (upper airway, blood PBMC, blood leukocytes) to identify sex-specific gene expression changes.
  • Cell Type Enrichment Analysis: Using XCell, they inferred the enrichment of various cell types in COVID-19 patient blood samples to identify potential sex-specific cellular differences.
  • Statistical Modeling: Logistic regression and Wilcoxon rank-sum tests were used to assess differences in gene expression and cell type enrichment between sexes and across different conditions.

Datasets

The study utilized three large public gene expression datasets:

  • Treehouse: 17,654 RNA-Seq samples.
  • ARCHS4: 60,936 RNA-Seq samples.
  • GEO (GPL570): 145,947 microarray samples.

These datasets were combined into a "Merged dataset" of 220,835 samples. Additionally, a "Healthy dataset" of 8,066 samples from the Treehouse project was used for specific analyses. Clinical data from 6,031 COVID-19 patients at Mount Sinai Health System was also analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Kidney as a Potential Key Organ: The consistent finding of sex differences in ACE2 and TMPRSS2 expression, particularly in the kidney, coupled with clinical evidence of impaired kidney function in male COVID-19 patients, strongly suggests the kidney plays a crucial role in sex disparities in COVID-19.
  • Age-Dependent Sex Differences: Sex differences in viral entry protein expression are more pronounced in older individuals (>60 years), hinting at age-related vulnerabilities.
  • Distinct Host Responses: Beyond immune responses, men and women exhibit distinct non-immune transcriptional responses to SARS-CoV-2 infection, involving pathways like mitochondrial function and cholesterol biosynthesis.
  • Mesangial Cells in Male COVID-19 Blood: The enrichment of kidney-specific mesangial cells in the blood of male COVID-19 patients is a novel finding that further implicates kidney involvement.

Key Results

  • Male samples showed higher expression levels of ACE2 and TMPRSS2 than female samples, especially in the older age group (>60 years) and in kidney tissue.
  • Male COVID-19 patients had significantly higher serum creatinine levels, indicating impaired kidney function, compared to female patients.
  • Analysis of 782 COVID-19 patient gene expression profiles revealed distinct transcriptional responses between men and women in the upper airway and blood.
  • Computational deconvolution identified enriched kidney-specific mesangial cells in the blood of male COVID-19 patients compared to healthy individuals.
  • In the kidney, ACE2 expression showed a significant sex difference, with higher expression in males (OR: 1.45 [1.26-1.67]).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Batch Effects and Confounding Factors: The authors acknowledge that batch effects between studies, variations among datasets, and other unknown confounding factors may exist in the quantitative analysis of ACE2 differences. While efforts were made to mitigate these, they may not be fully addressed.
  • dACE2 Isoform: The potential confounding effect of a non-functional ACE2 isoform (dACE2), which can be upregulated in response to inflammation and viral infections, was noted.
  • Disease State Annotation: The annotation of disease states for all samples was complex and potentially incomplete due to the urgency of the project.
  • Cell Type Quantification: While XCell was used for cell type enrichment, single-cell technologies could provide more precise quantification of cell fractions.
  • Heterogeneous Cell Composition: Differentially expressed genes in bulk samples might reflect differences in cell types rather than within infected cells.

Future work could involve further investigating the role of the kidney in sex differences in COVID-19, exploring the clinical implications of these findings, and assessing the efficacy of steroid sex hormones based on real-world evidence. The authors also suggest that accumulating more COVID-19 patient clinical data will be valuable for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Epidemiological studies suggest that men exhibit a higher mortality rate to COVID-19 than women, yet the underlying biology is largely unknown. Here, we seek to delineate sex differences in the gene expression of viral entry proteins ACE2 and TMPRSS2, and host transcriptional responses to SARS-CoV-2 through large-scale analysis of genomic and clinical data. We first compiled 220,000 human gene expression profiles from three databases and completed the meta-information through machine learning and manual annotation. Large scale analysis of these profiles indicated that male samples show higher expression levels of ACE2 and TMPRSS2 than female samples, especially in the older group (>60 years) and in the kidney. Subsequent analysis of 6,031 COVID-19 patients at Mount Sinai Health System revealed that men have significantly higher creatinine levels, an indicator of impaired kidney function. Further analysis of 782 COVID-19 patient gene expression profiles taken from upper airway and blood suggested men and women present distinct expression changes. Computational deconvolution analysis of these profiles revealed male COVID-19 patients have enriched kidney-specific mesangial cells in blood compared to healthy patients. Together, this study suggests biological differences in the kidney between sexes may contribute to sex disparity in COVID-19.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2020sex,
  author = {Mengying Sun and Rama Shankar and Meehyun Ko and Christopher Daniel Chang and Shan‐Ju Yeh and Shilong Li and Ke Liu and Guoli Zhou and Jing Xing and Austin VanVelsen and Tyler VanVelsen and Shreya Paithankar and Benjamin Y. Feng and Krista Young and Michael Strug and Lauren Turco and Zichen Wang and Eric E. Schadt and Rong Chen and Xiaohong Li and Tomiko Oskotsky and Marina Sirota and Benjamin S. Glicksberg and Girish N. Nadkarni and Adam J. Moeser and Li Li and Seungtaek Kim and Jiayu Zhou and Bin Chen},
  title = {{Sex differences in viral entry protein expression and host transcript responses to SARS-CoV-2}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-100914/v2},
}
Figure