Sex differences in craniofacial parameters of children and adolescents: a comparative study with the maturation of cervical vertebrae using a cephalometric method

Tao Gu, Shiyong Zhang, Chuqiao Xiao, Shoushan Hu, Xin XiongJournal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals significant sex differences in craniofacial development in children and adolescents, with males generally exhibiting larger linear measurements while females mature skeletally earlier. These findings highlight the importance of considering sex-specific reference standards for orthodontic treatment planning and diagnosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding craniofacial growth and development is crucial for diagnosing and treating various conditions, particularly in orthodontics. While sex differences in adult craniofacial morphology are well-documented, there's a need for updated and detailed research on these differences in children and adolescents, a group with high orthodontic demands. This study aims to fill this gap by comprehensively analyzing sex-based variations in craniofacial parameters and their relationship with skeletal maturation, using a novel quantitative method.

Methods

The researchers employed a cephalometric method to analyze lateral cephalograms from 340 subjects (141 males, 199 females) aged 6 to 18 years. A key aspect of their methodology was the use of the quantitative cervical vertebral maturity (QCVM) method to assess skeletal maturation. This method, described as a simple, reliable, and objective alternative to traditional hand-wrist radiographs, involves analyzing specific landmarks on the cervical vertebrae. They performed age-stratified analyses and also compared sexes within a specific QCVM stage (QCVM III) to control for skeletal maturity. Statistical analyses included independent samples t-tests, Mann-Whitney U tests, Chi-squared tests, and multivariate linear regression analysis adjusted for age.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 340 lateral cephalograms collected from patients visiting the orthodontic department of the West China Hospital of Stomatology between January and August 2022. These cephalograms were analyzed using Uceph software. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Males are bigger, females mature faster: The most striking finding is the consistent pattern of males having larger linear craniofacial dimensions (e.g., ramus height, anterior and posterior facial heights) compared to females, even when controlling for skeletal maturity. Conversely, females tend to reach advanced stages of cervical vertebral maturation earlier than males.
  • Age matters for sex differences: Sex differences in craniofacial parameters become more pronounced with age. While younger children (<12 years) show fewer significant differences, adolescents (≥12 years) exhibit a greater number of sex-distinct parameters.
  • QCVM is a valuable tool: The QCVM method proved effective in stratifying subjects by skeletal maturity, allowing for a more nuanced comparison of sex differences at similar developmental stages. This is crucial because growth spurts and hormonal influences can significantly impact craniofacial development.
  • Clinical implications are significant: The study strongly advocates for the integration of sex-specific reference standards in cephalometric measurements and treatment planning. Ignoring these differences could lead to suboptimal orthodontic outcomes.

Key Results

  • Overall: 17 out of 38 craniofacial parameters showed significant sex differences. Males had larger linear measurements, while facial convexity was the only angular soft tissue measurement that was lower in males.
  • Age Subgroups:
    • <12 years old: 6 significant sex differences, primarily in linear parameters (e.g., anterior facial height, lower anterior facial height, lower lip protrusion, lower lip thickness, N'-Sn, Sn-Me').
  • ≥12 years old: 19 significant sex differences, including additional parameters like mandibular body length and AFH/PFH.
  • QCVM III Patients: 12 cephalometric parameters showed significant sex differences.
  • Age-Adjusted Analysis: After adjusting for age, 3 angular parameters (facial convexity, soft tissue profile, soft tissue convexity) were significantly larger in females, while 18 linear measurements were significantly greater in males, particularly anterior and posterior facial heights.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Bias: The study sample was drawn from southwestern China, and the findings may not be fully generalizable to other populations due to potential influences of climate and genetics. Future research should include diverse regional groups.
  • Diagnostic Sample Bias: The cephalograms were collected from patients undergoing orthodontic treatment, meaning some subjects might have underlying maxillary or mandibular structures requiring correction. Future studies could benefit from analyzing randomly selected individuals without orthodontic needs.

The authors suggest that further investigations into craniofacial parameters of random individuals would be beneficial. They also highlight the potential of their findings for sex determination and estimation, which has applications in forensic science.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study aimed to investigate sex differences in craniomaxillofacial parameters in children and adolescents. Lateral cephalograms were obtained from 340 subjects (141 male, 199 female) aged 6 to 18 years, and their craniofacial characteristics and cervical vertebral maturity were assessed using the quantitative cervical vertebral maturity (QCVM) method. Age-based stratified analyses on craniofacial parameters and further comparison in QCVM Ⅲ subjects were performed. Among all analyses, male subjects had significantly greater value than females in sex-different parameters except for facial convexity. The overall group had 17 sex-different parameters (ramus height, anterior facial height (AFH), posterior facial height (PFH), upper anterior facial height (UAFH), lower anterior facial height (LAFH), anterior cranial base length, posterior cranial base length, facial convexity, upper lip length, upper lip thickness, lower lip thickness, soft tissue chin thickness, nasion of soft tissue-subnasale (N'-Sn), subnasale-menton of soft tissue (Sn-Me'), subnasale-stomion inferius (Sn-Sto)). The <12 years old group showed 6 significant sex differences (AFH, LAFH, lower lip protrusion, lower lip thickness, N'-Sn, Sn-Me'). While the ≥12 years old group occurred two more parameters (mandibular body length, AFH/PFH) than the overall group. 12 cephalometric parameters had significant sex differences among QCMV III patients. After age adjustment, the number of sex-different parameters only increased in soft tissue. Craniofacial characteristics and cervical vertebrae maturation of the youngsters exhibited significant sex differences. Though females reached an earlier cervical vertebral maturation, they still had smaller craniofacial linear features. Sex differences should be taken into account in developing reference standards for cephalometric measurements and treatment planning in the clinic.
BibTeX
@article{gu2024sex,
  author = {Tao Gu and Shiyong Zhang and Chuqiao Xiao and Shoushan Hu and Xin Xiong},
  title = {{Sex differences in craniofacial parameters of children and adolescents: a comparative study with the maturation of cervical vertebrae using a cephalometric method}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.22514/jocpd.2024.129},
}
Figure