Abstract
In cognitive radio networks (CRNs), secondary users (SUs) can proactively obtain spectrum access opportunities by helping with primary users' (PUs') data transmissions. Currently, such kind of spectrum access is implemented via a cooperative communications based link-level frame-based cooperative (LLC) approach where individual SUs independently serve as relays for PUs in order to gain spectrum access opportunities. Unfortunately, this LLC approach cannot fully exploit spectrum access opportunities to enhance the throughput of CRNs and fails to motivate PUs to join the spectrum sharing processes. To address these challenges, we propose a network-level session-based cooperative (NLC) approach where SUs are grouped together to cooperate with PUs session by session, instead of frame by frame as what has been done in existing works, for spectrum access opportunities of the corresponding group. Thanks to our group-based session-by-session cooperating strategy, our NLC approach is able to address all those challenges in the LLC approach. To articulate our NLC approach, we further develop an NLC scheme under a cognitive capacity harvesting network (CCHN) architecture. We formulate the cooperative mechanism design as a cross-layer optimization problem with constraints on primary session selection, flow routing and link scheduling. To search for solutions to the optimization problem, we propose an augmented scheduling index ordering based (SIO-based) algorithm to identify maximal independent sets. Through extensive simulations, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed NLC approach and the superiority of the augmented SIO-based algorithm over the traditional method.
Introduction
In Cognitive Radio Networks (CRNs), unlicensed "Secondary Users" (SUs) can access licensed spectrum bands when the licensed "Primary Users" (PUs) are not utilizing them. A common method to facilitate this is through cooperation: SUs act as relays to accelerate PU data transmission, and in exchange, SUs utilize the saved time for their own traffic.
Traditionally, this has been executed via a Link-Level Frame-based Cooperative (LLC) approach. However, LLC suffers from two major drawbacks. First, it lacks PU incentive; speeding up a single frame does not necessarily reduce the end-to-end delivery time of a full file transfer, leaving PUs with little reason to cooperate. Second, it leads to inefficient resource use, as individual SUs act selfishly, hoarding earned spectrum for themselves rather than optimizing for the network as a whole.
The Network-Level Session-Based Cooperative (NLC) Approach
To overcome the limitations of LLC, this paper proposes a Network-Level Session-Based Cooperative (NLC) scheme. This approach shifts the focus from individual, selfish devices to a coordinated network infrastructure operating on a Cognitive Capacity Harvesting Network (CCHN) architecture.
In this model, a Secondary Service Provider (SSP) deploys Base Stations and Cognitive Radio (CR) routers. Instead of frame-by-frame relaying, the SSP manages entire PU data sessions. By promising to deliver a PU's complete session in a fraction of its scheduled time, the SSP earns the remaining time as a bulk spectrum access opportunity for the entire group of SUs. This centralized coordination allows the network to pool earned spectrum and route SU traffic optimally across the infrastructure.
Cross-Layer Optimization and the Augmented SIO Algorithm
The NLC mechanism is formulated as a cross-layer optimization problem that jointly considers primary session selection, flow routing, and link scheduling to maximize total network throughput. A critical challenge in this optimization is identifying which wireless links can transmit simultaneously without interference, a task represented by finding Maximal Independent Sets (MISs) on a conflict graph.
Because the interference map changes dynamically based on which PU sessions the network chooses to assist, the authors developed an Augmented Scheduling Index Ordering (SIO) algorithm. Unlike traditional static methods, this algorithm pre-computes MISs for various combinations of PU session selections, allowing the system to find an optimal schedule even as the underlying conflict graph shifts.
Key Results and Insights
Extensive computer simulations of a grid-topology network (24 CR routers, 1 Base Station, and 5 primary sessions) demonstrate the following:
- Throughput Gains: The NLC approach achieved throughput approximately 2x to 3x higher than the traditional LLC approach.
- PU Latency Reduction: NLC significantly reduced completion times for primary sessions. For instance, a session requiring 60 seconds under LLC was completed in only 10 to 25 seconds under NLC.
- Algorithm Performance: The Augmented SIO algorithm maintained high throughput (~0.8 Mbps) even with large primary data volumes, whereas baseline methods saw throughput drop toward zero under similar conditions.
Conclusion
By transitioning from frame-based to session-based cooperation and employing network-level coordination, the NLC approach provides a genuine win-win incentive for both primary and secondary users. While future work is needed to address multi-channel environments and inter-provider information sharing, the NLC framework represents a significant step toward more efficient and cooperative spectrum management.
Summary updated