Sequential Recommender Systems: Challenges, Progress and Prospects

Shoujin Wang, Liang Hu, Yan Wang, Longbing Cao, Quan Z. Sheng, Mehmet A. Orgun

Abstract

The emerging topic of sequential recommender systems (SRSs) has attracted increasing attention in recent years. Different from conventional recommender systems including collaborative filtering and content-based filtering, SRSs try to understand and model sequential user behaviors, the interactions between users and items, and the evolution of user preferences and item popularity over time. SRSs involve these aspects for more precise characterization of user contexts, intent, and goals, leading to more accurate, customized, and dynamic recommendations. This paper provides a systematic review of SRSs, presenting their characteristics, summarizing key challenges, and discussing research progress and future directions.

Introduction: The Shift to Sequential Modeling

Traditional recommender systems (RSs), such as standard collaborative filtering, often treat user-item interactions as a static "bag of items." While effective at identifying general associations (e.g., users who bought a camera also bought a tripod), they struggle to capture the chronological order or the underlying intent behind a series of actions.

Real-world interactions are inherently sequential. For instance, booking a flight typically precedes booking a hotel, which in turn precedes renting a car. Furthermore, user preferences are dynamic; tastes in technology or fashion evolve over time. Sequential Recommender Systems (SRSs) address these limitations by modeling temporal dependencies to provide context-aware, "next-step" recommendations that reflect the user's current journey.

A Taxonomy of SRS Approaches

The technical evolution of SRSs can be categorized into three major paradigms, moving from foundational statistical methods to complex neural architectures.

  1. Traditional Sequence Models: These include Sequential Pattern Mining and Markov Chain models. While intuitive, they often face "state-space explosion" or are limited by the Markov property, which only captures very short-term dependencies.
  2. Latent Representation Models: These utilize Factorization Machines or Embeddings to map users and items into a high-dimensional latent space, capturing complex, implicit relationships beyond simple transaction counts.
  3. Deep Neural Network Models: This represents the current state-of-the-art, utilizing various architectures:
  4. RNNs (LSTM/GRU): Suited for sequences but can be overly rigid in assuming strict point-to-point dependencies.
  5. CNNs: Treat embedding matrices as images to learn local patterns regardless of strict order.
  6. GNNs: Model interactions as graphs to capture complex transitions and provide explainable recommendation paths.
  7. Advanced Modules: Incorporate Attention mechanisms to filter noise and Memory Networks to explicitly store long-term history.
Taxonomy of SRS approaches, categorizing traditional, latent representation, and deep neural network models.

Key Challenges and Solutions

The effectiveness of an SRS depends on how well it handles specific data characteristics. The research identifies several core challenges:

  • Flexible vs. Strict Order: Not all sequences are rigid. For example, the order of buying groceries like milk and bread is often interchangeable. CNN-based models are particularly effective here as they do not assume strict sequentiality.
  • Handling Noise: Users often interact with items accidentally or out of curiosity. Attention models are vital for "discriminative" learning, focusing on interactions that signal true intent while downplaying outliers.
  • Collective and Long-term Dependencies: A user's next action might depend on a combination of several previous actions rather than just the most recent one. Deep learning models, particularly those with memory components or hierarchical structures, excel at capturing these higher-order dependencies.
Summary of data characteristics in SRSs, the challenges they present, and the corresponding existing solutions.

Progress and Future Prospects

The field is rapidly converging toward Deep Learning. While Markov Chains remain efficient for low-data scenarios, they cannot match the accuracy of RNNs, GNNs, and Attention-based models in large-scale, complex environments. Integration of mixture models, which combine short-term and long-term encoders, has shown significant performance gains in recent literature.

Looking forward, several frontiers remain:

  • Context and Social Awareness: Integrating environmental factors (time, location) and social network data to refine sequential predictions.
  • Interactivity: Transitioning to conversational systems that handle multi-step feedback loops.
  • Cross-Domain Dependencies: Understanding how actions in one domain (e.g., buying a car) influence sequences in another (e.g., insurance).

This systematic review underscores the shift from static snapshots to dynamic, sequence-aware modeling as the future of personalized recommendation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The emerging topic of sequential recommender systems has attracted increasing attention in recent years.Different from the conventional recommender systems including collaborative filtering and content-based filtering, SRSs try to understand and model the sequential user behaviors, the interactions between users and items, and the evolution of users preferences and item popularity over time. SRSs involve the above aspects for more precise characterization of user contexts, intent and goals, and item consumption trend, leading to more accurate, customized and dynamic recommendations.In this paper, we provide a systematic review on SRSs.We first present the characteristics of SRSs, and then summarize and categorize the key challenges in this research area, followed by the corresponding research progress consisting of the most recent and representative developments on this topic.Finally, we discuss the important research directions in this vibrant area.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019sequential,
  author = {Shoujin Wang and Liang Hu and Yan Wang and Longbing Cao and Quan Z. Sheng and Mehmet A. Orgun},
  title = {{Sequential Recommender Systems: Challenges, Progress and Prospects}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=jwVfarC1cYg},
}
Figure