Sensitive radio-frequency read-out of quantum dots using an ultra-low-noise SQUID amplifier

Felix J. Schupp, Florian Vigneau, Yutian Wen, Aquila Mavalankar, Jonathan Griffiths, G. A. C. Jones, I. Farrer, D. A. Ritchie, Charles G. Smith, Leon C. Camenzind, Liuqi Yu, Dominik M. Zumbühl, G. Andrew D. Briggs, Natalia Ares, E. A. LairdLancaster 2020

TL;DR

Researchers have significantly improved the sensitivity of radio-frequency (RF) readout for quantum dots by incorporating a Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID) amplifier. This novel setup achieves a record capacitance sensitivity, paving the way for faster and more accurate qubit readout crucial for fault-tolerant quantum computing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Building a fault-tolerant quantum computer hinges on our ability to accurately and quickly read out the state of individual qubits. For electron spin qubits, a promising approach is radio-frequency (RF) reflectometry. This technique relies on detecting tiny changes in the quantum capacitance of a quantum dot as its spin state flips. However, existing methods, often using cryogenic semiconductor amplifiers, lack the necessary sensitivity for high-fidelity, single-shot readout. This limitation hinders the speed and accuracy of quantum computations. The paper addresses this gap by demonstrating how to dramatically enhance this sensitivity using a SQUID preamplifier.

Methods

The core innovation lies in supplementing a standard cryogenic RF reflectometry setup with a low-noise SQUID amplifier. The SQUID, operating at around 200 MHz, acts as a preamplifier, boosting the weak signal from the quantum dot before it's further amplified by a conventional semiconductor amplifier. This two-stage amplification significantly reduces the overall noise floor.

The researchers meticulously characterized the SQUID amplifier's gain and noise temperature by carefully tuning its bias currents and flux offset. They then integrated this optimized SQUID into a reflectometry circuit connected to a quantum dot device. The capacitance sensitivity was measured using a variable capacitor (varactor) and then by observing charge stability diagrams of a double quantum dot. The key metrics evaluated were capacitance sensitivity ($S_C$) and charge sensitivity ($S_{AQ}$).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SQUID Amplifiers for RF Quantum Dot Readout: The paper demonstrates that SQUID amplifiers, typically used at microwave frequencies, can be effectively employed at RF frequencies (around 200 MHz) for quantum dot readout, offering a substantial improvement in sensitivity.
  • Record Capacitance Sensitivity: By combining a SQUID preamplifier with RF reflectometry, the researchers achieved a record capacitance sensitivity of $0.07 \text{ aF}/\sqrt{\text{Hz}}$, a 23-fold improvement over previous setups. This level of sensitivity is crucial for resolving the small capacitance changes associated with qubit states.
  • Fast Charge Stability Diagrams: The enhanced sensitivity enabled the rapid acquisition of charge stability diagrams for a double quantum dot, taking only 20 ms for a 100x100 pixel map. This speed is vital for efficient quantum dot tuning and characterization.
  • Near Quantum Limit Performance: The SQUID amplifier achieved a noise temperature below 600 mK, which is remarkably close to the quantum limit for this frequency range, indicating highly efficient signal amplification with minimal added noise.
  • Single-Shot Readout Potential: The demonstrated sensitivity suggests that single-shot readout of spin qubits could be achieved in under a microsecond, a critical requirement for fault-tolerant quantum computing architectures.

Key Results

  • Capacitance Sensitivity: A record capacitance sensitivity of $S_C = 0.07 \pm 0.02 \text{ aF}/\sqrt{\text{Hz}}$ was achieved.
  • SQUID Noise Temperature: The SQUID amplifier exhibited a noise temperature below 600 mK.
  • Charge Stability Diagram Acquisition: A 100x100 pixel charge stability diagram was acquired in 20 ms.
  • Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR): An SNR of approximately 38 was achieved in 1 µs of integration time for distinguishing qubit states.
  • Charge Sensitivity: For a single quantum dot charge sensor, a charge sensitivity of $S_{AQ} = 60 \pm 20 \text{ µe}/\sqrt{\text{Hz}}$ was measured.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while the SQUID amplifier's noise temperature is impressive, it's still a factor of 120 away from the quantum limit. They also note that the amplifier's dynamic range was somewhat limited, potentially due to impedance matching issues between the SQUID and the 50Ω circuitry.

Future work could focus on further optimizing impedance matching to push the amplifier closer to its theoretical limits. Additionally, exploring higher operating frequencies or different SQUID designs could be beneficial for specific qubit modalities. The demonstrated capability for fast and sensitive readout opens doors for improved quantum error correction schemes and more efficient characterization of quantum devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fault-tolerant spin-based quantum computers will require fast and accurate qubit readout. This can be achieved using radio-frequency reflectometry given sufficient sensitivity to the change in quantum capacitance associated with the qubit states. Here, we demonstrate a 23-fold improvement in capacitance sensitivity by supplementing a cryogenic semiconductor amplifier with a SQUID preamplifier. The SQUID amplifier operates at a frequency near 200 MHz and achieves a noise temperature below 600 mK when integrated into a reflectometry circuit, which is within a factor 120 of the quantum limit. It enables a record sensitivity to capacitance of 0.07 aF/√Hz. The setup is used to acquire charge stability diagrams of a gate-defined double quantum dot in a short time with a signal-to-noise ration of about 38 in 1 µs of integration time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{schupp2020sensitive,
  author = {Felix J. Schupp and Florian Vigneau and Yutian Wen and Aquila Mavalankar and Jonathan Griffiths and G. A. C. Jones and I. Farrer and D. A. Ritchie and Charles G. Smith and Leon C. Camenzind and Liuqi Yu and Dominik M. Zumbühl and G. Andrew D. Briggs and Natalia Ares and E. A. Laird},
  title = {{Sensitive radio-frequency read-out of quantum dots using an ultra-low-noise SQUID amplifier}},
  booktitle = {Lancaster},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure